중국의 영향력 균형(balance of influence) 전략과 제3세계 외교: 과거의 경험, 그리고 오늘날의 함의 = China's Balance of Influence Strategy and the Third World Diplomacy: Focused on Past Experience and Today's Implications

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Recently China strengthens charm offensive diplomacy toward the third world. The development of this aggressive diplomacy was perceived as a challenge for the United States' influence on international society. China's such third world diplomacy can be characterized as a great powers' balance of influence strategy that aims to increase influence in the third world. The purpose of this paper is to evaluate China's third world diplomacy in the concept of "balance of influence", and reevaluate China's third world diplomacy in the past within this framework. As a result, this paper will show that China's diplomacy today toward the third world is not different from the past from the respect of its goal and intention. Accordingly neighboring countries states has to make a effort to identify between diplomatic rhetoric and substance.

국문 초록 (Abstract)

최근 들어 중국은 제3세계에 대한 외교적 공세를 강화하고 있다. 제3세계에 대한 중국의 적극적인 외교의 전개는 국제사회에 대한 미국의 영향력에 도전으로 인식되는 것이기도 하다. 중국이 제3세계 외교를 강화하고 있는 목적과 의도는 무엇인가. 본 연구는 중국의 제3세계 외교의 주요 목적을 강대국들이 추구하는 영향력 균형 전략으로 규정한다. 그리고 이러한 분석 시각으로 냉전시기 중국의 제3세계 외교의 전개과정과 결과를 재검토해보고, 과거의 경험이 오늘날에 갖는 함의를 도출해 보는 것을 주요 목적으로 한다. 냉전시기 중국이 제3세계 외교가 주변 강대국과 (패권적 의도가 내재된) 영향력 균형의 추구를 특징으로 했던 것처럼, 오늘날 중국의 제3세계 외교에도 이러한 전략적 목적과 의도가 내재되어 있을 수 있다. 실제로 최근 국제사회는 소프트 파워와 같은 다양한 외교적 수단을 이용한 강대국들 간의 치열한 영향력 경쟁이 전개될 가능성이 높아지고 있다. 따라서 주변 약소국들은 공정한 시각과 외교적 자율성을 가지고 이들 강대국들의 외교적 수사와 실제를 구별하려는 노력이 필요하다.

참고문헌 (Reference)

• 1 송종환, "한국전쟁에 대한 소련의 전략적 목표에 관한 연구" 39 (39): 1999
• 2 최명, "특집2 십전대회이후 중공의 향방 - 중공의 지도자와 지도체제, 중공경제의 진로와 대외무역, 중소분쟁의 신 전개와 한반도" (22) : 1973
• 3 김종휘, "특집(特輯) : 소련혁명(蘇聯革命) 50년(年)의「이데올로기」와 정책(政策) ; 논총(論叢) : 중소분쟁(中蘇紛爭)" 24 : 1968
• 4 신종호, "중국의 소프트파워 외교의 전개와 국제정치적 함의" 세종연구소 15 (15): 33-64, 2009
• 5 김애경, "중국의 부상과 소프트파워 전략: 대 아프리카 정책을 사례로" 세종연구소 14 (14): 143-168, 2008
• 6 조영남, "중국외교의 새로운 시도:‘ 소프트파워’전략 in:중국외교연구의 새로운 영역" 나남 179-233, 2008
• 7 김예경, "중국과 베트남 간의 영토분쟁과 해결방식" 동북아역사재단 2008
• 8 유세희, "중·소의 북한에 대한 영향력 경쟁에 관한 연구" 12 (12): 1988
• 9 박창희, "전략의 패러독스 : 비대칭전쟁에서의‘결전’과‘약자의 승리’" 한국정치학회 43 (43): 323-343, 2009
• 10 양승윤, "인도네시아정치론" 명지출판사 1990
• 11 에드워드 사이드, "오리엔탈리즘" 교보문고 2007
• 12 고병철, "북한의 시각에서 본 중소분쟁" (23) : 1973
• 13 하영선, "변환의 세계정치" 을유문화사 2007
• 14 장융, "마오: 알려지지 않은 이야기들(하)" 까치 2005
• 15 서보근, "냉전시기 중소 분쟁이 한반도에 미친 영향" 대한정치학회 13 (13): 281-297, 2006
• 16 고명식, "공산권의 연구" 4·5 : 1965
• 17 程重陽, "黨對國際環境認識與大躍進的發動" 6 : 1997
• 18 張驥, "軟國力與蘇聯解體" 4 : 2001
• 19 齊長安, "軟國力爭與中國的戰略選擇" 河北師範大學碩士究生學位論文 2002
• 20 戴超武, "肯尼迪- 翰遜期的外交第三世界" 3 : 2006
• 21 當代中國編輯委員會, "當代中國外交" 中國社會科學出版社 1990
• 22 柳家欽, "毛澤東在1958年發動大躍進的國際因素分析" 2 : 2004
• 23 賈慶國, "意識形態對於一國外交具有特殊的意義" 21 : 2002
• 24 閻學通, "意識形態對外交政策的影響無法回避" 21 : 2002
• 25 袁玉虎, "從中蘇關係的演變看大躍進的動因(1958-1960)-兼論中蘇關係的分裂" 外交學院碩士究生學位論文 2005
• 26 張淸敏, "對衆多國家的一個相同政策- 淺析中國對發展中國家的政策" 8 (8): 2001
• 27 任貴笭, "大躍進發生原因究綜述" 1 : 2008
• 28 袁易, "中起之再省思：現實與認知" 立政治大學國際關係硏究中心 2005
• 29 閻學通, "中美軟實力比較" 1 : 2008
• 30 戴超武, "中國核武器的發展與中蘇關係的破裂(連載二)" 5 : 2001
• 31 戴超武, "中國核武器的發展與中蘇關係的破裂(連載一)" (3) : 2001
• 32 吴天, "中國對外援助政策分析" 外交學院碩士究生學位論文 2004
• 33 Wesson, Robert G, "Why Marxism?" Basic Books 107-, 1976
• 34 Kang, David C, "Why China’s Rise will be peaceful" 30 (30): 585-608, 2007
• 35 Ciorciari, John David, "The balance of great-power influence in contemporary Southeast Asia" 9 : 2009
• 36 Mearsheimer, John J, "The Tragedy of Great Power Politics" W.W. Norton & Company 2001
• 37 Goldston, Robert C, "The Rise of Red China" Fawcett 1967
• 38 Percival, Bronson, "The Dragon Looks South: China and Southeast Asia in the New Century" Praeger Security Internatronal 2007
• 39 Holsti, K. J, "The Concept of Power in the Study of International Relations" 7 (7): 179-, 1964
• 40 Bernstein, Richard, "The Coming Conflict With China" Alfred A. Knopf 1997
• 41 Kroef. Justus M. van der, "Soviet and Chinese Influence in Indonesia.. in: Soviet and Chinese Influence in the Third World" Praeger Publishers 51-87, 1975
• 42 Justus M. van der Kroef in:Soviet and Ch, "Soviet and Chinese Influence in Indonesia" Praeger Publishers 51-87, 1975
• 43 Nye, Joseph S, "Soft Power: The Means to Sucess in World Politics" Public Affairs 2004
• 44 Goldstein, Avery, "Rising to The Challenge: China’s Grand Stratey and International Security" Stanford University Press 2005
• 45 Holsti, K. J., "Power, Capability, and Influence in International Politics in: The Global Agenda: Issues and Perspectives" McGraw-Hill 11-23, 1998
• 46 Goh, Evelyn, "Meeting the China Challenge" East-West Center 16 : 2005
• 47 Meisner, Maurice, "Mao’s China and After: A History of the People’s Republicthird edition" The Free Press 107-114, 1999
• 48 Johnston, Alastair Iain, "Is China a Status Quo Power?" 27 (27): 2003
• 49 Paine, S.C.M, "Imperial Rivals: China, Russia, and Their Disputed Frontier" M.E.Sharpe 1996
• 50 Carlsnaes, Walter, "Ideology and Foreign Policy: Problems of Comparative Conceptualization" Blackwell Publishers 1987
• 51 Zagoria, Donald S, "Ideology and Chinese Foreign Policy. in: Ideology and Foreign Policy" Cyrco Press 116-, 1978
• 52 Mathisen, Trygve, "How the Giants Wield their Influence. in: The Functions of Small States in the Strategies of the Great Powers" Universitetsforlaget 207-237, 1971
• 53 Mitchell, Derek, "Expanding the“ Strategic Periphery”: A History of China’s Interaction with the Developing World. in: China and the Developing World: Beijing’s Strategy for the Twenty-first Century" M.E.Sharpe 3-25, 2009
• 54 Heginbotham, Eric, "Evaluation China’s Strategy Toward the Developing World. in: China and the Developing World: Beijing’s Strategy for the Twenty-first Century" M.E.Sharpe 189-216, 2009
• 55 Cooley, John K, "East Wind Over Africa: Red China’s African Offensive" Walker and Company 1966
• 56 Barnett, A. Doak, "Communist Economic Strategy: The Rise of Mainland China" National Planning Association Place of Publication 1959
• 57 Barnett, A. Doak, "Communist China and Asia: Challenge to American Policy" Harper & Brothers 1960
• 58 Smith, Sarah-Ann, "China’s Third World Policy as a Counterpoint to the First and Second Worlds. in: China and the Third World: Champion or Challenger?" House Publishing Company 53-74, 1986
• 59 Cho, Young Nam, "China’s Soft Power: Discussions, Resources, and Prospects" 48 (48): 2008
• 60 Keller, William W, "China’s Rise and the Balance of Influence in Asia" Universe of Pittsburgh Press 2007
• 61 Dai, Shen-Yu, "China, the Superpowers and the Third World: A Handbook on Comparative World Politics" The Chinese University of Hong Kong 1974
• 62 Kornberg, Judith F, "China in World Politics: Policies, Processes, Prospects" Lynne Rienner Publishers, Inc 255-259, 2005
• 63 Alden, Chris, "China in Africa" Zen Books 2007
• 64 Ness, Peter Van, "China and the Third World: Patterns of Engagement and Indiference. in: China and the World: Chinese Foreign Policy Faces the New Millennium - 4th edition" Westview 151-168, 1998
• 65 Harris, Lillian Craig, "China and the Third World: Champion or Challenger?" Auburn House Publishing Company 1986
• 66 Eisenman, Joshua, "China and the Developing World: Beijing’s Strategy for the Twenty-First Century" M.E.Sharpe, Inc 2007
• 67 Kim, Samuel S, "China and The Third World: In Search of A Peace and Development Line in: China and the World: New Directions in Chinese Foreign Relations - 2nd edition" Westview Press 148-178, 1989
• 68 Kim, Samuel S, "China and The Third World: In Search of A Neorealist World policy. in: China and the World: Chinese Foreign Policy in the Post-Mao Era" Westview Press 178-211, 1984
• 69 Kim, Samuel S, "China and The Third World in the Changing World Order in: China and the World: Chinese Foreign Relations in the Post-Cold War Era - 3rd edition" Westview Press 128-168, 1994
• 70 Larkin, Bruce D, "China and Africa 1949-1970: The Foreign Policy of People’s Republic of China" University of California Press 1971
• 71 Belden, Jack, "China Shakes the World" Monthly Review Press 1970
• 72 Brautigam, Deborah, "China Aid and Africal Development: Exporting Green Revolution" St. Martin’s Press 1998
• 73 Kurlantzick, Joshua, "Charm Offensive: How China’s Soft Power Is Transforming the World" Yale University Press 2007
• 74 Nye, Joseph S, "Bound to Lead: The Changing Nature of American Power" Basic Books 1990
• 75 Ross, Robert S, "Balance of Power Politics and the Rise of China: Accomodation and Balancing in East Asia. in: China’s Rise and the Balance of Influence in Asia" Universe of Pittsburgh Press 121-148, 2007
• 76 Moon, Chung-in, "Balance of Influence vs. Balance of Power: An Eclectic Approach for East Asian Security. in: Northeast Asian Regional Security Order and Strategic Calculus on the Taiwan Straits" Yonsei University Press 2003
• 77 Rothstein, L. Robert, "Alliances and Small Powers" Columbia University Press 1968
• 78 周軍, "21世紀國際關係中的軟國力,”『連云港業技術學院學報』第4期.“建設和諧世界: 中國外交思想的新發展,”『半月談』(06/08/23)"
• 79 이미경, "1950-60년대 북한·중국·소련 삼각관계의 형성과 균열" 아태지역연구센터 26 (26): 81-106, 2002