경로의존성, 정보의 문제, 그리고 공공정책 : E. Ostrom의 신제도주의에 대한 비판적 논의 = Path Dependence, Emphasis on Informational Impactedness and Public Policy: A Critical Review of E. Ostrom's New Institutionalism

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

In this paper, we critically survey what E. Ostrom has tried to solve and how she has done it on the basis of the major work done by her throughout academic life. We identify two major aspects of her approach differentiable from the (traditional) rational choice new institutionalism: path dependence and emphasis on informational impactedness, whose foundation is greatly attributable to the related disciplines surrounding public policies such as economics, sociology, evolutionary biology, psychology, etc. We examine both aspects in building up successful institutions or public policies and derive its implications for policy formulations and evaluations.

국문 초록 (Abstract)

이 논문은 집단행동의 딜레마를 해결하기 위해 E. Ostrom이 수행한 20여년의 연구성과를 비판적으로 고찰하였다. 이를 위해 Ostrom의 학문적 여정에서 주요한 저작으로평가받는 세 권의 저서와 주요 논문들을 두 가지 측면 - 경로의존성과 정보의 문제 -에초점을 맞추어 들여다 봄으로써 그녀의 합리적 선택 신제도주의 입장이 어떻게 “확장”되었는지를 살펴보았다. 보다 구체적으로는 (1) Ostrom의 문제의식, (2) 인접 학문 -경제학, 사회학, 진화생물학, 심리학 등-의 연구성과를 수용한 통섭적 연구 방법, (3)경로의존성과 정보의 중요성이라는 측면에서 Ostrom의 주요 사고틀 및 분석모형 -IAD 분석틀, 사회생태체계(SESs) -의 세 부분으로 나누어 분석하였다. 이를 통해 지역공동체의 자치조직화에 의한 집단행동의 딜레마 해결이라는 Ostrom의 아이디어에서성공적인 제도의 내용 및 과정과 관련하여 끌어낼 수 있는 정책적 함의를 제시하였다.

참고문헌 (Reference)

• 1 도모노 노리오, "행동경제학: 경제를 움직이는 인간 심리의 모든 것" 지형 2007
• 2 이명석, "제도, 공유재 그리고 거버넌스" 한국행정연구소 44 (44): 247-275, 2006
• 3 최정규, "이타적 인간의 출현" 뿌리와이파리 2009
• 4 강은숙, "신제도주의 경제학과 공공정책" 한국정부학회 23 (23): 779-799, 2011
• 5 강은숙, "공유재의 딜레마상황을 극복하기 위한 또 하나의 길: E. Ostrom의 기여와 남겨진 연구과제들" 한국정부학회 25 (25): 531-555, 2013
• 6 이명석, "공유재문제의 자치적 해결가능성" 29 (29): 1291-1312, 1995
• 7 안도경(2012), "공유의 비극을 넘어: 공유자원 관리를 위한 제도의 진화" 랜덤하우스코리아 5 (5): 117-129,
• 8 엘리너 오스트롬, "공유의 비극을 넘어" 랜덤하우스코리아 2010
• 9 Ostrom, Elinor, "Updating the Theory of Collective Action. Seoul National University" 17-53, 2010
• 10 Sethi, R., "Understanding reciprocity" 50 (50): 1-27, 2003
• 11 Ostrom, Elinor., "Understanding Institutional Diversity" Princeton University Press 2005
• 12 Rapopport, A., "Two-Person Game Theory: The Essential Ideas" University of Michigan Press 1966
• 13 Williamson, Oliver E., "Transaction Cost Economics: The Natural Progression" 2009
• 14 Simon, Herbert A., "Theories of Bounded Rationality, In Decision and Organization: A Volume in Honor of Jacob Marschak" North Holland 161-176, 1972
• 15 Ostrom, Elinor., "The institutional analysis and development framework and the Commons" 95 : 807-815, 2010
• 16 Hamilton, William D., "The genetical theory of social behaviour" 7 : 1-52, 1964
• 17 Hardin, Garrett, "The Tragedy of the Commons. Science 162(December), In Debating the Earth: The Environmental Politics Reader" Oxford University Press 1243-1248, 1998
• 18 Williamson, Oliver E., "The Theory of the Firm as Governance Structure: From Choice to Contract" 16 (16): 171-195, 2002
• 19 Dietz, Thomas, "The Struggle to Govern the Commons" 302 (302): 1907-1911, 2003
• 20 Shepsle, K. A., "The Role of Institutional Structure in the Creation of Policy Equilibrium, In Public Policy and Public Choice" Sage 249-281, 1979
• 21 Hayek, Friedrich A., "The Road to Serfdom" University of Chicago Press 1944
• 22 Coase, R. H., "The Problem of Social Cost" 3 : 1-44, 1960
• 23 Coase, R. H., "The Nature of the Firm" 4 : 386-405, 1937
• 24 Shepsle, K. A, "The Institutional Foundations of Committee Power" 81 : 85-104, 1987
• 25 Axelrod, R., "The Evolution of Cooperation" Basic Books 1984
• 26 Hamilton, William D., "The Evolution of Altruistic Behavior" American naturalist 1963
• 27 Axelrod, R., "The Emergence of Cooperation Among Egoists" 75 : 306-318, 1981
• 28 Williamson, Oliver E., "The Economics of Organization: The Transaction Cost Approach" 87 (87): 548-577, 1981
• 29 Gordon, H. S., "The Economic Theory of a Common-Property Resource: The Fishery" 62 : 124-143, 1954
• 30 Shepsle, K. A., "Studying Institutions. Some Lessons from the Rational Choice Approach" 1 : 131-149, 1989
• 31 Economic Science Prize Committee of the Royal Swedish Academy of Science, "Scientific Background on the Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences in Memory of Alfred Nobel 2009"
• 32 Agrawal, Arun., "Rules, Rule Making, and Rule Breaking: Examining the Fit between Rule Systems and Resource Use, In Rules, Games, and Common-Pool Resources. ch. 12" The University of Michigan Press 1994
• 33 Ostrom, Elinor, "Rules, Games, and Common-Pool Resources" The University of Michigan Press 1994
• 34 Ostrom, Elinor., "Revising theory in light of experimental findings" 73 : 68-72, 2010
• 35 Kreps, D. M., "Rational Cooperation in the Finitely Repeated Prisoner's Dilemma" 27 : 245-252, 1982
• 36 Ostrom, Elinor., "Rational Choice Theory and Institutional Analysis: Toward Complementarity" 85 (85): 237-243, 1991
• 37 Rapopport, A., "Provision of Public Goods and MCS Experimental Paradigm" 79 : 148-155, 1985
• 38 Kahneman, Daniel, "Prospect Theory: An Analysis of Decision under Risk" 47 (47): 263-291, 1979
• 39 Kahneman, Daniel, "Prospect Theory: An Analysis of Decision under Risk" 47 (47): 263-291, 1979
• 40 Schlager, Edella, "Property-Rights Regimes and Natural Resources: A Conceptual Analysis" 68 (68): 249-262, 1992
• 41 Hall, Peter A, "Political Science and the Three New Institutionalism" ⅩLⅣ : 936-957, 1996
• 42 Lecours, A, "New institutionalism: Theory and Analysis" University of Toronto Press 2005
• 43 Simon, Herbert A., "Models of Man" Wiley 1957
• 44 Smith, Vernon L., "Mind, Reciprocity, and Markets in the Laboratory" 21 : 2001
• 45 Smith, Vernon L., "Microeconomic Systems as an Experimental Science" 72 : 923-955, 1982
• 46 Williamson, Oliver E., "Markets and Hierarchies: Analysis and Antitrust Implications" Free Press 1975
• 47 Tversky, A., "Judgment under Uncertainty: Heuristics and Biases" 185 : 1124-1131, 1974
• 48 Ostrom, Elinor., "Institutions and The Environment: the economic analysis of institutions" 24-31, 2008
• 49 Ostrom, Elinor., "Institutional Rational Choice: An Assessment of the Institutional Analysis and Development Framework, In Theories of the Policy Process. Part Ⅱ" Alternative Views of the Role of Rationality in the Policy Press. Westview Press 2007
• 50 Shepsle, K. A., "Institutional Arrangements and Equilibrium in Multidimensional Voting Models" 23 : 27-60, 1979
• 51 Poteete, A. R, "Heterogeneity, Group Size and Collective Action:The Role of Institutions in Forest Management" 35 (35): 435-461, 2004
• 52 Ostrom, Elinor., "Governing the Commons: The Evolution of Institutions for Collective Action" Cambridge Press 1990
• 53 Ostrom, Elinor, "Going beyond Panaceas" 104 (104): 15176-15178, 2007
• 54 Ostrom, Elinor., "Frameworks and theories of environmental change" 18 : 249-252, 2008
• 55 Coleman, J. S., "Foundations of Social Theory" Harvard University Press 1990
• 56 Price, George R., "Extension of Covariance Selection Mathematics" 35 : 485-490, 1972
• 57 Ostrom, Elinor., "Coping with Tragedies of the Commons" 2 : 493-535, 1999
• 58 Bate, R. H., "Contra Contractarianism: Some Reflections on the New Institutionalism" 16 : 387-401,
• 59 Blomquist, William., "Changing Rules, Changing Cames: Evidence from Groundwater Systems in Southern California, In Rules, Games, and Common-Pool Resources. ch. 13" The University of Michigan Press 1994
• 60 Ostrom, Elinor., "Challenges and growth: the development of the interdisciplinary field of institutional analysis" 3 (3): 239-264, 2007
• 61 Ostrom, Elinor., "Beyond Markets and States: Polycentric Governance of Complex Economic Systems" 100 : 1-33, 2010
• 62 Crawford, Sue, "A Grammar of Institutions, In Understanding Institutional Diversity. ch. 5" Princeton University Press 137-174, 2005
• 63 Ostrom, Elinor., "A General Framework for Analyzing Sustainability of Social-Ecological Systems" 325 : 419-422, 2009
• 64 Simon, Herbert A., "A Behavioural Model of Rational Choice" 69 : 99-188, 1955
• 65 Ostrom, Elinor., "A Behavioral Approach to the Rational Choice Theory of Collective Action" 92 (92): 362-383, 1998