언어행위론에 관한 일고찰 : 소통학과 권력론을 중심으로

국문 초록 (Abstract)

본고는 개인간 소통에 초점을 맞춘 소통학과 권력을 수단으로 보는 도구적 권력론의 입장 에서 언어행위론을 고찰하였다. 그 목적은 언어행위론의 소통학 및 권력론과의 상호보완적 관계를 모색하기 위해서였다. 이를 위해, 첫째 언어행위론의 가장 큰 기여라고 할 수 있는 언 어적 소통의 의미 규정의 문제를 소통학의 입장에서 반성적으로 고찰하고, 둘째 언어행위론 이 말하는 소통의 규정과 그 문제점은 무엇인지 논의하고, 셋째 언어행위론에 의한 소통과 권 력의 관계를 규명하면서 그와 관련된 언어행위론의 문제점을 살펴보고, 마지막으로 언어행위 론과 권력론의 의도성의 문제에 비추어 소통학의 의도성의 문제, 특히 소통의 효과에서 의도 성의 문제를 논의하였다. 그 결과로 언어행위론은 우리의 일상생활에서 언어가 구체적으로 어떻게 활용되는가를 규명함으로써 소통과 의미의 이해를 심화시켰고, 권력과 소통의 밀접한 관계를 보여주었다. 그러나 소통학이나 권력론의 관점에서 언어행위론은 몇 가지 문제점을 내포하고 있어 이들이 서로 보완적 관계에 있음도 알 수 있었다.

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

This paper is a study of speech act theory from the perspectives of communication studies which focus on interpersonal verbal communication, and theory of power which sees power as an instrument, that is, someone's means to a purpose. The aim was to search for complementary relationships between speech act theory on the one hand and communication studies and power theory on the other. For the aim, this paper tries to examine the following problems: firstly, the problem of establishing meaning, one of the greatest contribution by speech act theory, from the communication studies perspective; secondly, the way that linguistic communication is defined by speech act theory and its problems; thirdly, the relationship mediated by speech acts between power and communication and problems of speech act theory in terms of power theory; and lastly, the problem of intention in communication, especially in its effects, as entailed by speech act theory. As a result of this inquiry, speech act theory, through examining how ordinary language is used, deepens the understanding of communication and meaning, and mediates the close relationship between power and communication. However, from the perspectives of communication studies and power theory, speech act theory also has some drawbacks, which shows that speech act theory, communication studies, and theory of power are in complementary relationships to each other.

목차 (Table of Contents)

• 요약
• 1. 문제의 제기
• 2. 언어행위론과 의미의 문제
• 3. 언어행위론과 소통의 규정의 문제
• 4. 언어행위론과 권력의 문제
• 5. 언어행위론과 의도성의 문제
• 6. 맺는 말
• 참고문헌
• Abstract

참고문헌 (Reference)

• 1 Gode, A., "What is communication" 9 : 5-, 1959
• 2 DeFleur, M., "Understanding mass communication: A liberal arts perspective" Houghton Mifflin Co 1996
• 3 Sadock, J., "Toward a linguistic theory of speech acts" Academic Press 1974
• 4 Mills, C., "The power elite" Oxford Univ. Press 1956
• 5 Peters, J., "The international encyclopedia of communication, II" Blackwell Publishing Ltd 689-693, 2008
• 6 Sandstrom, K., "The international encyclopedia of communication, I" Blackwell Publishing Ltd 4927-4933, 2008
• 7 Porcar, C., "The interactive dimension of communication: The pragmatics of Palo Alto Group" 1 (1): 4-19, 2011
• 8 Sadock, J., "The handbook of pragmatics" Blackwell Publishing Ltd 2008
• 9 Klapper, J., "The effects of mass communication" The Free Press 1960
• 10 Debnam, G., "The analysis of power: A realist approach" MacMillan Press 1984
• 11 Searle, J., "Syntax and semantics, vol. 3: Speech acts" 59-82, 1975
• 12 Searle, J., "Speech acts: An essay in the philosophy of language" Cambridge University Press 1969
• 13 Stanford Enyclopedia of Philsophy, "Speech acts. [Electronic version]"
• 14 Cohen, A., "Sociolinguistics and language teaching" Cambridge University Press 383-420, 1996
• 15 Bach, K., "Semantics vs. pragmatics" Clarendon Press 115-144, 2005
• 16 Bach, K., "Routledge encyclopedia of philosophy" Routledge 1998
• 17 Cairns, H., "Psycholinguistics" Holt, Rinehart &Winston 1976
• 18 Grice, H., "Pragmatics: A reader" Oxford University Press 65-76, 1991
• 19 Grice, H., "Pragmatics: A reader" Oxford University Press 305-315, 1991
• 20 Wrong, D., "Power: Its forms, bases, and uses" Harper Colophon Books 1979
• 21 Parsons, T., "Power: A reader" Manchester Univ. Press 70-112, 2002
• 22 Haugaard, M., "Power: A reader" Manchester Univ. Press 2002
• 23 Lukes, S., "Power: A radical view" The MacMillan Press Ltd 1974
• 24 Foucault, M., "Power/knowledge: Selected interviews and other writings 1972-1977" Pantheon Books 1972
• 25 Lasswell, H., "Power and society" Yale Univ. Press 1950
• 26 Arendt, H., "Power" New York Univ. Press 59-74, 1986
• 27 McDowell, J., "Philosophical Subjects: Essays Presented to P. F. Sfrawson" Clarendon Press 117-139, 1980
• 28 Motley, M., "On whether one can(not) not communicate: An examination via traditional communication postulates" 54 : 1-20, 1990
• 29 Recanati, R., "On defining communicative intentions" 3 (3): 213-242, 1986
• 30 Miller, G., "On defining communication : Another stab" 16 : 88-98, 1966
• 31 Grice, H., "Meaning" 66 (66): 377-388, 1957
• 32 Lasswell, H., "Mass communications" Univ. of Illinois Press 117-130, 1948
• 33 Bach, K., "Linguistic Communication and Speech Acts" M.I.T. Press 1979
• 34 Searle, J., "Language, mind and knowledge" University of Minnesota Press 344-369, 1975
• 35 West, R., "Introducing communication theory: Analysis and application" McGraw Hill 2007
• 36 Strawson, P., "Intention and convention in speech acts" 73 : 439-460, 1964
• 37 Harper, N., "Human communication theory" Hayden Book Co., Inc 1979
• 38 Berelson, B., "Human Behavior" Harcourt, Brace and World 1964
• 39 Austin, J., "How to do things with words" Harvard University Press 1962
• 40 Hoben. J., "English communication at Colgate re-examined" 4 : 76-86, 1954
• 41 Williams, R., "Communications" Penguin Books 1962
• 42 Severin, W., "Communication theories: Origins, methods, and uses in the mass media" Longman 2001
• 43 Straubhaar, J., "Communication media in the information society. Beloment" Wadsworth Publishing Co 1996
• 44 Newcomb, T., "Communication and Culture" Holt, Rinehart and Winston 66-79, 1966
• 45 McQuail, D., "Communication" Longman 1975
• 46 Weber, M., "Classes, power, and conflict:Classical and contemporary debates" Univ. of California Press 60-86, 1982
• 47 Intante, A., "Building communication theory" Waveland Press, Inc 1990
• 48 Bach, K., "Blackwell guide to the philosophy of language" Blackwell Publishing Ltd 2003
• 49 Bach, K., "Basic topics in the philosophy of language" Prentice-Hall 1-23, 1994
• 50 Braddock, R., "An extension of Lasswell Formula" 8 : 88-93, 1958
• 51 Theodorson, S., "A modern dictionary of sociology" Cassell 1969