When Theology and Ethics Meet = Rereading Romans 14:13-15:6

국문 초록 (Abstract)

본고는 바울의 신학과 윤리 사이에 밀접한 관계가 있으며 전자는 후자를 형성하는 데 있어 분명한 동력을 제공하고 있다는 입장에 기대어 롬 14:13-15:6을 재고찰한다. 바울의 신학 특히 기독론 · 종말론적 입장이 그의 윤리를 구성함에 있어 핵심적 역할을 한다는 선행연구들이 많았음에도 불구하고 본문은 그 논의에서 철저히 배제되거나 혹은 충분히 검토되지 못했다. 이러한 간극을 메우기 위해 본고는 이전 문맥(12:1-2과 13:11-14)과 롬 14:13-15:6을 중심으로 주석 작업을 실행하고자 한다. 이전 문맥에 대한 연구가 중요한 것은 해당 두 본문이 차지하는 전략적 위치 때문인데, 롬 12:1-2은 윤리적 권면을 주로 다루는 12-15장 전체의 서론에 해당하며, 13:11-14은 신자에게 두루 적용되는 일반 권면(general hortatory section; 12:1-13:10)과 로마 신자에게 주어지는 특별 권면(particular hortatory section; 14:1-15:13)을 연결하는 이음새 역할을 하기 때문이다. 이전 문맥의 주석 작업을 통해 얻을 수 있는 두 가지 사실은, 첫째 두 본문의 전략적 위치를 고려할 때 그것들이 12-15장의 윤리적 권면을 해석하는 틀을 제공한다는 것, 둘째 그 해석학적 틀은 다름 아닌 바울의 기독론 · 종말론적 입장이라는 것이다. 이러한 구조가 함의하는 바는 롬 14:13-15:6 역시 바울의 신학과 윤리의 긴밀한 상관관계 속에서 해석되어야 한다는 것이다. 다시 말해, 롬 14:13-15:6의 다양한 윤리적 권면은 바울의 기독론 · 종말론이라는 해석학적 틀에 근거하여 독해할 때 가장 잘 이해될 수 있다.

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

This article aims to provide additional textual evidence to the position that Paul’s ethics is fundamentally shaped by his theology, especially his christological and eschatological beliefs. In scholarly endeavor to prove this position, Rom 14:13-15:6 has been either completely ignored or partially treated in the previous scholarship. In an attempt to fill this lacuna, the article will conduct a contextual analysis of the previous context (12:1-2 and 13:11-14) and a textual analysis of our passage (14:13-15:6). The contextual analysis reveals that 12:1-2 and 13:11-14 contain two hermeneutical frameworks that affect the interpretation of the hortatory section of which our passage is part: christology and eschatology. That is, the strategic places of these passages (i.e. 12:1-2 as programmatic statements for the entire hortatory section, and 13:11-14 as a connecting section that signals reading strategies for surrounding hortatory units) invite us to interpret our passage from these two hermeneutical frameworks. After this contextual analysis, the rest of this article will examine 14:13-15:6 with a special concern to show how Paul constantly formulates various ethical admonitions based on his christological and eschatological beliefs.

목차 (Table of Contents)

• Abstract
• I. Introduction
• II. Contextual Analysis
• III. Textual Analysis of Romans 14:13-15:6
• Ⅳ. Conclusion
• Bibliography
• 초록

참고문헌 (Reference)

• 1 장흥길, "신약성서윤리의 성격과 최근 연구동향" 한국신약학회 18 (18): 375-411, 2011
• 2 장상, "바울의 종말론" 15 : 113-137, 1983
• 3 김중기, "바울 윤리의 바탕: 서신의 표현 양식을 이야기 신학으로 수용하면서" 27 : 269-290, 1999
• 4 Gagnon, Robert A. J., "Why the ‘Weak’ at Rome Cannot Be Non-Christian Jews" 62 : 64-82, 2000
• 5 Sampley, J. Paul, "Walking Between the Times: Paul’s Moral Reasoning" Fortress 1991
• 6 Achtemeier, Paul J., "Theology and Ethics in Raul and His Interpreters" Abingdon 132-145, 1996
• 7 Furnish, Victor Paul, "Theology and Ethics in Paul" Abingdon 1968
• 8 Gupta, Nijay K., "The Theo-Logic of Paul’s Ethics in Recent Research: Crosscurrents and Future Directions in Scholarship in the Last Forty Years" 7 : 336-361, 2009
• 9 Grieb, A. Katherine, "The Story of Romans: A Narrative Defense of God’s Righteousness" Westminster John Knox 2002
• 10 Nanos, Mark D., "The Mystery of Romans: The Jewish Context of Paul’s Letter" Fortress 1996
• 11 Hays, Richard B., "The Moral Vision of the New Testament" HarperSanFrancisc 1996
• 12 Schnackenburg, Rudolf, "The Moral Teaching of the New Testament" Herder and Herder 1965
• 13 Hamilton, Neill Quinn, "The Holy Spirit and Eschatology in Paul" Oliver and Boyd 1957
• 14 Verhey, Allen, "The Great Reversal: Ethics and the New Testament" Eerdmans 1984
• 15 Hays, Richard B., "The Future of Christology: Essays in Honor of Leander E. Keck" Fortress 122-136, 1993
• 16 Schrage, Wolfgang, "The Ethics of the New Testar-ment" Fortress Press 1988
• 17 Barrett, C. K., "The Epistle to the Romans" Hendrickson 1991
• 18 Moo, Douglas J., "The Epistle to the Romans" Eerdmans 1996
• 19 Dodd, C. H., "The Epistle of Paul to the Romans" Harper & Row 1932
• 20 O’Callaghan, Paul, "The Christological Assimilation of the Apocalypse: An Essay on Fundamental Eschatology" Four Courts 2004
• 21 Dodd, C. H., "The Apostolic Preaching and Its Developments" Hodder & Stoughton 1944
• 22 Lovestam, Evald, "Spiritual Wakefulness in the New Testament" Gleerup 1963
• 23 Horrell, David G., "Solidarity and Difference: A Contemporary Reading of Paul’s Ethics" T & T Clark 2005
• 24 Jewett, Robert, "Romans: A Commentary" Fortress 2007
• 25 Byrne, Brendan, "Romans. SP 6; Collegeville" Liturgical Press 1996
• 26 Fitzmyer, Joseph A., "Romans : A New Translation with Introduction and Commentary" Doubleday 1993
• 27 Dunn, James D. G., "Romans 9-16" Word Books 1988
• 28 Wright, N. T., "Romans" Abingdon 2002
• 29 Keck, Leander E, "Romans" Abingdon 2005
• 30 Achtemeier, Paul J., "Romans" John Knox 1985
• 31 Matera, Frank J., "Romans" Baker Academic 2010
• 32 Schreiner, Thomas R., "Romans" Baker Books 1998
• 33 Longenecker, Bruce W., "Rhetoric at the Boundaries: The Art and Theology of the New Testament Chain-Link Transitions" Baylor University Press 2005
• 34 Martin, Ralph P., "Reconciliation: A Study of Paul’s Theology" John Knox 1981
• 35 Johnston, George, "Prom Jesus to Paul: Studies in Honor of Francis Wright Beare" Wilfrid Laurier University Press 143-156, 1984
• 36 Hultgren, Arland J., "Paul’s Letter to the Romans: A Commentary" Eerdmans 2011
• 37 Witherington, Ben, "Paul’s Letter to the Romans" Eerdmans 2004
• 38 Beker, J. Christiaan, "Paul’s Apocalyptic Gospel" Fortress 1982
• 39 Campbell, William S., "Pauline Theology. Vol. 3: Romans" Fortress 259-286, 1995
• 40 Engberg-Pedersen, Troels, "Paul, Grace and Freedom: Essays in Honour of John K. Riches" T & T Clark 22-38, 2009
• 41 Beker, J. Christiaan, "Paul the Apostle: The Triumph of God in Life and Thought" Fortress 1980
• 42 Porter, Stanley E., "Paul and His Theology" Brill 2006
• 43 Morris, Leon, "New Testament Theology" Academie Books 1986
• 44 Donfried, Karl Paul, "Kingdom of God in 20th-Century Interpretation" Hendrickson 175-190, 1987
• 45 Seifrid, Mark A., "Justification by Faith: The Origin and Development of a Central Pauline Theme" Brill 1992
• 46 Shogren, Gary Steven, "Is the Kingdom of God About Eating and Drinking or Isn’t It?’ (Romans 14:17)" 42 : 238-256, 2000
• 47 Wagner, J. Ross, "Heralds of the Good News: Isaiah and Paul “in Concert” in the Letter to the Romans" Brill 2002
• 48 Dibelius, Martin, "From Tradition to Gospel" Scribner 1935
• 49 Barclay, John M. G., "Faith and Self-Detachment from Cultural Norms: A Study in Romans 14-15" 104 : 192-208, 2013
• 50 Lohr, Hermut, "Eschatology of the New Testament and Some Related Documents" Mohr Siebeck 644-665, 2011
• 51 Frey, Jorg, "Eschatology of the New Testament and Some Related Documents" Mohr Siebeck 3-32, 2011
• 52 Wolter, Michael, "Eschatology of the New Testament and Some Related Documents" Mohr Siebeck 416-426, 2011
• 53 Hays, Richard B., "Echoes of Scripture in the Letters of Paul" Yale University Press 1989
• 54 Hawthorne, Gerald F., "Dictionary of Paul and His Letters: A Compendium of Contemporary Biblical Scholarship" InterVarsity Press 1993
• 55 Gorman, Michael J., "Cruciformity: Paul’s Narrative Spirituality of the Cross" Eerdmans 2001
• 56 Kasemann, Emst, "Commentary on Romans" Eerdmans 1980
• 57 Thompson, Michael B., "Clothed with Christ: The Example and Teaching of Jesuin Romans 12.1-15.13" JSOT 1991
• 58 Duff, Nancy J., "Apocalyptic and the New Testament" JSOT 279-296, 1989
• 59 Freedman, David Noel., "Anchor Bible Dictionary. 6 vols" Doubleday 1992
• 60 Horrell, David G., "An Introduction to the Study of Paul" Continuum 2000
• 61 Bryan, Christopher, "A Preface to Romans" Oxford University Press 2000
• 62 Cranfield, C. E. B., "A Critical and Exegetical Commentary on the Epistle to the Romans, Vol. 2" T & T Clark 1975
• 63 Sanday, William, "A Critical and Exegetical Commentary on the Epistle to the Romans" T & T Clar 1902