Research on the Formation Mechanism and Realization Path of Harmonious Labor Relations in the New Employment Form

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

In the context of the development of new employment patterns, emerging enterprises are rapidly developing following the footsteps of the Internet. In the process of enterprise development, labor-management conflicts between employees and employers may arise. Previous studies have found that five parties: employees, government, enterprises, trade unions and social organizations can improve employee job satisfaction or employer satisfaction in manufacturing enterprises. However, in the new form of employment with the rapid development of network, will labor relations also be affected by these five parties? Based on labor relations theory, this study investigates the effect of the five parties: employee self-control, enterprise management, trade union consultation, government guidance, and non-governmental organizations (NGOs) supervision on the establishment of harmonious labor relations in the context of new employment patterns.
In this study, a questionnaire was used and 361 employees were used as the data sample. The analysis of the results showed that employees’ self-control, enterprises management and government guidance had a significant positive effect on the establishment of harmonious labor relations, trade union consultation had no significant positive effect on harmonious labor relations, and NGOs supervision had no significant negative effect on harmonious labor relations.
The results of this study suggest management suggestions for the different effects of the five parties’ labor relations coordination power on harmonious labor relations. Firstly, the improvement of employees’ self-control has the greatest effect on harmonious labor relations.
In view of this, the main suggestions are: First, practitioners should have a clear understanding of themselves, make up for their own shortcomings, continue to learn to improve their professionalism, and better play the role of the master; second, practitioners should change their traditional fixed mindset, strengthen their knowledge of democratic management, and actively participate in the democratic management of the enterprise.
Secondly, the improvement of enterprise management and government guidance has a positive impact on the construction of harmonious labor relations. The following management recommendations are made: Enterprise managers need to guide employees to learn, increase professional quality and further study opportunities, create an atmosphere of learning organization and improve the working ability of practitioners. This can be applied not only to Chinese workers, but also to practitioners of Korean platform economy enterprises. The government should pay attention to the interests of enterprises and employees, and formulate appropriate policies that are conducive to labor-management relations.
Thirdly, the trade union consultation has no significant impact on harmonious labor relations. In order to further build a harmonious labor relationship between employees and employers, the following policy suggestions are put forward: establish a reasonable, legal and compliant trade union organization serving employees and management. Trade union organizations should improve their own visibility through corresponding measures, so that employees recognize the importance and convenience of trade unions, join the organization and development of trade unions, and gradually grow and expand trade union organizations for common development, interdependence, mutual benefit and win-win; Third, improve the professional and theoretical education of relevant staff of trade unions, increase the participation of professionals, and ensure that they play a correct and positive role.
Fourthly, the following recommendations are made to address the point that the impact of NGOs supervision on harmonious labor relations shows a non-significant negative effect. The focus of NGOs should not only be on the direction of practitioners, but also on monitoring the market behav...

참고문헌 (Reference)

• 1 Frank, L., "Work, Politics and Power: An International Perspective on Workers’ Control and Self-Management, by Assef Bayat" 18 (18): 143-146, 1991
• 2 John, A., "When money isn’t enough: the effect of equity sensitivity on performance-based pay systems" 1992
• 3 Lee, C. H., "What sort of collective bargaining is emerging in China?" 54 (54): 214-236, 2014
• 4 Budd, J. W, "The thought of work in employment relations" 25 (25): 61-65, 2013
• 5 Arthur, W. B., "The nature of technology: what it is and how it evolves" Penguin Books 2009
• 6 Li, C. J., "The formation mechanism and management strategies of harmonious labor relations in new forms of employment in China" 46 (46): 62-70, 2021
• 7 Pfeffer, J., "The effect of wage dispersion on satisfaction, productivity, and working collaboratively: evidence from college and university faculty" 38 (38): 382-407, 1993
• 8 Schumpeter, J. A., "The Theory of Economic Development: An Inquiry Into Profits, Capital, Credit, Interest, and the Business Cycle" Transaction Publishers 1934
• 9 Xie, Y. H., "The Formation Mechanism of the Demand-Oriented Wage Collective Bargaining: An Exploratory Cases Study" 14 (14): 497-504, 2017
• 10 Tu, W., "The Contemporary Theoretical Debates on Labor Relations Research and Its Enlightenment to the Innovation of Labor Relations Coordination Mechanism with Chinese Characteristics" 35 (35): 60-103, 2021
• 11 Hu, F. Z., "The Construction of Harmonious Labor Relations in the New Era: Influence Factors and Countermeasures——Based on the Investigation of Hubei Enterprises" 18 (18): 5-10, 2018
• 12 Zhou, Y., "The Conflict and Coordination of Form Regulations of the Mixed Contra Between Companies and Senior Executives" 23 (23): 100-107, 2021
• 13 Chang, K., "The Collective Transformation of Labor Relations and Improvement of the Government’s Labor Policy" 35 (35): 82-99, 2014
• 14 Perez C., "Technological Revolutions and Techno－economic Paradigms" 34 (34): 185-202, 2010
• 15 Dosi G, "Technological Paradigms and Technological Trajectories: A Suggested Interpretation of the Determinants and Directions of Technical Change" 11 (11): 147-162, 1982
• 16 Freeman, C., "Technical Change and Economic Theory" Pinte 1988
• 17 Sun, R., "Status and Improvement of the Government’s Role in Labor Relations Private Sector via the Tri-partite Consultation Mechanism" 15 (15): 103-108, 2015
• 18 Tan, H., "Research on the role orientation and function performance of the government in building harmonious labor relations" 34 (34): 45-49, 2013
• 19 Gong, X. C., "Research on the method of building harmonious labor relations in scientific and technological small and micro enterprises" 26 : 66-69, 2021
• 20 Xu, J. Y., "Research on the innovation path of labor relations coordination mechanism of private enterprises in the new era" 19 (19): 120-127, 2019
• 21 Zhang, Y., "Research on the current situation of practitioners in new employment forms" 09 : 166-185, 2019
• 22 Ding, G. D., "Research on the Labor Relations of College Students During the period Practice" 37 (37): 108-115, 2022
• 23 Sun, Y. B., "Research on the Coordination Mechanism of Enterprise Labor Relation Based on the Principal Perspective" 38 (38): 104-108, 2018
• 24 Wang, Y. L., "Research on harmonious labor relations under the financial crisis -- Based on the survey of 100 enterprises in Guangzhou" 11 (11): 173-174, 2011
• 25 Spector, P. E., "Reducing subjectivity in the assessment of the job environment: development of the factual autonomy scale (FAS)" 24 (24): 417-432, 2003
• 26 Hill S., "Raw Deal: How the ‘Uber Economy’ and Runaway Capitalism Are Screwing American Workers" 2015
• 27 Cowherd, D. M., "Product quality and pay equity between lower-level employees and top management: An investigation of distributive justice theory" 37 (37): 524-524, 1992
• 28 Pan, H., "Problems and measures of labor relations in the new form of employment" (47) : 105-106, 2019
• 29 Hair, J. F., "PLS-SEM: Indeed, a silver bullet" 19 : 139-152, 2011
• 30 Tian, W., "On the role of non-governmental organizations in the development of harmonious labor relations" 10 (10): 242-245, 2010
• 31 He, T. F., "On the characteristics of labor relations under the new form of employment" 18 (18): 98-99, 2019
• 32 Li, C. J., "On the Systemic and Holistic Reform of Labor Relations Coordinating Mechanism in Chinese Enterprises" 29 (29): 77-83, 2016
• 33 Shi, X. T., "On Tripartite Consultation Mechanism and its Influence on Labor Policy Making" 28 (28): 23-28, 2014
• 34 Yuan, S., "On Protection of Rights and Interests of Workers in New Forms of Employment" 34 (34): 46-49, 2017
• 35 Liu, P. K., "Node autonomy: achieve employee self-management" 16 (16): 93-95, 2016
• 36 Child., "Management issues in China: volume 2:international enterprises" 5 (5): 337-338, 1996
• 37 Gittell, J. H, "Layoffs and Organizational Resilience: Lessons for Workers, Managers, and Investors" 10 (10): 6-8, 2006
• 38 Budd, J., "Labor relations" McGraw-Hill Publishing 2009
• 39 Borjas, G. J., "Labor economics" McGraw-Hill/Irwin 2010
• 40 Wang, R. J., "Labor Conflict and Employee Participation Mechanism" 13 (13): 94-98, 2013
• 41 Befort, S. F., "Invisible hands, invisible objectives: bringing workplace law and public policy into focus" Stanford Economics and Finance 2009
• 42 Plouffe, C. R., "Intraorganizational employee navigation and socially derived outcomes: conceptualization, validation, and effects on overall performance" 64 (64): 693-738, 2011
• 43 He, Y. C., "Intervention of Social Organizations and Operation of Collective Labor Relations in China——A Tentative Model in Labor Disputes Resolution" 15 : 93-108, 2015
• 44 Chen, F, "Individual rights and collective rights: labor’s predicament in China" 40 (40): 59-79, 2007
• 45 Wei, X. H., "Have trade unions improved the employment term structure of enterprises?" 15 (15): 52-62, 2015
• 46 Yang, Q. T., "Give play to the leading role of the government in building harmonious labor relations" 18 (18): 66-67, 2018
• 47 Memon., "Gender Inequality, Job Satisfaction and Job Motivation: Evidence from Indian Female Employees" Sage Publishers 42 : 1-22, 2017
• 48 Tan, Q. X., "Exploration of the Tripartite Coordination Mechanism for Labor Relation China" 13 (13): 38-41, 2013
• 49 Cheng, Y. Y., "Establish and improve the coordination mechanism of labor relations" 25 (25): 1-, 2011
• 50 Zhu, F., "Enterprises Labor Relations Management Research in China: Literature Review for Forty Years" 35 (35): 83-96, 2018
• 51 Budd, J. W., "Employment with a Human Face: Balancing Efficiency, Equity, and Voice" Cornell University Press 2004
• 52 Renn, R. W., "Empirical examination of the theory of self-management failure" 32 : 25-43, 2011
• 53 Bu, M. X., "Current situation and improvement strategy of enterprise labor relations management" 21 (21): 113-114, 2021
• 54 Li, C. J., "Comparison of structural labor relations of manufacturing enterprises in different industries in China -- Taking the eastern coastal area as an example" 38 (38): 45-52, 2019
• 55 Scoville, J. G., "Comparative industrial relations: An introduction to cross-national perspectives" 40 (40): 150-, 1986
• 56 Tang, K., "Comment on the eighth of the new economy: the Internet subverts the working mode and the emergence of new platform employment"
• 57 Qi, F. L., "Collective negotiation system of labor capital conflict: ethical principles and reflection" 15 (15): 147-152, 2015
• 58 Ming, J., "Collective Transformation and Evolution of Industrial Relationship: A Comparative Institutional Analysis" 17 (17): 137-147, 2017
• 59 Han, X. P., "Classified Research on the Coordination of Labor Relations in Countries along One Belt and One Road" 35 (35): 70-76, 2019
• 60 Zhao, Z. P., "Change and Coordination Mechanism of French Labor Relations ——A Exploration of the Context of Globalization and Financial Crisis" 19 (19): 87-95, 2019
• 61 Keen, A., "Can the Sharing Economy Provide Good Jobs?" 10 : 2015
• 62 Edwards, J. C., "Business ideologies and perceived breach of contract during downsizing: The role of the ideology of employee self-reliance" 24 (24): 1-23, 2003
• 63 Backes, U., "Avoiding labor shortages by employer signaling:On the importance of good work climate and labor relation" 63 (63): 271-286, 2010
• 64 Xie, Y. H., "An Empirical Study on Enterprise Union Practice and Its Effect on Industrial Relations Climate" 40 (40): 137-142, 2019
• 65 Zhao, D. L., "A Study on the Participation of China’s Trade Unions in the Coordination Labor Relations in Enterprises in the New Era" 18 (18): 110-116, 2019
• 66 Xie, Y. H., "A Study on the Impact of Corporate Employee Social Responsibility of Labor Relations Climate——Based on the Moderating Effect of High Involvement Work System" 30 (30): 1-7, 2016
• 67 Zhang, C. G., "A Growing Trend of Employment? Analysis of Concept and Impact of New Forms of Employment" 19 : 86-91, 2016