과학기술 이미지의 미학적 해명: 19세기 골지와 카할의 신경과학 실험연구를 중심으로 = An Aesthetic Explanation of Technoscientific Images: focusing on Golgi and Cajal’s Neuroscientific Experimental Researches in the 19th Century

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

The relationships between technoscience and aesthetics are questioned by the fact that their theoretical intentions are different. However, the historical epistemology that scientific knowledge is historically constructed by variously intervening in its outsides shows the potential of coupling technoscientific images with the aesthetic. The article focuses on their representation of neuron images in the neuroscience debate of Golgi and Cajal in the 19th century. In these representation processes scientific knowledge has been transformed and structured not only by the aesthetic intervening, but by the intervention of materials, such as dyeing materials and experimental tools. In their analyzing the epistemic conventions of technoscientific images, Daston and Galison have rightly disposed the their images to historical-epistemic division of 'the mechanical objectivity', but could not properly explain the materiality intervened in the representation. On the other hand, their representation involved not only the aesthetic, but the materiality of the contemporary photographic techniques. This shows the historical aspect of technoscientific images related to the aesthetic through the materiality of the experiment, and instantiates the coupling of technoscience with aesthetics.

국문 초록 (Abstract)

과학기술과 미학의 관련은 학문 영역의 지향점이 상이하다는 사실에서 의문시되었다. 그러나 과학 지식이 그 외부의 다양한 개입에 의해 역사적으로 구성된다는 이해는 과학기술 이미지와 미적인 것의 연결 가능성을 보여준다. 본 논문은 19세기 골지와 카할의 신경과학 논쟁에서 실험 이미지의 재현 과정에 주목한다. 그들의 신경세포 이미지 재현에는 미학적인 개입만이 아니라 신경세포염색물질의 개입이 과학적 지식을 변형시켰다. 대스턴과 갤리슨의 ‘기계적 객관성’ 개념은 그들의 이미지 재현을 인식적․역사적 구분에 따라 적합하게 배치했으나, 물질적인 개입을 제대로 설명하지 못했다. 반면 골지와 카할의 이미지재현은 19세기 사진 기술이 사용한 물질들과 긴밀히 연결되었다. 이는 과학기술 이미지가 실험 재료의 물질성을 매개로 해서 미적인 것과 연결될 수 있는역사적 계기들을 보여주며, 과학기술과 미학의 접점을 예시한다.

참고문헌 (Reference)

• 1 Hacking, I., "표상하기와 개입하기" 한울 2016
• 2 이재준, "이미지와 기계의 생성: 장욱진의 회화와 R. 브룩스의 로봇을 중심으로" 한국예술연구소 (15) : 189-211, 2017
• 3 Latour, B, "우리는 결코 근대인이었던 적이 없다" 갈무리 2009
• 4 이재준, "얼굴과 사물의 인상학: 근대 신경과학과 광학미디어에서 기계의 표현을 중심으로" 한국미술이론학회 (22) : 62-85, 2016
• 5 김재인, "들뢰즈의 ‘아펙트’ 개념의 쟁점들: 스피노자를 넘어" 영미문학연구회 (43) : 132-155, 2017
• 6 Kaemmerling, E, "도상학과 도상해석학" 사계절 1997
• 7 Hacking, I., "‘Style’ for historians and philosophers" 23 (23): 1-20, 1992
• 8 Hacking, I., "Wahrheit und Geschichte" Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht 53-77, 1999
• 9 Daston L, "The image of objectivity" 40 : 81-128, 1992
• 10 Raviola, E, "The diffuse nervous network of Camillo Golgi:facts and fiction" 66 (66): 75-82, 2011
• 11 DeFelipe, J., "The dendritic spine story an intriguing process of discovery" 9 (9): 1-14, 2015
• 12 Newman, E. A., "The Beautiful Brain: The Drawings of Santiago Ramón y Cajal" Abrams 8-10, 2017
• 13 King, L, "The Beautiful Brain: The Drawings of Santiago Ramón y Cajal" Abrams 21-29, 2017
• 14 Swanson, L. W., "The Beautiful Brain: The Drawings of Santiago Ramón y Cajal" Abrams 11-20, 2017
• 15 Bredekamp, H., "Technical Image" The University of Chicago Press 18-31, 2015
• 16 Golgi, C, "Sulla Fina Anatomia degli Organi Cenrtrali del Sistema Nervoso" Urlico Hoepli 1886
• 17 Bueno, O., "Styles of reasoning: A pluralist view" 43 : 657-665, 2012
• 18 Baloyannis, S. J., "Staining neurons with Golgi techniques in degenerative diseases of the brain" 10 (10): 693-695, 2015
• 19 Piccolino, M, "Santiago Ramón Y Cajal, the retina and the neuron theory" 71 : 123-141, 1989
• 20 Cajal, S. R. y, "Reflections of My Life" the MIT Press 1989
• 21 Daston, L., "Questions of Evidence" University of Chicago Press 282-289, 1994
• 22 Ihde, D, "Philosophy of Technology: An Introduction" Paragon 1993
• 23 Golgi, C., "On the fine structure of the pes Hippocampi major, with plates XIII-XXIII(1886)" 54 (54): 461-483, 2001
• 24 Sciortino, L., "On Ian Hacking’'s Notion of Style of Reasoning" 82 : 243-264, 2017
• 25 Guillery, R. W., "Observations of synaptic structures: origins of the neuron doctrine and its current status" 360 : 1281-1307, 2005
• 26 Daston L, "Objectivity" Zone Books 2007
• 27 Golgi, C., "Nobel Lectures, Physiology or Medicine 1901-1921" Elsevier Pub. Co 189-217, 1967
• 28 Foster, M., "Kölliker, Rudolph Albert von" 889-890, 1911
• 29 Daffner, L. A., "Investigation of a Surface Tarnish Found on 19th-Century Daguerreotypes" 35 (35): 9-21, 1996
• 30 Galison, P, "Image and Logic: A Material Culture and Metaphysics" The University of Chicago Press 1997
• 31 Nissl, F., "Histologische und histopathologische Arbeiten über die Grosshirnrinde, Bd. II" 1904
• 32 Cajal, S. R. y, "Histologie du système nerveux de l'homme & des vertébrés" Maloine 1901
• 33 Grant, G., "Gustaf Retzius and Camillo Golgi" 8 (8): 151-163, 1999
• 34 Johnstone, J., "Friedrich Kittler's Essays" OPA 1-26, 1997
• 35 Gerlach, J. von, "Die Photographie als Hilfsmittel mikroskopischer Forschung" Wilhelm Engelmann 1863
• 36 Lenhossék, M, "Der feinere Bau des Nervensystems im Lichte neuester Forschungen" Fischer's Medicinische Buchhandlung 1893
• 37 Krämer, S, "Culture, Technology, Cultural Techniques-Moving Beyond Text" 30 (30): 20-29,
• 38 Gernsheim, H, "Creative Photography: Aesthetic Trends 1839–1960" Bonanza Books 1962
• 39 Ramón-Moliner, E., "Contemporary Research Methods in Neuroanatomy" Springer 32-55, 1970
• 40 Jones, E. G., "Colgi, Cajal and the Neuron Doctrine" 8 (8): 170-178, 1999
• 41 Mazzarello, P., "Camillo Golgi’s Scientific Biography" 8 (8): 121-131, 1999
• 42 Bredekamp, H, "Bildakt at the Warburg Institute" De Gruyter 3-32, 2014
• 43 Trabant, J., "Bildakt at the Warburg Institute" De Gruyter 9-14, 2014
• 44 Diamantis, A, "Alfred Francois Donné (1801-78): a pioneer of microscopy, microbiology and haematology" 17 : 81-87, 2009
• 45 Foster, M, "A textbook of physiology" Macmillan 1879