중국과 소련의 핵 기술 개발 협력 재고, 1945~1960 = Rethinking Sino-Soviet Cooperation for Nuclear Technology, 1945~1960

국문 초록 (Abstract)

본고는 1946년에서 1960년대까지 중화인민공화국의 핵무기 및 원자력 산업 발전과 연관된 중·소 핵 기술 협력을 탐구하는 것을 목적으로 한다. 이 주제에 대한 대부분의 중국 측 연구들은 초기 중화인민공화국 지도부가 자체 핵 개발 계획을 시작하기로 결정한 1955년을 두 사회주의 국가들 사이의 핵 협력에서 중요한 전기로 보고 있다. 그러나 본고는 중화인민공화국 건설 초기에 이미 히로시마 원폭 투하직후 원자폭탄 보유의 전략적 중요성을 깨달았고, 중국의 지속적인 핵무기 보유 노력이 중소분쟁뿐만 아니라 중소동맹 형성에 기여했음을 주장한다. 특히 본고에서는 1940년대 후반부터 1960년대 중반까지 중소협력 과정 전반을 보면 중소 핵 협력문제의 연속성이 강조된다는 점에 주목한다. 대표적으로 초기 중소경제협력 과정에서 설립된 중소금속공사나, 무엇보다도 모스크바 근교 두브나에 건설된 연합원자력연구소에서 이러한 중요한 협력의 예를 확인할 수 있다.

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

This paper explores Sino-Soviet cooperation over the development of nuclear weapons and industries in the Peoples Republic of China(PRC) roughly from 1946 to 1960. Most studies from Chinese side on the topic view the year of 1955 when the early PRC leadership decided to start its own nuclear program as a crucial turning point for the nuclear cooperation between the two leading socialist nations. But the paper argues that the early PRC under Chinese Communist Party had been well aware of the strategic and political significance of possessing an atomic bomb from right after Hiroshima. And the continued national quest for nuclear weapon contributed to the formation of Sino-Soviet alliance as well as the Sino-Soviet split. Primary concern of the paper is to emphasize the continuity of the issue by examining the Sino-Soviet cooperative activities from late 1940s to mid-1960. The cases of Sino-Soviet Joint Stock Nonferrous and Rare Metals Company and the Institute for Joint Nuclear Research at Dubna, above all, could be suggested as remarkable examples of the cooperation.

참고문헌 (Reference)

• 1 손한별, "중국 핵전력의 발전과 핵전략의 변화" 신아시아연구소 21 (21): 128-150, 2014
• 2 毛澤東, "論人民民主主義專政"
• 3 李覺, "當代中國的核工業" 中國社科學出版社社 1987
• 4 謝光, "當代中國的國防科技事業 1" 當代中國出版社 1992
• 5 林雙幸, "新疆鈾礦資源開發回顧及未來前景" 新疆維吾爾自治區地質學會 20 (20): 103-105, 2002
• 6 沈志華, "援助與限制: 蘇聯與中國的核武器硏制(1949~1960)" 中國社會科學杂志社 (3) : 110-131, 2004
• 7 趙忠堯, "我的回憶: 物理學家回憶錄" 中國科學院高能物理硏究所 (1) : 28-29, 1993
• 8 趙忠堯, "我的回憶: 物理學家回憶錄" 中國科學院高能物理硏究所 (6) : 11-12, 1992
• 9 趙忠堯, "我的回憶: 物理學家回憶錄" 中國科學院高能物理硏究所 (2) : 43-44, 1993
• 10 吳文瓏, "從引進到贖回: 新中國初期的中蘇合資企業" 中共黨史硏究室 (3) : 44-53, 2013
• 11 戴超武, "中國核武器的發展與中蘇關系的破裂" 中國社會科學院當代中國硏究所 (3) : 76-85, 2001
• 12 平松茂雄, "中國の核戰力" 勁草書房̄ 1996
• 13 В. В. Кротков ред, "Как искали и добывали уран: сб. статей-воспоминаний" 2002
• 14 "За коммунизм 1957 №. 2, 16 Ноя."
• 15 К. С. Медведь, "Велихова, История советского атомного проекта (40-е~50-е годы): междунар. симп. т. 3" 2003
• 16 Рябев, Л. Д., "Атомный проэкт СССР: Документы и материалы. Том 2. Атомная бомба 1945~1954" 1 : 2003
• 17 Heinzig, Dieter, "The Soviet Union and Communist China, 1945~1950: the Arduous road to the alliance" M.E. Sharp 1950
• 18 Lühi, Lorenz M., "The Sino-Soviet Split: Cold War in the Communist World" Princeton University Press 2008
• 19 Zagoria, Donald S., "The Sino-Soviet Split, 1956~1960" Princeton University Press 1962
• 20 Gobarev, Viktor M, "Soviet policy toward China: Developing nuclear weapons 1949~1969" 12 (12): 1-53, 1999
• 21 Zuberi, Martin, "Soviet and American technological assistance and the pace of Chinese nuclear tests" 24 (24): 1247-1266, 2000
• 22 Central Intelligence Agency, "Soviet Economic Assistance to the Sino-Soviet Bloc Countries"
• 23 Schmid, S., "Producing power: the pre-Chernobyl history of the Soviet nuclear industry" The MIT Press 2015
• 24 Harrison, Henrietta, "Popular Responses to the Atomic Bomb in China 1945~1955" 218 (218): 98-116, 2013
• 25 Sidorenko, Viktor A, "Nuclear power in the Soviet Union and in Russia" 173 (173): 3-20, 1997
• 26 Semenov, B. A., "Nuclear power in the Soviet Union" 25 (25): 47-59, 1983
• 27 Nan, Y. T., "Note on Some Uranium Minerals from Eastern Kuangsi" 23 (23): 169-172, 1943
• 28 Shen, Zhihua, "Mao and the Sino-Soviet Partnership, 1945~1959: A New History" Lexington Books 2015
• 29 "John Trump Dies; Engineer was 78"
• 30 Lewis, John, "China builds the Bomb" Stanford University Press 1991
• 31 Hu, Danian, "China and Albert Einstein: The Reception and the physicist and his theory in China, 1917~1979" Harvard University Press 1979
• 32 Westad, Odd Arne, "Brothers in Arms: The Rise and Fall of the Sino-Soviet Alliance, 1945~1963" Stanford University Press 1998
• 33 Zhihua Shen, "Between Aid and Restriction: The Soviet Union’s Changing Policies on China’s Nuclear Weapons Program, 1954–1960" 극동문제연구소 36 (36): 95-122, 2012
• 34 Shen, Zhihua, "Between Aid and Restriction: Changing Soviet Policies toward China’s Nuclear Weapons Program: 1954~1960" Wilson Center 2012
• 35 Zhang, Shu Guang, "Beijing’s Economic Statecraft during the Cold War, 1949~1991" Johns Hopkins University Press 2014
• 36 Liu, Yanqiong, "Analysis of Soviet Technology Transfer in the Development of China’s Nuclear Weapons" 7 (7): 66-110, 2009