독재는 민주주의의 반의어(反意語)인가? －대중독재의 모순어법과 민주주의의 민주화－ = Featured Articles : Democracy in the Western History; Mass Dictatorship as a Conceptual Oxymoron: How Are Dictatorships Interwoven with Democracies?

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Mass dictatorship as a working hypothesis was designed to challenge the antithetical comparison of dictatorship and democracy inherent to the old school of totalitarian scholarship and the political common sense of the demonological dichotomy in the Cold War era. Initiated by the problematics of how to democratize democracy, the mass dictatorship thesis raises a set of questions: what if majoritarian democracy in the modern nation-state is based on the categorization of minorities as ``Others`` in terms of nation, class, gender, race, ethnicity and so on? What if the majority tyrannize minorities? Is that democracy or is it dictatorship? In answering these questions, it tries to comprehend the common ground between twentieth century mass dictatorships and mass democracies in their attempted mobilization of masses to participate voluntarily in and to support the regime. By locating the Holocaust in the context of the continuity of ``Western`` colonialism rather than by recourse to German peculiarities, the mass dictatorship thesis bridges between Western modernity and German peculiarity in perpetrating genocide. What I mean is not that dictatorship is the same as democracy, but that the dividing line is blurred much more than what was previously thought. That critical overview of the interwoven history of mass dictatorships and mass democracies in the twentieth century would lead us to a self-reflexive question of how to democratize democracies in the twenty first century.

참고문헌 (Reference)

• 1 Robert Paxton, "파시즘" 교양인 2005
• 2 Simon Wiesenthal, "제노사이드" 책세상 106-, 2005
• 3 Carl Schmitt, "정치신학 외" 법문사 102-, 1998
• 4 김용우, "이탈리아 파시즘－강제적 동의에서 문화적 동의로, In 대중독재 I" 73-75,
• 5 스벤 린트크비스트, "야만의 역사" 41-,
• 6 Sven Lindqvist, "야만의 역사" 한겨레신문사 244-, 2002
• 7 Christopher Browning, "아주 평범한 사람들" 책과함께 2010
• 8 최장집, "민주주의의 민주화" 후마니타스 2006
• 9 임지현, "마르크스/엥겔스와 민족문제" 탐구당 127-144, 1990
• 10 임지현, "독재와 민주주의의 근대적 기원, In 근대의 경계에서 독재를 읽다" 35-,
• 11 임지현, "대중독재: 강제와 동원의 사이에서" 책세상 17-55, 2004
• 12 스테판 버거, "대중독재1: 강제와 동의 사이에서" 책세상 149-174, 2004
• 13 김학이, "나치독재와 대중, In 근대의 경계에서 독재를 읽다" 그린비 126-127, 2006
• 14 Jürgen Zimmerer, "die Geburt des Ostlandes.." 31-32,
• 15 Karl D. Bracher, "Zeitgeschichtlichen Kontroversen: Um Faschismus, Totalitarianismus" Demokratie 1976
• 16 Jeroen van der Waal, "Why Are in Some European Countries Immigrants Considered Less Entitled to Welfare?"
• 17 Michael Halberstam, "Totalitarianism and the Modern Conception of Politics" 2-, 1999
• 18 Kyu Hyun Kim, "Total war mobilisation and transformation of the national public sphere in Japan, 1931-1945"
• 19 Drakulić, "They would never hurt a fly: war criminals on trial in the Hague" 2004
• 20 Michael Burleigh, "The Third Reich: A New History" 427-, 2001
• 21 Roger Griffin, "The Palingenetic Political Community: Rethinking the Legitimation of Totalitarian Regimes in Inter-war Europe" 3 : 29-, 2002
• 22 Jacob L. Talmon, "The Origins of Totalitarian Democracy" 1-3, 1970
• 23 Ian Kershaw, "The Nazi Dictatorship: Problems and Perspectives of Interpretation" 2000
• 24 George L. Mosse, "The Fascist Revolution" 76-, 1999
• 25 Michael Mann, "The Dark Side of Democracy: Explaining Ethnic Cleansing" Cambridge University Press 2005
• 26 Jie-Hyun Lim, "Series Introduction-Mapping mass dictatorship: towards a transnational history of twentieth century dictatorship, In Gender Politics and Mass Dictatorship: Global Perspectives. Mass Dictatorship in the 20th Century series vol. 1" 1-22, 2011
• 27 Richard Evans, "Rethinking German History" 27-44, 1987
• 28 Arie Dubnov, "Priest or Jester? Jacob L. Talmon (1916-1980) on history and intellectual engagement" 34 : 137-138, 2008
• 29 Peter Fritzsche, "Nazi Modern" 3 (3): 7-, 1996
• 30 Zygmunt Bauman, "Modernity and Holocaust" 227-228,
• 31 Simon Tormey, "Making Sense of Tyranny: Interpretations of Totalitarianism" 115-, 1995
• 32 Richard J. Evans, "Kisses for the Duce" 35 (35): 6-, 2013
• 33 H. Malcom MacDonald, "Karl Marx, Friedrich Engels and the South Slavic Problem in 1848-9" 9 : 457-, 1939
• 34 박선주, "Imagining Mass Dictatorships: The Individual and the Masses in Literature and Cinema" Palgrave MacMillan 2013
• 35 Paul Corner, "Habermas, Fascism and the Public Sphere"
• 36 Elaine Jeffreys, "Governmentality, governance and China, In China’s Governmentalities: governing change, changing government" Routledge 1-23, 2009
• 37 Susan Mayhew, "Governmentality, In A Dictionary of Geography" Oxford University Press 2004
• 38 Ulrich Herbert, "Good Times, Bad Times: Memories of the Third Reich, In Life in the Third Reich" Oxford University Press 102-108, 1987
• 39 Benjamin Madley, "From Africa to Auschwitz: How German South West Africa Incubated Ideas and Methods Adopted and Developed by the Nazis in Eastern Europe?" 35 (35): 435-, 2005
• 40 Ruth Ben-Ghiat, "Fascist Modernities: Italy, 1922-1945" University of California Press 6-, 2001
• 41 Hannah Arendt, "Eichmann in Jerusalem: A Report on the Banality of Evil" 1994
• 42 Jürgen Zimmerer, "Die Geburt des >Ostlandes< aus dem Geiste des Kolonialismus. Die nationalsozialistische Eroberungs-und Beherrschungspolitik in (post-)kolonialer Perspektive" 19 (19): 18-21, 2004
• 43 Mark Mazower, "Dark Continent: Europe’s Twentieth Century" 13-, 1998
• 44 Jie-Hyun Lim, "Befreiung oder Modernisierung? Sozialismus als ein Weg der anti-westlichen Modernisierung in unterwickelten Laendern" 43 (43): 5-23, 2001