인터액티브 정보검색 모형 = Interactive Information Retrieval (IR) Models: Tradition and Development

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

This paper is divided into two parts. The first part elaborates on four Information Retrieval (IR) models: a traditional IR model and three more recent, user-oriented models of IR interaction presented by Belkin, Ingwersen, and Saracevic. The strengths and limitations of each model are discussed. The second part, based on an analysis of the previous models, presents the author's interactive model, namely, the Iceberg Model. The rationales that are given to explain the design of this model are associated with the following: a greater specificity of system attributes; more concrete interplays among different components of IR interaction; and, the increased role of the Human Information Intermediary (HII). In sum, the new model presents a framework that can evolve in varying information-seeking contexts.

국문 초록 (Abstract)

본 논문은 다음과 같은 두 부분으로 구성된다. 논문의 전반부는 네 개의 정보검색 모형을 다루고 있는데 이는 전통적 정보검색 모형과 보다 최근에 나온 세 연구자의 이용자 중심 인터액티브 모형을 포함한다. 인터액티브 정보검색 모형은 Belkin, Ingwersen, 그리고 Saracevic 에 의하여 제시된 것인데, 전통적 정보검색 모형을 포함한 각 모형의 장점과 한계점이 기술된다. 논문의 후반부에서 저자는 이상과 같은 모형들의 분석을 토대로 그 자신의 인터액티브 모형, 즉 빙산모형(Iceberg Model)을 제시하고 있다. 빙산모형의 타당성으로 다음과 같은 세 가지 사항을 강조하고 있는데, 즉, 보다 구체화된 시스템 특성의 포함, 보다 명확한 인터액티브 정보검색 요소간의 상호작용, 그리고 정보매개자의 증가된 역할 등이 그것이다. 요약하면, 빙산모형은 변화하는 정보추구환경에서 진화할 수 있는 틀을 제시하고 있다.

참고문헌 (Reference)

• 1 "Users’ interaction with World Wide Web resources: An exploratory study using a holistic approach" 36 (36): 229-251, 2000
• 2 "Users in context" Bonn: Springer Verlag 157-178, 2001a
• 3 "User-oriented representation of documents for Interactive IR: Connecting beyond-topical criteria of user-defined relevance with the surrogate features of an IR database" 2003b
• 4 "Typology of ambiguity on representation of information problem: An exploratory study" 366-380, 2003a
• 5 "The stratified model of information retrieval interaction : Extension and applications" 34 : 313-327, 1997
• 6 "The role of relational structures in indexing for the humanities" 24 (24): 72-83, 1997
• 7 "The development of a method for the evaluation of interactive information retrieval systems" 53 (53): 225-250, 1997
• 8 "The Big Six Skills Approach to Library and Information Skills Instruction. Ablex Publishing Corporation"
• 9 "T. K. 1994＂Toward a Theory of User-Based Relevance A Call for a New Paradigm of Inquiry＂ Journal of the American Society for Information Science" 135-141,
• 10 "T. K. 1993＂The Nature of Relevance in Information Retrieval" 318-351,
• 11 "T. D. 1981＂On user studies and information needs＂ Journal of Documentation" 3-15,
• 12 "Study of Interactive Feedback during Mediated Information Retrieval" 48 (48): 382-394, 1997
• 13 "R. S. 1968＂Questions-negotiation and information seeking in libraries＂ College and Research Libraries" 178-194,
• 14 Oddy, "R. N. 1977＂Information retrieval through man-machine dialogue＂ Journal of Documentation" 1-14,
• 15 "N. J. 1993＂Interaction with texts Information retrieval as information-seeking behavior＂ Information Retrieval 55-66. Von der Modelierung zur Anwerdung. Konstanz" Universitaetsverlag.
• 16 "N. J. 1980＂Anomalous states of knowledge as the basis for information retrieval＂ Canadian Journal of Information Science" 133-143,
• 17 "Models in information behavior research" 55 (55): 249-270, 1999
• 18 Leckie, G. L, "Modeling the information seeking of professionals: A general model derived from research on engineers, health care professionals and lawyers" 66 : 161-193, 1996
• 19 "Modeling interaction in information retrieval (IR) A review and proposal" 33 : 3-9, 1996
• 20 "M. S. 1990＂A re-examination of relevance" 755-776,
• 21 "M. J. 1989＂The Design of Browsing and Berrypicking Techniques for the Online Search Interface＂ Online Review" 407-424,
• 22 "M. 1986＂Information needs and uses＂ In M. Williams Annual Review of Information Science and Technology" 3-33,
• 23 "Information science" 50 (50): 1051-1063, 1999
• 24 Larsen, B, "Exploiting citation overlaps for Information Retrieval : generating a boomerang effect from the network of scientific papers" 54 (54): 155-178, 2002
• 25 "Experimental Components for the evaluation of interactive information retrieval systems" 56 (56): 71-90, 2000b
• 26 "Evaluation of interactive information retrieval systems" 2000a
• 27 "Cognitive perspectives of information retrieval interaction : Elements of a cognitive IR theory" 52 (52): 3-50, 1996
• 28 "Cognitive perspectives of document representation" Colorado: Libraries Unlimited 285-300, 2002
• 29 "Cognitive Information Retrieval" 34 : 3-52, 2001b
• 30 "Cases, scripts, and information seeking strategies: On the design of interactive information retrieval systems" 9 (9): 379-395, 1995
• 31 Kuhlthau, "C. C. 1988b＂Longitudinal Case Studies of the Information Search Process of Users in Libraries＂ Library and Information Science" 251-304,
• 32 Kuhlthau, "C. C. 1988a＂Developing a Model of the Library Search Process Investigation of Cognitive and Affective Aspects＂ Reference Quarterly" 232-242,
• 33 "B. 1983. An overview of sense making research and results to date. Seattle School of Communication University of Washington."
• 34 "An exploratory study＂ Journal of the American Society for Information Science" 149-159,
• 35 "A new approach to the design of document retrieval systems＂ Journal of the American Society for Information Science Moving toward a Reconceptualization＂ In B Dervin & M. Voigt Progress in Communication Sciences" 389 73-112,
• 36 "A cognitive model of document use during a research project : Study 1. Document selection" 49 (49): 115-133, 1998