몬머스 반란과 세지무어 전투(1685)의 재해석: 근대 영국 육군 발달사의 관점에서 = The Monmouth Rebellion and the Battle of Sedgemoor (1685): The Origin of the First Professional English Army

국문 초록 (Abstract)

전문화된 근대 군대로서 영국 육군의 창설은 오래도록 윌리엄 3세의 업적이었다고 여겨져 왔다. 전통적인 관점은 명예혁명으로 집권한 윌리엄 3세에 의해 네덜란드의 최신 군사 이론과 제도가 도입되어, 유럽 대륙의 ‘군사혁명’으로부터 유리되었던 스튜어트 군대를 일신하였다고 보았다. 본고는 제임스 2세 치세에 영국 육군에 일어난 변화를 분석함으로서 이러한 해석에 이의를 제기한다. 제임스 2세의 군대는 그동안 큰 주목을 받지 못하였지만, 많은 면에서 이후 근대 영국군의 발전에 핵심적인 기틀을 놓은 시대였다. 본고는 제임스 2세 치세에 영국군이 치른 유일한 실전인 몬머스 반란의 군사적 의의를 재검토함으로서 당시 영국군이 제도적, 군사교리적인 측면 뿐 아니라 실전 수행 능력에 있어서도 전문화된 근대 군대의 모습을 충실히 갖춰나가고 있었음을 주장한다.

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

William III has long been credited for the creation of modern, professional English army. It has been commonly argued that the Tudor and Stuart army was largely alienated from the European ‘military revolution’, until William III ‘modernised’ it by adopting Dutch military practice after the ‘Glorious’ Revolution of 1688. This article, however, suggests that the origin of truly professional English army must trace back to the initiation of James II. His significant achievement in transforming a small police force he inherited from his brother, Charles II, into a regular army comparable to its continental counterparts has been unfairly forgotten mainly due to later Protestant propaganda against this Briatin’s last Catholic king. However, it was during James II’s reign that the fundamental structure of English army was first established and its tactical doctrine was updated. The army he created proved displayed its professionalism and operational capacity when confronted the Duke of Monmouth’s rebel army, which was a more significant threat than the popular epithet the ‘Pitchfork Rebellion’ suggests.

참고문헌 (Reference)

• 1 박정규, "왕정복고기 잉글랜드 국교도의 설교정치" 영국사학회 (48) : 1-39, 2022
• 2 Yun, Dukhee, "The ‘Push of Pike’ in Seventeenth-Century English Infantry Combat" 86 (86): 837-857, 2022
• 3 Goldsworthy, Adrian, "The Roman Army at War 100 BC-AD 200" Clarendon Press 1996
• 4 Childs, John, "The Nine Years' War and the British Army, 1688-1697: The Operations in the Low Countries" Manchester University Press 1991
• 5 Wignfield, W. Macdonald, "The Monmouth Rebellion: A Social History" Barnes & Noble 1980
• 6 Miller, John, "The Militia and the Army in the Reign of James II" 16 (16): 678-679, 1973
• 7 Mackay, Hugh, "The Exercise of the Foot with the Evolutions, With the Rules of War in the day of Battel, when Encountering with the Enemy" 1693
• 8 Gaunt, Peter, "The English Civil War: A Military History" I. B. Tauris 2014
• 9 Louth, Warick, "The Arte Militaire : The Application of 17th Century Military Manuals to Conflict Archaeology" Helion & Company 2016
• 10 Childs, John, "The Army, James II, and the Glorious Revolution" Manchester University Press 1980
• 11 Foard, Glenn, "The Archaeology of English Battlefields: Conflicts in the Pre-industrial Landscape" Council for British Archaeology 2012
• 12 Manning, Roger B., "Styles of Command in Seventeenth-Century English Armies" 71 : 671-699, 2007
• 13 Turner, Sir James, "Pallas Armata, Military essayes of the ancient Grecian, Roman, and modern art of war written in the years 1670 and 1671" 1683
• 14 Monck, George, "Observations upon Military & Political Affairs" 1671
• 15 Arni, Eric Gruber von, "Hospital Care and the British Standing Army, 1660–1714" Ashgate 2006
• 16 Walton, Clifford, "History of the British Standing Army, A.D. 1660 to 1700" Harrison 1894
• 17 Anon, "Hardwick State Papers: From 1501 to 1726, Vol. 2" 1778
• 18 Childs, John, "General Percy Kirke and the Later Stuart Army" Bloomsbury 2014
• 19 Duffy, Christopher, "Fight for a Throne: The Jacobite '45 Reconsidered" Helion & Company 2015
• 20 Blackmore, David, "Destructive & Formidable: British Infantry Firepower, 1642-1765" Frontline Books 2014
• 21 Black, Jeremy, "Britain As A Military Power" UCL Press 1999
• 22 "BL Lansdowne MS 1152"
• 23 "BL Harley MS 6845"
• 24 Anon, "An Abridgment of English Military Discipline" 1676
• 25 Anon, "An Abridgment of English Military Discipline" 1685
• 26 Anon, "An Abridgment of English Military Discipline" 1686
• 27 Lambert, Andrew, "Admirals: The Naval Commanders who made Britain Great" Faber 2008
• 28 Anon, "A True Relation of the Late Action and Victory against the Rebels in England, near Bridgewater on Monday the 6. Of July 1685 From Several Hands" 1685
• 29 Coad, John, "A Memorandum of the Wonderful Providences of God to a Poor Unworthy Creature During the Time of the Duke of Monmouth's Rebellion and to the Revolution in 1688" Longman, Brownm, Green & Longmans 1849
• 30 윤덕희, "18세기 중반 영국 육군의 전투력 분석 -데팅겐 전투(1743)를 중심으로-" 한국서양사학회 (157) : 69-101, 2023
• 31 윤덕희, "17세기 잉글랜드군 전술 교리의 재검토: 스튜어트 시대 잉글랜드는 군사적으로 낙후되었는가" 영국사학회 (47) : 35-71, 2022
• 32 Lenihan, Pádraig, "1690 Battle of Boyne" Tempus 2003