Non-Classical Crystallization of Bulk Crystals in Solution and of Thin Films in the Gas Phase by Chemical Vapor Deposition

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Although non-classical crystallization is a relatively revolutionary concept, where a building block for crystallization is neither an atom nor an ion but a nanoparticle, it has become so much established now that numerous papers as well as several books were published and its tutorial and technical sessions were included in international conferences. The purpose of this paper is to review how non-classical crystallization was developed in solution and in the gas phase synthesis of films by chemical vapor deposition (CVD). Findings made in the study of non-classical crystallization in solution turn out to be very useful in understanding of non-classical crystallization of thin films by CVD. Similarly, findings made in the study of non-classical crystallization of thin films by CVD would be useful in understanding of non-classical crystallization of bulk crystals in solution. Therefore, it is synergistic to review non-classical crystallization both in solution and in the gas phase.
For example, the presence of charge in nanoparticles is hardly mentioned in non-classical crystallization in solution whereas it is clearly revealed by the current measurement in the gas phase synthesis of thin films by CVD. The building block in non-classical crystallization is not simply a nanoparticle but a charged nanoparticle (CNP). Many evidences indicate that charged nanoparticles (CNPs) should be liquid-like or superplastic and this property changes abruptly with their charging state and size.

참고문헌 (Reference)

• 1 Nunomura, S., "situ simple method for measuring size and density of nanoparticles in reactive plasmas" 99 (99): 083302-, 2006
• 2 Stranski, I., "Zur theorie des kristallwachstums" 136 : 259-278, 1928
• 3 P.M Ajayan, "Wetting and de-wetting transitions of small metal particles on substrates under electron irradiation" Elsevier BV 147 (147): 281-285, 1991
• 4 Niu, K. -Y., "Visualization of the coalescence of bismuth nanoparticles" 20 (20): 416-424, 2014
• 5 Hwan-Young Kim, "Various Allotropes of Diamond Nanoparticles Generated in the Gas Phase during Hot Filament Chemical Vapor Deposition" MDPI AG 10 (10): 2504-, 2020
• 6 Yarbrough, W.A., "Vapor-phase-deposited diamond: Problems and potential" 75 (75): 3179-3200, 1992
• 7 Welch, D. A., "Understanding the role of solvation forces on the preferential attachment of nanoparticles in liquid" 10 : 181-187, 2015
• 8 Zhang, Z. -P., "Three-dimensionally oriented aggregation of a few hundred nanoparticles into monocrystalline architectures" 17 (17): 42-47, 2005
• 9 Rutkevych, P., "Thermophoretic control of building units in the plasma-assisted deposition of nanostructured carbon films" 96 (96): 4421-4428, 2004
• 10 Hwang, N.M., "Thermodynamics and kinetics for nucleation of diamond in the chemical vapor deposition process" 1 (1): 191-194, 1992
• 11 Vakil, H., "Thermodynamic and kinetic aspects of CVD diamond growth" 1989
• 12 Yushkin, N., "Theory of the microblock growth of crystals in natural heterogeneous solutions" Inst. Geol. Komi Fil. AN SSSR 1971
• 13 Hyun M. Jang, "Theory of the charged cluster formation in the low pressure synthesis of diamond: Part II. Free energy function and thermodynamic stability" Springer Science and Business Media LLC 13 (13): 3536-3549, 1998
• 14 Hyun M. Jang, "Theory of the charged cluster formation in the low pressure synthesis of diamond: Part I. Charge-induced nucleation" Springer Science and Business Media LLC 13 (13): 3527-3535, 1998
• 15 Abraham Glasner, "The thermal effects of nucleation and crystallization of KBr solutions" Elsevier BV 13-14 : 441-444, 1972
• 16 Chonan, T., "The preparation and characterization of diamond powder by DC arc plasma" 28 (28): L1058-, 1989
• 17 Salvadori, M, "The effect of a graphite holder on diamond synthesis by microwave plasma chemical vapor deposition" 139 (139): 558-560, 1992
• 18 Ichiro, S., "The distinction of natural from synthetic diamonds" 24 (24): 485-499, 1995
• 19 Fedorov, E.S., "The crystallization process" 12 : 1471-, 1915
• 20 A. Glasner, "The crystallization of KCl from aqueous solutions in the presence of lead ions. I. A calorimetric study" Elsevier BV 2 (2): 119-127, 1968
• 21 A. Glasner, "The crystallization of KCl from aqueous solutions in the presence of lead ions" Elsevier BV 6 (6): 135-142, 1970
• 22 Abraham Glasner, "The Thermal Effects of Nucleation and Crystallization of KBr and KCl Solutions. II. The Heat Of Nucleation and the Supersaturated Solution" Wiley 12 (12): 799-816, 1974
• 23 Abraham Glasner, "The Thermal Effects of Nucleation and Crystallization of KBr and KCL Solutions. III. The Heat of Crystallization and the Co-Precipitation of Lead Ions" Wiley 12 (12): 817-826, 1974
• 24 Terashima, K., "Synthesis of high transition temperature superconducting Y-Ba-Cu-O films by radiofrequency plasma flash evaporation" 18 (18): 980-984, 1990
• 25 Howard, W, "Synthesis of diamond powder in acetylene oxygen plasma" 68 (68): 1247-1251, 1990
• 26 Oura, K., "Surface Science: An Introduction" Springer 2013
• 27 Gaubert, P., "Sur la production artificielle de la macle des spinelles dans les cristaux d’azotate de plomb" 19 : 431-434, 1896
• 28 Iijima, S., "Substrate and size effects on the coalescence of small particles" 70 (70): 5138-5140, 1991
• 29 Shiratani, M., "Study on growth processes of particulates in helium-diluted silane rf plasmas using scanning electron microscopy" 65 (65): 1900-1902, 1994
• 30 Sumio Iijima, "Structural instability of ultrafine particles of metals" American Physical Society (APS) 56 (56): 616-619, 1986
• 31 Zhiyong Tang, "Spontaneous Organization of Single CdTe Nanoparticles into Luminescent Nanowires" American Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS) 297 (297): 237-240, 2002
• 32 Rae, H., "Spiral growths on large crystal surfaces" The Royal Society 1954
• 33 Yin, L. -W., "Some aspects of diamond crystal growth at high temperature and high pressure by TEM and SEM" 55 (55): 397-402, 2002
• 34 Iijima, S., "Some Experiments on Structural Instability of Small Particles of Metals, in Microclusters" Springer 186-199, 1987
• 35 Shiratani, M., "Simultaneous in situ measurements of properties of particulates in rf silane plasmas using a polarization-sensitive laser-light-scattering method" 79 (79): 104-109, 1996
• 36 Sugawara, A., "Self-organization of oriented calcium carbonate/polymer composites: effects of a matrix peptide isolated from the exoskeleton of a crayfish" 45 (45): 2876-2879, 2006
• 37 Pacholski, C., "Self-assembly of ZnO:from nanodots to nanorods" 41 (41): 1188-1191, 2002
• 38 Tatarskii V.B., "Rost Kristallov/Growth of Crystals vol. 9" Springer 3-7, 1975
• 39 Chung, Y.-B., "Reduction of amorphous incubation layer by HCl addition during deposition of microcrystalline silicon by hot-wire chemical vapor deposition" 95 (95): 211-214, 2011
• 40 Liao, H. -G., "Real-time imaging of Pt3Fe nanorod growth in solution" 336 (336): 1011-1014, 2012
• 41 Cheng, Q., "Rapid, low-temperature synthesis of nc-Si in high-density, non-equilibrium plasmas:enabling nanocrystallinity at very low hydrogen dilution" 19 (19): 5134-5140, 2009
• 42 Ji Hye Kwon ; Du Yun Kim ; Kun-Su Kim ; Nong Moon Hwang, "Preparation of Highly (002) Oriented Ti Films on a Floating Si (100) Substrate by RF Magnetron Sputtering" 대한금속·재료학회 16 (16): 14-21, 2020
• 43 Terashima, K., "Preparation of superconducting Y-Ba-Cu-O films by a reactive plasma evaporation method" 52 (52): 1274-1276, 1988
• 44 Ostrikov, K., "Plasma-aided nanofabrication: where is the cutting edge?" 40 (40): 2223-, 2007
• 45 Ostrikov, K., "Plasma nanoscience:from nano-solids in plasmas to nano-plasmas in solids" 62 (62): 113-224, 2013
• 46 Cabarrocas, P.R., "Plasma enhanced chemical vapor deposition of silicon thin films for large area electronics" 6 (6): 439-444, 2002
• 47 Cabarrocas, P.R., "Plasma enhanced chemical vapor deposition of amorphous, polymorphous and microcrystalline silicon films" 266 : 31-37, 2000
• 48 Shiratani, M., "Particle growth kinetics in silane RF discharges" 38 (38): 4542-, 1999
• 49 Ivanov, V. K., "Oriented attachment of particles: 100 years of investigations of non-classical crystal growth" 83 (83): 1204-, 2014
• 50 Frank, F., "On the equations of motion of crystal dislocations" 62 (62): 131-, 1949
• 51 Mitura, S.W., "Nucleation of diamond powder particles in an RF methane plasma" 80 (80): 417-424, 1987
• 52 Choi, K., "Nucleation behavior in the presence of charge in the CVD diamond process" 172 (172): 416-425, 1997
• 53 Jae-Soo Jung, "Non-classical crystallization of silicon thin films during hot wire chemical vapor deposition" Elsevier BV 458 : 8-15, 2017
• 54 Hwang, N.M., "Non-Classical Crystallization of Thin Films and Nanostructures in CVD and PVD Processes, vol. 60" Springer 2016
• 55 Levchenko, I., "Nanostructures of various dimensionalities from plasma and neutral fluxes" 40 (40): 2308-, 2007
• 56 Kambara, M., "Nano-composite Si particle formation by plasma spraying for negative electrode of Li ion batteries" 115 (115): 143302-, 2014
• 57 Ichiro, S., "Morphology of natural and synthetic diamond crystals" 303-330, 1984
• 58 R.Lee Penn, "Morphology development and crystal growth in nanocrystalline aggregates under hydrothermal conditions: insights from titania" Elsevier BV 63 (63): 1549-1557, 1999
• 59 Reddy, K.N., "Modern Electrochemistry: An Introduction to an Interdisciplinary Area" Plenum Publishing Corporation 1977
• 60 i Cabarrocas, P. R., "Microcrystalline silicon thin-films grown by plasma enhanced chemical vapour deposition-growth mechanisms and grain size control" 93 : 257-268, 2003
• 61 Cöelfen, H., "Mesocrystals and Nonclassical Crystallization" John Wiley & Sons 2008
• 62 Rajagopalan Krishnan ; Jagannathan Thirumalai ; Arunkumar Kathiravan, "Luminescence and Magnetic Properties of Novel Nanoparticle-Sheathed 3D Micro-Architectures of Fe0.5R0.5(MoO4)1.5:Ln3+ (R = Gd3+, La3+), (Ln = Eu, Tb, Dy) for Bifunctional Application" 대한금속·재료학회 11 (11): 24-33, 2015
• 63 Q. J. Cheng, "Low-Temperature PECVD of Nanodevice-Grade nc-3C-SiC" Wiley 13 (13): 561-566, 2007
• 64 Liao, H. -G., "Liquid cell transmission electron microscopy study of platinum iron nanocrystal growth and shape evolution" 135 (135): 5038-5043, 2013
• 65 Polleux, J., "Liganddirected assembly of preformed titania nanocrystals into highly anisotropic nanostructures" 16 (16): 436-439, 2004
• 66 Volmer. M, "Kinetik Der Phasenbildung" Dresden 1939
• 67 Frenklach, M, "Induced nucleation of diamond powder" 59 (59): 546-548, 1991
• 68 Hong, J.-S., "In-Situ measurements of charged nanoparticles generated during hot wire chemical vapor deposition of silicon using particle beam mass spectrometer" 47 (47): 46-51, 2013
• 69 Chen, X., "In situ wet-cell TEM observation of gold nanoparticle motion in an aqueous solution" 71 : 598-, 2012
• 70 Koga, K., "In situ observation of nucleation and subsequent growth of clusters in silane radio frequency discharges" 77 (77): 196-198, 2000
• 71 Sutter, E., "In situ microscopy of the selfassembly of branched nanocrystals in solution" 7 : 1-7, 2016
• 72 Yuk, J. M., "In situ atomic imaging of coalescence of Au nanoparticles on graphene: rotation and grain boundary migration" 49 (49): 11479-11481, 2013
• 73 Frenklach, M, "Homogeneous nucleation of diamond powder in the gas phase" 66 (66): 395-399, 1989
• 74 Takamura, Y., "Highrate deposition of YBa 2 Cu 3 O 7–x films by hot cluster epitaxy" 84 (84): 5084-5088, 1998
• 75 Iizuka, K., "Highly sensitive SnO2porous film gas sensors fabricated by plasma spray physical vapor deposition" 173 : 455-461, 2012
• 76 Yuk, J. M., "High-resolution EM of colloidal nanocrystal growth using graphene liquid cells" 336 (336): 61-64, 2012
• 77 Homma, K., "High throughput production of nanocomposite SiOx powders by plasma spray physical vapor deposition for negative electrode of lithium ion batteries" 15 (15): 025006-, 2014
• 78 Hwang, N.M., "Growth of silicon nanowires by chemical vapor deposition: approach by charged cluster model" 218 (218): 33-39, 2000
• 79 Botsaris, G., "Growth of potassium chloride crystals from aqueous solutions. I. The effect of lead chloride" 45 (45): 1893-1899, 1966
• 80 A. Glasner, "Growth of Potassium Chloride Crystals from Aqueous Solutions. I. The Effect of Lead Chloride" AIP Publishing 47 (47): 3687-3689, 1967
• 81 Ichiro Sunagawa, "Growth and morphology of diamond crystals under stable and metastable contitions" Elsevier BV 99 (99): 1156-1161, 1990
• 82 Kim, C.-S., "Generation of charged nanoparticles during the synthesis of carbon nanotubes by chemical vapor deposition" 47 (47): 2511-2518, 2009
• 83 Daseul Kim ; Du Yun Kim ; Ji Hye Kwon ; Kun‑Su Kim ; Nong‑Moon Hwang, "Generation of Charged SiC Nanoparticles During HWCVD Process" 대한금속·재료학회 16 (16): 498-505, 2020
• 84 Jin-Woo Park, "Gas phase generation of diamond nanoparticles in the hot filament chemical vapor deposition reactor" Elsevier BV 106 : 289-294, 2016
• 85 Hahn, J. H., "Formation of soot or diamond on the iron substrate in the chemical vapour deposition process of diamond" 15 (15): 1240-1242, 1996
• 86 Watanabe, Y., "Formation kinetics and control of dust particles in capacitively-coupled reactive plasmas" (T89) : 29-, 2001
• 87 Imai, Y., "Formation energies of two-dimensional nuclei randomly-generated on (001), (110), and (111) planes of a face-centered-cubic crystal" 300 (300): 305-313, 1997
• 88 Sugimoto, T., "Formation Mechanism of Monodispersed ͣ-Fe2O3Particles in Dilute FeCl3Solutions" 184 (184): 626-638, 1996
• 89 Shinozawa, A., "Featherlike structured YSZ coatings at fast rates by plasma spray physical vapor deposition" 19 (19): 190-197, 2010
• 90 M. Muruganandham ; Rominder P.S. Suri ; Mika Sillanpää ; Gang-Juan Lee ; Jerry J. Wu, "Facile Synthesis of Self-Assembled Biporous NiO and its Electrochemical Properties" 대한금속·재료학회 12 (12): 693-701, 2016
• 91 Nunomura, S., "Fabrication of nanoparticle composite porous films having ultralow dielectric constant" 44 (44): L1509-, 2005
• 92 Kossel, W., "Extending the law of Bravais" Nachrichten von der Gesellschaft der Wissenschaften zu Göttingen 135-143, 1927
• 93 Jeon, J.-D., "Experimental confirmation of charged carbon clusters in the hot filament diamond reactor" 213 (213): 79-82, 2000
• 94 Hwang, N.M., "Evidence of nanometer-sized charged carbon clusters in the gas phase of the diamond chemical vapor deposition (CVD) process" 204 (204): 85-90, 1999
• 95 Shiratani, M., "Effects of gas temperature gradient, pulse discharge modulation, and hydrogen dilution on particle growth in silane RF discharges" 39 (39): 287-, 2000
• 96 Yoo, S. -W, "Effect of substrate bias on deposition behaviour of charged silicon nanoparticles in ICP-CVD process" 50 (50): 035201-, 2016
• 97 Jeon, I.-D., "Effect of methane concentration on size of charged clusters in the hot filament diamond CVD process" 223 (223): 6-14, 2001
• 98 B. W. Clare, "Effect of charge on bond strength in hydrogenated amorphous silicon" Wiley 15 (15): 644-652, 1994
• 99 Lee, S. -H, "Effect of HCl addition on the properties of p-type silicon thin films during hot-wire chemical vapor deposition" 54 : 85-90, 2013
• 100 Yoonjung Lee ; Heung Nam Han ; 김웅식 ; Nong Moon Hwang, "Effect of Bipolar Charging of SiH4 on the Growth Rate and Crystallinity of Silicon Films Grown in the Atmospheric Pressure Chemical Vapor Deposition Process" 대한금속·재료학회 16 (16): 385-395, 2020
• 101 Soon-won Park, "Effect of Bias Applied to the Substrate on the Low Temperature Growth of Silicon Epitaxial Films during RF-PECVD" American Chemical Society (ACS) 18 (18): 5816-5823, 2018
• 102 Vladimirov, S. V., "Dynamic self-organization phenomena in complex ionized gas systems: new paradigms and technological aspects" 393 (393): 175-380, 2004
• 103 Qijin Cheng, "Deterministic plasma-aided synthesis of high-quality nanoislanded nc-SiC films" AIP Publishing 90 (90): 173112-, 2007
• 104 Hwang, N.M., "Deposition behavior of Si on insulating and conducting substrates in the CVD process: approach by charged cluster model" 206 (206): 177-186, 1999
• 105 Hwang, N.M., "Deposition and simultaneous etching of Si in the chemical vapor deposition (CVD) process: approach by the charged cluster model" 205 (205): 59-63, 1999
• 106 Gil Su Jang ; Du Yun Kim ; Nong-Moon Hwang, "Dependence of the Generation Behavior of Charged Nanoparticles and Ag Film Growth on Sputtering Power during DC Magnetron Sputtering" 대한금속·재료학회 17 (17): 172-180, 2021
• 107 Badzian, A. R, "Crystallization of diamond crystals and films by microwave assisted CVD (Part II)" 23 (23): 531-548, 1988
• 108 Berg, W., "Crystal growth from solutions" The Royal Society 1938
• 109 Bunn, C., "Crystal growth from solution. II. Concentration gradients and the rates of growth of crystals" 5 : 132-144, 1949
• 110 Bunn, C., "Crystal growth from solution. I. Layer formation on crystal faces" 5 : 119-132, 1949
• 111 Hwang, N.M., "Crystal growth by charged cluster focused on CVD diamond process" 198 : 945-950, 1999
• 112 Cabarrocas, P. R., "Critical issues in plasma deposition of microcrystalline silicon for thin film transistors" 52 (52): 422-426, 2008
• 113 Jin, R., "Controlling anisotropic nanoparticle growth through plasmon excitation" 425 (425): 487-, 2003
• 114 Jianmin Gu ; Baipeng Yin ; Shaoyan Fu ; Cuihong Jin ; Xin Liu ; Zhenpan Bian ; Jianjun Li ; Lu Wang ; Xiaoyu Li, "Controlled self-assembly of low-dimensional Alq3 nanostructures from 1D nanowires to 2D plates via intermolecular interactions" 대한금속·재료학회 14 (14): 181-186, 2018
• 115 Lili Liu, "Connecting energetics to dynamics in particle growth by oriented attachment using real-time observations" Springer Science and Business Media LLC 11 (11): 2020
• 116 Soon-won Park ; Gil-su Jang ; Kun-Su Kim ; Nong Moon Hwang, "Comparison of Plasma Efect on Dewetting Kinetics of Sn Films Between Grounded and Floating Substrates" 대한금속·재료학회 16 (16): 72-80, 2020
• 117 Woong-Kyu Youn, "Comparison of the Deposition Behavior of Charged Silicon Nanoparticles between Floating and Grounded Substrates" American Chemical Society (ACS) 118 (118): 11946-11953, 2014
• 118 Hwan-Young Kim, "Comparison of diamond nanoparticles captured on the floating and grounded membranes in the hot filament chemical vapor deposition process" Royal Society of Chemistry (RSC) 11 (11): 5651-5657, 2021
• 119 Botsaris, G., "Comments on the letter by Glasner and Skurnik entitled growth of potassium chloride crystals from aqueous solutions. I. The effect of lead chloride" 47 (47): 3689-3690, 1967
• 120 Ostrikov, K., "Colloquium: reactive plasmas as a versatile nanofabrication tool" 77 (77): 489-, 2005
• 121 Hwang, N.M., "Chemical potential of carbon in the low pressure synthesis of diamond" 160 (160): 87-97, 1996
• 122 Hwang, N.-M., "Charged nanoparticles in thin film and nanostructure growth by chemical vapour deposition" 43 (43): 483001-, 2010
• 123 Nong-Moon Hwang, "Charged clusters in thin film growth" Informa UK Limited 49 (49): 171-190, 2004
• 124 Hwang, N.M., "Charged cluster model in the low pressure synthesis of diamond" 162 (162): 55-68, 1996
• 125 Hwang, N. -M., "Charged cluster model as a new paradigm of crystal growth" 1 (1): 34-44, 2000
• 126 Ueda, M., "Change in microstructure of an aqueous citric acid solution under crystallization" 156 (156): 261-266, 1995
• 127 Mann, S., "Biomineralization:Chemical and Biochemical Perspectives" John Wiley & Sons 1989
• 128 Mann, S., "Biomineralization: Principles and Concepts in Bioinorganic Materials Chemistry" Oxford University Press on Demand 2001
• 129 Niederberger, M., "An iron polyolate complex as a precursor for the controlled synthesis of monodispersed iron oxide colloids" 14 (14): 78-82, 2002
• 130 Beniash, E., "Amorphous calcium carbonate transforms into calcite during sea urchin larval spicule growth" 264 (264): 461-465, 1997
• 131 Glasner, A., "A new mechanism for the crystallization and growth of ionic crystals, with special reference to KCl in the presence of Pb2+ ions" 6 : 69-72, 1968
• 132 A. Glasner, "A New Mechanism for the Crystallization and Growth of Ionic Crystals, with Special Reference to KCl in the Presence of Pb²⁺Ions." Wiley 6 (6): 69-72, 1968