와스디, 에스더, 세레스: 에스더서의 여성 리더십과 복잡한 유산 = Vashti, Esther, and Zeresh: Women’s Leadership in the Book of Esther and Its Complicated Legacy

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

This essay attempts to evaluate women's leadership presented by the narrator of the Book of Esther. The narrator presents distorted images of women's leadership through the description of Vashti, Esther and Zeresh. Vashti is a woman leader who is independent and has high self-esteem. But she is an example of a lousy woman who does not support her husband and makes him look bad in public. This kind of woman deserves punishment and women readers are not to emulate her. Esther is helpful to men and gives everything good to men, although she has to risk her safety. She is an ideal woman leader to the narrator. Zeresh is also helpful to men. She offers counsel to her husband when asked. But she speaks against her own interests. The readers have been divided in regard to interpreting the biblical women. Some feminist readers praise Vashti for her independence and criticize Esther for working for men in their terms. Others give credit to Esther for using what is available to her with wisdom and courage to meet her ends despite the limits of the times. Most scholars do not even deal with Zeresh. We see Zeresh as the brain behind her husband's political activities. All these women are separated from one another and never talk to one another. Each is like an island drifting alone in men's sea. The narrator makes the reader compare and contrast the women characters and take a side. Focusing on a woman character or comparison or contrast among them only results in separating them even more. Women readers will also be divided into two. Seeing Vashti as a better leader than Esther risks the same danger. The women's leadership described by the narrator misleads the readers. It leaves complicated heritage to Korean church women. Most Korean preachers not only follow the narrator, but intensify and magnify it in the patriarchal context of the Korean church. Their understanding of biblical women's leadership is in direct proportion to modern women's leadership status in the church. In fact, among women in the church there is separation and conflict among Vashitis and Esthers. Thus, sensitive readers can see the need for the women character in the Book Esther and church women need to be incorporated into one respectively. We see Vashti in Esther when the latter breaks a royal rule. We see Zeresh in Esther when the latter acts like a sage. Church women also have all these women in them, being Vashti rebellious against the opaque church management, being Esther obedient to the end, and being Zeresh speaking against her interests. A healthy incorporation of the three will strengthen the church.

국문 초록 (Abstract)

와스디, 에스더, 세레스는 서로에게서 분리되어 있고 서로 말하지 않는다. 에스더서의 화자는 이 세 여성을 나누고 암시적으로 갈등관계에 둔다. 그러나 이 세 여자는 뜻밖에도 에스더 안에서 하나로 통합될 수 있다. 나아가 교회 여성들 사이에서 와스디들, 에스더들, 세레스들로 나뉘지 않고 하나로 통할될 가능성을 모색한다.

참고문헌 (Reference)

• 1 강병도, "호크마 종합주석 3" 기독지혜사 1997
• 2 라페이, "여성신학을 위한 구약개론" 대한기독교서회 213-216, 1998
• 3 김서택, "민족을 구한 여성 에스더" 기독교문사 2006
• 4 제자원, "그랜드 종합주석 7" 성서아카데미 1999
• 5 이경숙, "구약성서의 여성들" 대한기독교서회 1998
• 6 "www.gnbtv/bard/boarddetail.html"
• 7 "https://sisa-news.com/read.php3?no=18778&read_temp=20070419§ion=24"
• 8 "http://www.brethrenhouse.or.kr/jamee/ja_01.htm"
• 9 "http://sdskc.co.kr/zbxe/board_9/2516/page/15"
• 10 "http://mission.bz/976"
• 11 "http://blog.naver.com/goldnature"
• 12 "http://blog.joins.com/yiyoyong/"
• 13 Talmon, S., "Wisdom’ in the Book of Esther" 13 : 437-453, 1963
• 14 Jones, Bruce William, "Two Misconceptions about the Book of Esther, In Studies in the Book of Esther" KTAV Publishing 437-447, 1982
• 15 Gendler, Mary, "The Restoration of Vashti, In The Jewish Woman: New Perspectives" Schocken Books 241-247, 1976
• 16 Zeitlin. S., "The Books of Esther and Judith: A Parallel, In The Book of Judith" Brill 1-37, 1972
• 17 Bronner, Leila Leah, "Reclaiming Esther: From Sex Object to Sage" 26 (26): 3-10, 1998
• 18 Rosenblatt, Naomi Harris, "Portraits In Heroism: Esther and Samson" 15 (15): 20-25, 1999
• 19 Lerner, Berel Dov, "No Happy Ending for Esther" 29 (29): 3-11, 2001
• 20 Weems, Renita, "Just a Sister Away" LuraMedia 1988
• 21 Anderson, Bernhard W., "Introduction and Exegesis to Esther, In The Interpreter’s Bible III" Abingdon Press 821-874, 1954
• 22 Lichtenberger, A. C., "Exposition to Esther, In The Interpreter’s Bible III" Abingdon Press 841-847, 1974
• 23 White, Sidnie Ann, "Esther: A Feminine Model for Jewish Diaspora, In Gennder and Difference in Ancient Israel" Fortress Press 161-177, 1989
• 24 Moore, Carey A., "Esther and Jeremiah : The Additions" Doubleday 1977
• 25 Day, Linda M., "Esther" Abingdon Press 2005
• 26 Berlin, Adele, "Esther" The Jewish Publication Society 2001
• 27 Moore, Carey A., "Esther" Doubleday 1971
• 28 Stanton, Elizabeth Cady, "Comments on the Book of Esther, In The Woman’s Bible" Coalition Task Force on Women and Religion 84-92, 1974
• 29 Paton, Lewis Bayles, "A Critical and Exegetical Commentary on the Book of Esther" Charles Scribners & Son 1908