EU의 가스 정책의 딜렘마와 탈근대적 대안 모색 : 대 러시아 가스 정책을 중심으로 = Dilemmas in EU's Gas Policy and Search for De-Modern Alternatives : Centering on EU's Gas Policy to Russia

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

The European Commission(EC) has tried to proceed the three main gas policies of internal energy market, security of energy supply, and climate changes simultaneously for 20 years without any fundamental change except for reordering the highest top priority among themselves. In the present, given the aggravation of security of energy supply and climate change, EC has put more emphasis on these two issues with the internal gas market still remaining in the list of the highest priorities. However many experts and concerned people estimate the EC's policies "unsuccessful, even consumptive" The EC's failure in achieving its goals could be attributed partially to ambiguities of objectives in EC's directives, institutional differences between Anglo-Saxon economic model and socio-economical model, and euro-centric gas cooperation policies, etc.
This study suggests that EU gas agents, including EC and each EU member state, engage in energy policy-making and industry from the de-modern viewpoints, especially René Girard's theory of 'mimetic desire' and the gift theory in the Christian sense. From such de-modern viewpoints, the EC's previous concept of 'security of gas supply' focused on market function and supply sector might be changed into more comprehensive meaning, which would cover all political and social contexts relevant to gas transaction and all stages from gas exploration to gas consumption, supply and demand. In addition, EU had better transform its euro-centric attitude to non-EU gas exporting countries into an ethical one of other-respect and understanding. The EU's alternative gas policies in accordance with gift theory would give EU more chances to improve not only its energy security and economical competitiveness, but also its ethical, cultural, political, and social status at the global dimension.

참고문헌 (Reference)

• 1 홍승표, "통일체적 세계관과 새로운 유토피아의 모색" 25 (25): 2006
• 2 에너지경제연구원, "주간 해외에너지정책 동향"
• 3 백훈, "유럽연합의 에너지협력정책: 동북아에 주는 교훈" 2007
• 4 도현재, "에너지경제연구원 기본연구보고 06-07" 19,175-22,184, 2006
• 5 송현호, "신제도이론" 민음사 16-17, 2004
• 6 이경완, "신자유주의적 세계화와 러시아의 자원 민족주의: 러시아-EU의 새로운 에너지 협력 방안 모색" 17 (17): 2007
• 7 윌리엄 엥달, "석유 지정학이 파헤친 20세기 세계사의 진실: 영국과 미국의 세계 지배체제와 그 메커니즘" 길 19-21, 2007
• 8 김진식, "르네 지라르에 의지한 경제논리 비판" lUUP(울산대학교 출판부 2005
• 9 "“Will gas OPEC have final say on pipeline plans?” http://en.rian.ru/analysis/20080430/106256668.html"
• 10 "“Trans-European Energy Networks", http://europa.eu/scadplus/leg/en/lvb/127066.htm"
• 11 "“Capgemini Launches the Ninth Edition Energy Markets Observatory(EEMO) Report," Capgemini. 2007.? http://www.uk.capgemini.com/news/pr/pr1584"
• 12 "“Algeria keen on establishing "Gas OPEC"," http://www.afrol.com/articles/24865"
• 13 "Миллер: российский рынок является приоритетным для Газпрома” http://www.oilcapital.ru/news/2008/06/071559_125100.shtml"
• 14 Милов, В, "Итоги 2007 года для энергетики России"
• 15 Kahn, J. S, "Towards a History of the Critique of Economism: The Nineteenth-Century German Origins of the Ethnographer's Dilemma" 25 : 235-241, 1990
• 16 Helm,?D, "The Russian Dimension and Europe's External Energy Policy"
• 17 Bialasiewicz, L, "The New Geopolitics of Division and the Problem of a Kantian Europe" 32 : 2006
• 18 Eberlein, B, "The Making of the European Energy Market: The Interplay of Governance and Government," Jnl Publ. Pol. 28"
• 19 Johnstone, B.D, "The Ethics of the Gift: Aquinas, Derrida, Marion" 3 : 2004
• 20 Vinois, J.A, "Security of Gas Supply: Gas Coordination Group" 2008
• 21 Wallander,C.A, "Russian Transimperialism"
• 22 Arbatova, N, "Russia-EU beyond 2007. Russian Domestic Debates" 5-7, 2007
• 23 Milov, V, "Russia-EU Energy Dialogue: Falling a Vacuum" 4 : 2007
• 24 Shapiro. M.J, "Reading "Adam Smith": Desire, History, and Value SAGE Publications"
• 25 Gomart, T, "Quelle place pour la Russie en Europe?" 27 : 2007
• 26 Rutledge, I, "New Labour, Energy Policy and 'Competitive Markets" 31 : 2007
• 27 Creti, A, "Long-term contracts and take-or-pay clauses in natural gas markets" 13 (13): 2-3, 2003
• 28 "Final report on the Green Paper “Towards a European strategy for the security of energy supply," Com(2002) 321 final (Brussels: Commission of the European Communities, 2002)"
• 29 European Council, "European Council Action Plan(2007-2009)," Presidency Conclusions, Brussels,http://www.eruopa-eu-un.org/articles/en/articla_6836_en.htm"
• 30 Youngs, R, "Europe's External Energy Policy: Between Geopolitics and the Market" 278 : 14-15, 2007
• 31 "Energy and Conflict Prevention, ed. by A. Greg and Marie-Ange Schellekens-Gaiffe, Madariaga European Foundation, etc"
• 32 Austin, G, "Energy Sovereignty and Security: Restoring Confidence in a Cooperative International System"
• 33 "Energy Policy for Europe: Identifying the European Added-Value, CEPS Task Force Report, Centre for European Policy Studies"
• 34 "Energy Policy for Europe: Identifying the European Added-Value, CEPS Task Force Report (Centre for Euoprean Policy Studies: 2008)"
• 35 에너지경제연구원, "EU 에너지 정책"
• 36 이경완, "EU 가스 정책을 둘러싼 역내 가스 주체들간의 갈등: EU 집행위와 독일간의 갈등을 중심으로" 15 (15): 115-119, 2008
• 37 Stein, I, "EU Energy Policy vis-?vis Algeria: Challenges and Opportunities" 2008
• 38 P.D. Cameron, "Competition and Investment in EU Energy Markets in the Light of the 3rd Energy Package 6th Workshop on EU Energy Law and Policy, organized by Professor P.D. Cameron"
• 39 Valentin, A. B, "An Institutional Framework for a More Efficient Use of Natural Resource" 22 : 1-2, 2007
• 40 Williams, G. M, ""Truth Overlooked: The Legacy of List." 2000. http://members.aol.com/BevinSoc/FriedrichList.html"
• 41 Cavaliere, A, ""The Liberalization of Natural Gas Markets: Regulatory Reform and Competitive Failures in Italy," NG 20, Oxford Institute for Energy Studies"
• 42 Darbouche, H, ""Russian-Algerian cooperation and the gas OPEC? What's in the pipeline?," CEPS, Policy Brief"
• 43 Zagorski, A, ""Russia and Germany: Continuity and Changes" IFRI 6 : 2005
• 44 Godzimirski, J. M, ""Pipelines and Identities. Current European Debate on Energy Security, Shtokman and NEGP Case," Energy and Conflict Prevention"
• 45 Jessop, B, ""Liberalism, Neoliberalism, and Urban Governance: A State-Theoretical젨 Perspective," Antipode (Blackwell Publishers, 2002)"
• 46 Szabo, S, ""Is There a West?," The Globalist"
• 47 Havard, J, ""International Gas Markets - Supply & Competing Demand," BERR"
• 48 Egenhofer, C, ""Integrating Security of Supply, Market Liberalisation and Climate Change," European Energy Security: What Should it Mean? What to do?, CEPS, ISS & DCAF"
• 49 Cohen, A, ""Europe's Strategic Dependence on Russian “Trans-European Energy Networks", http://europa.eu/scadplus/leg/en/lvb/127066.htm"
• 50 Kagan, R, ""End of Dreams, Return of History: International Rivalry and American Leadership," Policy Review"
• 51 Mabey, N, ""Beyond Zero-Sum Politics: Frameworks for delivering Energy and Climate Security in the Asia Pacific Region," Energy and Conflict Preventio"
• 52 Pearson, P. O, ""Algeria Oil Min: Won't Sign More Long-Term Gas Supply Deals" http://www.zawya.com/Story.cfm/sidZW20080414000144"
• 53 Heinz, D, ""A Review of EU-Russian Relations: Added Value of Structurally Deficient?," Discussion paper 177"