음악 청취 시 나타나는 음악적 몰입 연구에 대한 고찰: 플로우(Flow) 이론을 중심으로 = Understanding Musical Flow during Music Listening Based on Empirical Observations

국문 초록 (Abstract)

음악적 몰입은 음악 청취, 악기 연주 등의 음악 활동에 참여하는 동안 음악에 깊게 집중하고 있는 심리적 상태를 의미한다. 특히 음악을 청취하는 동안 나타나는 몰입은 청취자로 하여금 긍정적인 감정을 경험하게 하며, 이때 몰입을 자주 경험하는 사람일수록 주관적 행복감이 높은 것으로 나타났다. 그렇다면 음악 청취 시 나타나는 음악적 몰입 상태를 어떻게 규정할 수 있으며, 청취자가 몰입을 경험하고 있다는 것을 확인할 수 있는 방법에는 무엇이 있을까? 인지과학, 신경과학 분야에서 다양한 연구들이 음악 청취자의 몰입 상태를 과학적으로 평가하고 정량화하고자 시도하고 있다. 그러나 기존 연구에서는 플로우(flow), 몰두(absorption), 참여(engagement) 등 몰입을 설명하는 여러 개념들이 혼재되어 사용되고 있어 음악적 몰입 현상을 개념화하기 어렵다는 문제가 있다. 본 연구에서는 몰입에 관한 다양한 논문 리뷰를 통해 음악 청취 활동 시 나타나는 몰입 모형이 선행요인-몰입 상태-결과의 3단계로 구분될 수 있음을 칙센트미하이(Csikszentmihalyi)의 플로우 이론에 기반하여 확인할 것이다. 또한, 음악 청취의 몰입을 행동적, 생리학적, 신경과학적으로 정량화할 수 있는 방법론과 향후 연구 방향을 제안하고자 한다.

참고문헌 (Reference)

• 1 Bakker, Arnold B., "Weekly Work Engagement and Flourishing : The Role of Hindrance and Challenge Job Demands" 83 (83): 397-409, 2013
• 2 Tozman, Tahmine, "Understanding the Psychophysiology of Flow : A Driving Simulator Experiment to Investigate the Relationship Between Flow and Heart Rate Variability" 52 : 408-418, 2015
• 3 Bonnet, Louise, "The Role of the Amygdala in the Perception of Positive Emotions: An “Intensity Detector”" 9 : 178-, 2015
• 4 Hall, Sarah E, "The Role of Trait and State Absorption in the Enjoyment of Music" 11 (11): 2016
• 5 Saarikallio, Suvi, "The Role of Music in Adolescents’ Mood Regulation" 35 (35): 88-109, 2007
• 6 De Manzano, Örjan, "The Psychophysiology of Flow during Piano Playing" 10 (10): 301-311, 2010
• 7 Schäfer, Thomas, "The Psychological Functions of Music Listening" 4 : 511-, 2013
• 8 Chanda, Mona Lisa, "The Neurochemistry of Music" 17 (17): 179-193, 2013
• 9 Keeler, Jason R., "The Neurochemistry and Social Flow of Singing: Bonding and Oxytocin" 518-, 2015
• 10 Brattico, Elvira, "The Neuroaesthetics of Music" 7 (7): 48-61, 2013
• 11 Rogatko, Thais Piassa, "The Influence of Flow on Positive Affect in College Students" 10 : 133-148, 2009
• 12 Dolan, David, "The Improvisational State of Mind: A Multidisciplinary Study of an Improvisatory Approach to Classical Music Repertoire Performance" 9 : 1341-, 2018
• 13 North, Adrian C., "The Importance of Music to Adolescents" 70 (70): 255-272, 2000
• 14 Cardona, Gemma, "The Forgotten Role of Absorption in Music Reward" 1514 (1514): 142-154, 2022
• 15 Fritz, Barbara Smolej, "The Experience of Flow and Subjective Well-being of Music Students" 16 (16): 5-17, 2007
• 16 Moneta, Giovanni B., "The Effect of Perceived Challenges and Skills on the Quality of Subjective Experience" 64 (64): 275-310, 1996
• 17 Csikszentmihalyi, Mihaly, "Television and the Rest of Life : A Systematic Comparison of Subjective Experience" 45 (45): 317-328, 1981
• 18 Czepiel, Anna, "Synchrony in the Periphery : Inter-Subject Correlation of Physiological Responses during Live Music Concerts" 11 (11): 22457-, 2021
• 19 North, Adrian C., "Subjective Complexity, Familiarity, and Liking for Popular Music" 14 (14): 77-93, 1995
• 20 Boly, Melanie, "Stimulus Set Meaningfulness and Neurophysiological Differentiation: A Functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging Study" 10 (10): 2015
• 21 Hetland, Audun, "Skiing and Thinking About It : Moment-to-Moment and Retrospective Analysis of Emotions in an Extreme Sport" 9 : 971-, 2018
• 22 Crum, Alia J., "Rethinking Stress : The Role of Mindsets in Determining the Stress Response" 104 (104): 716-733, 2013
• 23 Tschacher, Wolfgang, "Physiological Synchrony in Audiences of Live Concerts" 17 (17): 152-162, 2023
• 24 Tian, Yu, "Physiological Signal Analysis for Evaluating Flow During Playing of Computer Games of Varying Difficulty" 8 : 1121-, 2017
• 25 Harmat, László, "Physiological Correlates of the Flow Experience during Computer Game Playing" 97 (97): 1-7, 2015
• 26 Keller, Johannes, "Physiological Aspects of Flow Experiences: Skills-Demand-Compatibility Effects on Heart Rate Variability and Salivary Cortisol" 47 (47): 849-852, 2011
• 27 Csikszentmihalyi, Mihaly, "Optimal Experience in Work and Leisure" 56 (56): 815-822, 1989
• 28 Tellegen, Auke, "Openness to Absorbing and Self-Altering Experiences(’Absorption’), a Trait Related to Hypnotic Susceptibility" 83 (83): 268-277, 1974
• 29 Ulrich, Martin, "Neural Signatures of Experimentally Induced Flow Experiences Identified in a Typical fMRI Block Design with BOLD Imaging" 11 (11): 496-507, 2016
• 30 Gaggioli, Andrea, "Networked Flow in Musical Bands" 45 (45): 283-297, 2017
• 31 Kaneshiro, Blair, "Natural Music Evokes Correlated EEG Responses Reflecting Temporal Structure and Beat" 214 : 116559-, 2020
• 32 Witek, Maria AG, "Musicians and Non-Musicians Show Different Preference Profiles for Single Chords of Varying Harmonic Complexity" 18 (18): 2023
• 33 Vuust, Peter, "Music in the Brain" 23 (23): 287-305, 2022
• 34 DeNora, Tia, "Music as a Technology of the Self" 27 (27): 31-56, 1999
• 35 Madsen, Jens, "Music Synchronizes Brainwaves Across Listeners with Strong Effects of Repetition, Familiarity, and Training" 9 (9): 3576-, 2019
• 36 Wolf, Sebastian, "Motor Skill Failure or Flow-Experience? Functional Brain Asymmetry and Brain Connectivity in Elite and Amateur Table Tennis Players" 105 : 95-105, 2015
• 37 Vroegh, Thijs, "Manual Motor Reaction While Being Absorbed into Popular Music" 89 : 103088-, 2021
• 38 Güçlütürk, Yağmur, "Liking versus Complexity : Decomposing the Inverted U-Curve" 10 : 112-, 2016
• 39 Hu, Guangliang, "Is This Science Video Popular? Let Us See How the Audience Reacts!" 39 (39): 1-11, 2022
• 40 Rheinberg, F, "Intrinsic Motivation and Flow" 6 (6): 199-200, 2020
• 41 Chabin, Thibault, "Interbrain Emotional Connection during Music Performances Is Driven by Physical Proximity and Individual Traits" 1508 (1508): 178-195, 2022
• 42 Kaneshiro, Blair, "Inter-Subject EEG Correlation Reflects Time-Varying Engagement with Natural Music" 2021
• 43 Dauer, Tysen, "Inter-Subject Correlation While Listening to Minimalist Music: A Study of Electrophysiological and Behavioral Responses to Steve Reich’s Piano Phase" 15 : 702067-, 2021
• 44 De Manzano, Örjan, "Individual Differences in the Proneness to Have Flow Experiences Are Linked to Dopamine D2-Receptor Availability in the Dorsal Striatum" 67 : 1-6, 2013
• 45 Schubert, Emery, "Identifying Regions of Good Agreement Among Responders in Engagement with a Piece of Live Dance" 31 (31): 1-20, 2013
• 46 Nakamura, Jeanne, "Handbook of positive psychology" Oxford University Press 89-105, 2002
• 47 Engeser, Stefan, "Flow, Performance, and Moderators of Challenge-Skill Balance" 32 : 158-172, 2008
• 48 Loepthien, Tim, "Flow in Music Performance and Music-Listening : Differences in Intensity, Predictors, and the Relationship Between Flow and Subjective Well-being" 50 (50): 111-126, 2022
• 49 Ilies, Remus, "Flow at Work and Basic Psychological Needs : Effects on Well-being" 66 (66): 3-24, 2017
• 50 Habe, Katarina, "Flow and Satisfaction with Life in Elite Musicians and Top Athletes" 10 : 698-, 2019
• 51 de Sampaio Barros, "Flow Experience and the Mobilization of Attentional Resources" 18 : 810-823, 2018
• 52 Poulsen, Andreas Trier, "EEG in the Classroom : Synchronized Neural Recordings During Video Presentation" 7 (7): 43916-, 2017
• 53 Katahira, Kenji, "EEG Correlates of the Flow State : A Combination of Increased Frontal Theta and Moderate Frontocentral Alpha Rhythm in the Mental Arithmetic Task" 9 : 300-, 2018
• 54 Eisen, Mitchell L., "Dissociation, Memory, and Suggestibility in Adults and Children" 15 (15): S49-S73, 2001
• 55 Ara, Alberto, "Different Theta Connectivity Patterns Underlie Pleasantness Evoked by Familiar and Unfamiliar Music" 11 (11): 18523-, 2021
• 56 Jackson, Susan A., "Development and Validation of a Scale to Measure Optimal Experience : The Flow State Scale" 18 (18): 17-35, 1996
• 57 Csikszentmihalyi, Mihaly, "Creativity in performance" 43-66, 1997
• 58 Ziv, Jacob, "Coding Theorems for Individual Sequences" 24 (24): 405-412, 1978
• 59 Farrugia, Nicolas, "Beta and Theta Oscillations Correlate with Subjective Time during Musical Improvisation in Ecological and Controlled Settings: A Single Subject Study" 15 : 626723-, 2021
• 60 Chmiel, Anthony, "Back to the Inverted-U for Music Preference : A Review of the Literature" 45 (45): 886-909, 2017
• 61 Jackson, Susan A., "Assessing Flow in Physical Activity : The Flow State Scale–2 and Dispositional Flow Scale–2" 24 (24): 133-150, 2002
• 62 Vuust, Peter, "Anticipation is the Key to Understanding Music and the Effects of Music on Emotion" 31 (31): 599-600, 2008
• 63 Salimpoor, Valorie N., "Anatomically Distinct Dopamine Release during Anticipation and Experience of Peak Emotion to Music" 14 (14): 257-262, 2011
• 64 Banks, Sarah J., "Amygdala–Frontal Connectivity during Emotion Regulation" 2 (2): 303-312, 2007
• 65 Ruth, Nicolas, "Alternative Music Playlists on the Radio : Flow Experience and Appraisal during the Reception of Music Radio Programs" 21 (21): 75-97, 2017
• 66 Czepiel, Anna, "Aesthetic and Physiological Effects of Naturalistic Multimodal Music Listening" 239 : 105537-, 2023
• 67 Norsworthy, Cameron, "Advancing Our Understanding of Psychological Flow : A Scoping Review of Conceptualizations, easurements, and Applications" 147 (147): 806-827, 2021
• 68 Sandstrom, Gillian M., "Absorption in Music : Development of a Scale to Identify Individuals with Strong Emotional Responses to Music" 41 (41): 216-228, 2013
• 69 Lifshitz, Michael, "Absorption and Spiritual Experience : A Review of Evidence and Potential Mechanisms" 73 : 102760-, 2019
• 70 Casali, Adenauer G., "A Theoretically Based Index of Consciousness Independent of Sensory Processing and Behavior" 5 (5): 198ra105-198ra105, 2013
• 71 Swann, Christian, "A Review of Scientific Progress in Flow in Sport and Exercise : Normal Science, Crisis, and a Progressive Shift" 30 (30): 249-271, 2018
• 72 Jaque, S., "A Psychophysiological Case Study of Orchestra Conductors" 30 (30): 189-196, 2015
• 73 Bian, Yulong, "A Framework for Physiological Indicators of Flow in VR Games : Construction and Preliminary Evaluation" 20 : 821-832, 2016