중국인민지원군 단독철군 문제 재론

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

In 1958, Chinese People’s Volunteers (CPV) withdrew from North Korea. It was a unilateral withdrawal while the United States Armed Force remained in South Korea. In 1956, there was a growing demand inside North Korea for withdrawal of CPV, which led to the decision at the end of 1956. It appears that North Korea did not make official request for the Chinese army to withdraw, because: first, there is no official document disclosed mentioning such request; second, such record has not been found in any document from the USSR. If North Korea demanded withdrawal of PVA, the USSR must have known it; third, the record of the meeting between Mao Zedong and Kim Ilsung in November 1957 suggests North Korea did not raise the issue.
However, more importantly, inside North Korea, an increasing number of people were calling for withdrawal of CPV and the Chinese government was also acutely aware of this. In other words, China was also feeling the pressure of the demand to withdraw their army from from North Korea. In that regard, the decision to withdraw CPV was not solely made by the Chinese government. Rather, it was made as a result of pressure.
China initially demanded all foreign military forces withdraw simultaneously from the Korean peninsula. However, in late 1956, they changed their position to withdraw their army unilaterally. The change in their position implied the necessity to change their policy toward North Korea and improve the relationship between the two governments. As a result, the Chinese government changed their position regarding the August incident and implemented more relaxed policy toward North Korea, which was largely influenced by the Eastern Europe conflict between Poland and Hungary that threatened the solidarity among socialist governments.
Therefore, the Chinese government made the decision to withdraw their army from North Korea was made after they changed their policy toward North Korea. China was well aware of the discontent and concerns of North Korea regarding presence of the Chinese army in their land. And China tried to bring North Korea closer by responding to their request, such as withdrawing the Chinese army from North Korea. However, the North Korea-China relationship did not suffer during the Eastern Europe crisis and China did not immediately notify North Korea of their decision to withdraw CPV. The official agreement on the withdrawal was made a year later, in November 1957.

목차 (Table of Contents)

• Ⅰ. 서론
• Ⅱ. 북한이 철군을 요구했는가?
• Ⅲ. 모택동의 의심: 헝가리 사태의 영향
• Ⅳ. ‘동시철군’에서 ‘단독철군’으로
• Ⅴ. 결론
• 참고문헌
• Abstract

참고문헌 (Reference)

• 1 이웅현, "헝가리 침공과 흐루시초프 : 1956년 10월 23일-11월 4일, 위기의13일간" 세종연구소 1999
• 2 장삼열, "한미동맹 60년사" 군사편찬연구소 2013
• 3 김용현, "한국전쟁 이후 중국인민지원군의 역할에 관한 연구" 북한연구학회 10 (10): 149-164, 2006
• 4 와다 하루끼, "한국전쟁" 창비 2003
• 5 沈志華, "최후의 천조 : 모택동 김일성 시대의 중국과 북한" 선인 2017
• 6 박영실, "중국인민지원군과 북ㆍ중 관계" 선인 2012
• 7 한상준, "중국인민지원군 철군의 원인과 중·북 관계" 국제지역연구원 19 (19): 5-39, 2012
• 8 김일영, "주한미군 역사ㆍ쟁점ㆍ전망" 한울 2014
• 9 서울신문사, "주한미군 30년" 행림출판사 1979
• 10 김동길, "제2의 해방: 북한 자주화와 1956- 57년의 중국-북한관계" 세종연구소 20 (20): 69-108, 2014
• 11 한상준, "안보위협에 대한 공동인식과 북중관계의 ‘탄성’" 대구사학회 129 : 397-426, 2017
• 12 김용현, "북한의 군사국가화에 관한 연구 : 1950∼60년대를 중심으로" 동국대학교 대학원 2002
• 13 박종철, "북한에서 ‘중국인민지원군’의 철군을 둘러싼 북중관계 연구" 5 : 2008
• 14 국사편찬위원회, "북한관계사료집 75 : 조선민주주의인민공화국 주재 소련 대사의 일지 3" 국사편찬위원회 2014
• 15 국사편찬위원회, "북한관계사료집 74 : 조선민주주의인민공화국 주재 소련 대사의 일지 2" 국사편찬위원회 2013
• 16 국사편찬위원회, "북한관계사료집 73 : 조선민주주의인민공화국 주재 소련 대사의 일지 1" 국사편찬위원회 2013
• 17 이종석, "북한 주둔 중국인민지원군 철수에 관한 연구" 19 : 2014
• 18 서동만, "북조선 사회주의체제 성립사(1945-1961)" 선인 2005
• 19 "로동신문"
• 20 국사편찬위원회, "남북관계사료집 1" 국사편찬위원회 1994
• 21 한상준, "韓國戰爭 停戰 以後, 中國人民志願軍 撤軍問題를 둘러싼 北ㆍ中의 異見과 軋轢" 중국근현대사학회 (75) : 123-146, 2017
• 22 "毛澤東第二次接見蘇共中央代表團談話記錄"
• 23 "毛澤東接見蘇共中央代表團談話記錄"
• 24 "毛澤東接見朝鮮代表團談話紀要"
• 25 "毛澤東接見尤金談話記錄"
• 26 中共中央文獻硏究室, "毛澤東年譜(一九四九-一九七六)" 中央文獻出版社 2013
• 27 中共中央文獻硏究室, "毛澤東傳(1949-1976) 上" 中央文獻出版社 2003
• 28 中共中央文獻硏究室, "楊尙昆日記 上" 中央文獻出版社 2001
• 29 福凱斯, "東歐共産主義的興衰" 中央編譯出版社 1998
• 30 中共中央文獻硏究室, "朱德年譜(新編本)1886-1976 (下)" 中央文獻出版社 2006
• 31 韓相俊, "朝鮮戰後中朝關係從危機到緩和的歷史考察-以中共中央對朝鮮八月事件的態度變化爲中心" 北京大學 2017
• 32 軍事科學院軍事歷史硏究部, "抗美援朝戰爭史 第三卷" 軍事科學出版社 2000
• 33 新華社, "志願軍與朝鮮人民關係中存在的一些問題"
• 34 中共中央文獻編輯委員會, "周恩來選集 (下)" 人民出版社 1984
• 35 中共中央文獻硏究室, "周恩來年譜 (1949∼1976) (中)" 中央文獻出版社 1997
• 36 田武雄, "同聲異氣: 中國1958年從朝鮮全部撤軍方案的形成" (5) : 2014
• 37 新華社, "停戰以來志願軍與朝鮮黨政軍民關係中的若干問題"
• 38 沈志華, "俄羅斯解密檔案選編: 中蘇關係 (1956.10-1958.3) 第7卷" 東方出版中心 2015
• 39 "人民日報"
• 40 中共中央黨史硏究室, "中華人民共和國大事記(1949-2009)" 人民出版社 2009
• 41 "中國外交部檔案"
• 42 田武雄, "中國人民志願軍撤軍回國的若干史實考辨" (2) : 2015
• 43 田武雄, "中國人民志願軍從朝鮮撤軍問題硏究" 北京大學 2015
• 44 沈志華, "一九五六年十月危機: 中國的角色和影向-波匈事件與中國硏究之一" (2) : 2005
• 45 沈志華, "‘脣齒相依’還是‘政治聯姻’?-中朝同盟的建立及其延續(1946~1961)" (63) : 2009
• 46 Mark Kramer, "The Soviet Union and the 1956 Crises in Hungary and Poland: Reassessments and New Findings" 33 (33): 1998
• 47 "Foreign Relations of the United States(FRUS) 1955∼1957 Vol. XⅩIII" .S. Government Printing Office 1993
• 48 "A/3251) Hungary: request for the inclusion of an additional item in the agenda of the General Assembly, 1 November 1956"
• 49 김택빈, "1958년, 위기의 북한과 중국의 선택: 북한 주둔 중국군 철수의 원인과 배경" 평화문제연구소 27 (27): 69-99, 2015
• 50 이상숙, "1958년 북한주둔 중국인민지원군 철수의 원인과 영향 : 북한의 대중국 협력 확대와 대중동원 경제노선 강화를 중심으로" 북한연구학회 13 (13): 83-107, 2009