러시아 천연가스 전략 중심이동의 원인, 경과, 지속가능성: 상호의존의 관점 = The Causes, Development and Sustainability of Russia's Natural Gas Strategic Pivot: An Interdependence Perspective

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Russia’s recent surge of natural gas projects and the consequent rise in exports to Northeast Asia cannot be fully grasped without taking into account the following: the unique nature of natural gas as a commodity; energy sources as a strategic resource; and the politico-economic characteristics of the Russian state. An analysis of Russia’s effort to expand natural gas sales to Northeast Asia through the framework of interdependence where vulnerability and sensitivity are considered to be key variables reveals that this move is driven by a long-term national shift in strategy catalyzed by political and economic distress. This is in contrast to the popular notion that Russia’s shift is a stopgap measure in response to its souring relationship with European countries. An application of the same framework to Northeast Asia’s position in this relationship reveals that natural gas cooperation between Russia and the countries in this region is lagging despite the vast benefits it promises to bring. Russia and China are reluctant to cooperate due to a fear of becoming overly dependent on others. At the same time, South Korea and Japan’s current energy security leaves them with little incentive to pursue rapid progress despite potentially significant benefits by cooperating with Russia.

국문 초록 (Abstract)

최근 본격적으로 진전되고 있는 러시아의 동북아 천연가스 공급 및 교역 확대는 천연가스라는 자원의 특성, 전략 자원으로서 에너지의 특수성, 그리고 러시아라는 국가의 정치경제적 특수성을 고려할 때 온전하게 파악할 수 있다. 특히 취약성과 민감성의 두 변수를 고려하는 상호의존 분석틀을 통해 살펴보면 러시아가 동북아 지역으로 천연가스 판매 확대를 모색하는 것이 최근 유럽과의 관계 경색에 대응한 미봉책이라는 통념과는 다른 그림이 보인다. 즉, 이러한 변화는 근본적으로 러시아의 장기적 전략변화에서 비롯된 것이며 유럽과 겪고 있는 정치적, 경제적 갈등은 이 움직임을 촉진하는 촉매로 작용한 것이다. 동일한 분석틀을 동북아에 적용해보면 러시아와 동북아 국가 간의 천연가스 협력이 왜 그 잠재력에 비해 상대적으로 부진한지를 이해할 수 있다. 러-중 관계처럼 협력의 이득이 큰 경우는 과잉의존에 대한 두려움이 있는 반면 한국이나 일본과의 협력은 상대적으로 안정적이지만 시급히 협력해야 할 유인은 작은 것이다.

참고문헌 (Reference)

• 1 신범식, "세계정치, 제23권" 사회평론 2015
• 2 최영림, "러시아 푸틴정부의 신동방정책과 對아시아 LNG 수출전략" 에너지경제연구원 2014
• 3 신범식, "러시아 신(新)동방정책과 동북아 지역정치: 지역 세력망구도 변화와러시아의 가능성 및 한계" 동아시아연구원 2014
• 4 "https://www.oxfordenergy.org/wpcms/wp-content/uploads/2014/02/The-Pot ential-Impact-on-Asia-Gas-Markets-of-Russias-Eastern-Gas-Strateg y-GPC2-.pdf"
• 5 Yamal LNG, "Yamal LNG Signed Loan Agreement with JBIC" Yamal LNG Press
• 6 IEA, "World Energy Outlook 2011"
• 7 IEA, "World Energy Outlook 2009"
• 8 "World Bank Commodities Price Data"
• 9 "Ukrtransgaz Statistics"
• 10 Bierman Stephen, "U.S Puts Russian Gas Field Off Limits as Sanctions Tighten" Bloomberg
• 11 Stevens, Paul, "Transit Troubles: Pipelines as Sources of Conflict" Royal Institute of International Affairs 2009
• 12 Johnson, Robert, "The Russian Gas Sector; A Political Risk Case Study"
• 13 Pirani, Simon, "The Russian Gas Matrix: How Markets are Driving Change" OIES 2014
• 14 Henderson, James, "The Potential Impact on Asia Gas Markets of Russia’s Eastern Gas Strategy" Oxford Energy Comment 2014
• 15 Deutch, John., "The Natural Gas Revolution and its Consequences" 90 (90): 2011
• 16 Itoh, Shoichi, "The Geopolitics of Northeast Asia’s Pipeline Development" National Bureau of Asian Research 2010
• 17 Lis, Aleksandra, "The Energy Union: What is it about and how can it develop?"
• 18 Yafimava, Katja, "The EU Third Package for Gas and the Gas Target Model:major contentious issues inside and outside the EU" OIES 2013
• 19 Victor, David G., "The Belarus Connection:Exporting Russian Gas to Germany and Poland" Standford IIS 2004
• 20 Corbeau, Anne-Sophie, "The Asian Quest for LNG in a Globalising Market" International Energy Agency 2014
• 21 Makan, Ajay, "Statoil breaks oil-linked gas pricing"
• 22 Powell, William, "Statoil Ditches the Theory, Beating Gazprom in Practice"
• 23 Petrostratégies, "Statistics: Europe’s Growing Dependence on Imported Gas" 97 : 1988
• 24 Paik, Keun-Wook, "Sino-Russian Oil and Gas Cooperation" OIES 2012
• 25 Mitrova, Tatiana, "Shifting Political Economy of Russian Oil and Gas" CSIS 2016
• 26 Sberbank, "Sberbank Signs Loan Agreement to Finance Yamal LNG Project" Sberbank Press Release
• 27 Takeda, Yoshinori, "Russia’s New Political Leadership and Its Implications for East Siberian Development and Energy Cooperation with North East Asian States" 33 (33): 2008
• 28 Gerasimchuk, Olga, "Russia’s Natural Gas Export Policy in Asia Pacific in the 1990s: Unfulfilled Potential" 5 (5): 1990
• 29 Gerasimchuk Olga, "Russia’s Gas Pivot to Asia: A Short-Sighted Policy or A Long-Term Strategy?" 2017
• 30 Luft, Gal, "Russia’s Big Bear Hug on China" The American Interest
• 31 Platts, "Russian Yamal LNG to Sell First 2017 Cargoes on Spot Market"
• 32 Federal State Statistics Service, "Russian Statistical Yearbook 2015"
• 33 Central Bank of the Russian Federation, "Russian Natural Gas Exports in 2000-2015"
• 34 Henderson, James, "Russian LNG : Progress and delay in 2017" OIES 2017
• 35 Godzimirski, Jakub M., "Russian Energy in a Changing World: What is the Outlook for the Hydrocarbons Superpower?" Routledge 2013
• 36 Oxenstierna, Susanne, "Russian Energy and Security up to 2030" Routledge 2013
• 37 Sotiriou, Stylianos A., "Russian Energy Strategy in the European Union, the Former Soviet Union Region, and China" Lexington Books 2015
• 38 Staalesen, Atle, "Russian Crisis Money for Yamal" Barents Observer
• 39 Goldthau, Andreas, "Resurgent Russia? Rethinking Energy Inc" 147 : 2008
• 40 RIA Novosti, "Reshenie ob otkaze dostupa Rosnefti ktrube “Sakhalin-2”vstupilo v silu"
• 41 Reuters, "Putin Says Russia May Become Swing Gas Producer for Europe, Asia" Reuters
• 42 The Moscow Times, "Putin Orders More Tax Breaks for Yamal" The Moscow Times
• 43 Keohane, Robert, "Power and interdependence" 15 (15): 1973
• 44 Nariman, Karimbayev, "Monetizing Sakhalin-1 Gas. Russian Far East LNG Project" 2017
• 45 Nishiyama, Hidemasa, "Japan’s Policy on Energy Conservation" 2013
• 46 "International Monetary Fund Commodity Data"
• 47 Toyin, Falola, "I diethnis politiki tou petrelaiou" Ekdoseis Ppazisi 2008
• 48 Harada, Daisuke, "How Drastically Russian Gas Flows to Asia Pacific Region Changed in a Decade" 2008
• 49 Maslin, Elaine, "Gazprom, Shell Agree to Sakhalin Expansion"
• 50 OAO Gazprom, "Gazprom in figures 2006-2010" OAO Gazprom
• 51 OAO Gazprom, "Gazprom in Figures 2011-2015" OAO Gazprom
• 52 Rosner, Kevin, "Gazprom and the Russian State" GMB Publishing Ltd 2006
• 53 "Gazprom Export 2016"
• 54 Orlova, Elena V., "Evropa idet na birzhu" 7 (7): 2017
• 55 Eurostat, "Eurostat yearbook 2015"
• 56 Stulberg, Adam N., "Energy Security Cooperation in Northeast Asia" Routledge 2015
• 57 Kong, Bo, "Energy Security Cooperation in Northeast Asia" Routledge 2015
• 58 Herberg, Mikkal E., "Energy Security Cooperation in Northeast Asia" Routledge 2015
• 59 Shaffer, Brenda, "Energy Politics" University of Pennsylvania Press 2009
• 60 Energititseskaia Strategia Rossii, "Energititseskaia strategia Rossii na period do 2020 goda"
• 61 U.S. Energy Information Administration, "Country Analysis Brief : South Korea"
• 62 U.S. Energy Information Administration, "Country Analysis Brief : Japan"
• 63 Clingendael, "Clingendael Annual Report 2008" Clingendael Institute 2008
• 64 Dunnahoe, Tayvis, "China’s Shale Gas Production Outperforms Expectations"
• 65 British Petroleum, "BP Statistical Review of World Energy"
• 66 U.S Department of the Treasury, "Actions Implement Executive Order 13662against Two Russian Financial Institutions and Two Energy Firms"