TIMSS 2023 과학 인지 영역 분석틀을 활용한 2015 개정 및 2022 개정 초등 과학과 성취 기준 분석 = Analysis of the 2015 Revised and 2022 Revised Elementary School Science Achievement Standards Using the TIMSS 2023 Scientific Cognitive Domain Analysis Framework

국문 초록 (Abstract)

본 연구의 목적은 TIMSS 2023 과학 인지 영역 분석틀을 활용하여2015 개정과 2022 개정의 과학과 교육과정의 성취 기준을 분석하는것이다. 연구 대상은 2015 개정과 2022 개정 과학과 교육과정에서초등 전 영역의 성취 기준이다. 연구 분석에는 초등과학교육을 전공한 3명의 현장 교사와 초등과학교육전문가 1명이 참여하였다. 본 연구의 결과는 다음과 같다. 첫째, 2022 개정 운동과 에너지 분야에서‘알기’ 영역의 비율은 2015 개정보다 약 16% 높았고, ‘추론하기’ 영역의 비율도 약 5.8% 증가하였다. 둘째, 물질 분야에서 TIMSS 2023 인지 영역의 비율은 학년군과 교육과정의 개정 시기와 관련 없이 ‘알기’, ‘적용하기’, ‘추론하기’의 순이었다. 셋째, 생명과학 분야에서TIMSS 2023 인지 영역의 비율은 학년군과 교육과정의 개정 시기에따라 달랐다. 넷째, 2022 개정의 지구와 우주 분야 또한 다른 세 영역과 유사하게 ‘알기’ 영역의 비율은 증가하였고 ‘적용하기’ 영역은 감소하였다. 하지만 2022 개정에서 다른 세 분야의 ‘추론하기’ 영역은모두 증가하였는데 지구와 우주 분야에서만 감소하였다. 다섯째, 2015 개정 통합 단원과 2022 개정 과학과 사회 분야에서는 ‘알기’ 영역의 ‘인식하기’와 ‘예 제시하기’, ‘적용하기’ 영역의 ‘관계짓기’와‘설명하기’, ‘추론하기’ 영역의 ‘종합하기’ 요소만 다루고 있었다.
2022 개정 초등 전체 과학 분야에서 ‘알기’ 영역의 비율은 52.5%, ‘적용하기’ 영역의 비율은 33.8%, ‘추론하기’ 영역의 비율은 13.7%였다. 결론적으로 2022 개정 초등 과학과 성취 기준에서 ‘알기’ 영역의의존도가 너무 높았기 때문에 ‘적용하기’와 ‘추론하기’ 영역의 비율이낮았다.

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

The purpose of this study is to analyze the achievement standards of the 2015 revision and 2022 revision of the science curriculum using the TIMSS 2023 science cognitive domain analysis framework. The subject of the study is the achievement standards for all elementary school areas in the 2015 and 2022 revised science curriculum. Three field teachers and one elementary science education expert who majored in elementary science education participated in the research analysis. The results of this study are as follows. First, in the 2022 revised movement and energy field, the ratio of the ‘knowing’ area was about 16% higher than the 2015 revision, and the ratio of the ‘reasoning’ area also increased by about 5.8%.
Second, in the material field, the proportion of TIMSS 2023 cognitive domains was in the order of ‘knowing’, ‘applying’, and ‘reasoning’ regardless of grade group and curriculum revision period. Third, in the field of life sciences, the proportion of TIMSS 2023 cognitive domains differed depending on grade group and curriculum revision period. Fourth, in the Earth and Space field of the 2022 revision, similar to the other three fields, the proportion of the ‘Knowing’ field increased and while the ‘Applying’ field decreased. However, in the 2022 revision, the ‘reasoning’ area in all three other fields increased, but decreased only in the earth and space fields. Fifth, the 2015 revised integrated unit and the 2022 revised science and society field only covered the elements of ‘recognizing’ and ‘presenting examples’ in the ‘knowing’ area, ‘making relationships’ and ‘explaining’ in the ‘applying’ area and ‘Synthesize’ in the ‘reasoning’ area. In the 2022 revised elementary school science field, the proportion of the ‘knowing’ section was 52.5%, the proportion of the ‘applying’ section was 33.8%, and the proportion of the ‘reasoning’ section was 13.7%. In conclusion, in the 2022 revised elementary science achievement standards, the ratio of the ‘applying’ and ‘reasoning’ areas was low because the reliance on the ‘knowing’ area was too high.

참고문헌 (Reference)

• 1 이일 ; 곽영순, "Ways to Restructure Science Elective Courses in Preparation for the High School Credit System and the 2022 Revised Curriculum" 41 (41): 145-154, 2021
• 2 곽영순, "Ways to Restructure Science Convergence Elective Courses in Preparation for the High School Credit System and the 2022 Revised Curriculum" 14 (14): 112-122, 2021
• 3 Kim, K., "Trends in international mathematics and science study: Report of TIMSS 2007 Results" KICE 2007
• 4 이경건, "Trends and Issues of the Korean National Curriculum Documents’ Subject-Matter Content System Table : Focusing on the Science Subject Case" 44 (44): 87-103, 2024
• 5 Park, S., "Trends International Mathematics and Science Study: TIMSS 2019 main survey" KICE 2019
• 6 Sang, K., "The Trends in International Mathematics and Science Study (TIMSS): In-depth analysis of TIMSS 2015" KICE 2017
• 7 김선경 ; 김현경, "The Relationship Analysis of the Korean Science Curriculum with the Physical Science Domains of the 4th Grade TIMSS 2019" 45 (45): 1-10, 2021
• 8 Landis, J. R., "The Measurement of Observer Agreement for Categorical Data" 33 (33): 159-174, 1977
• 9 ERISNU(Educational Research Institute Seoul National University), "The Dictionary of Educational Studies" Hawoo 2011
• 10 IEA, "TIMSS 2023 Assessment Frameworks"
• 11 Mullis, I. V. S., "TIMSS 2019 progress report" 2019
• 12 IEA, "TIMSS 2019 Assessment Frameworks"
• 13 이혜정 ; 최혜경 ; 권용주, "Science Knowledge and Scientific Emotion during the Generation of Biological Hypotheses in High School Students" 37 (37): 229-243, 2009
• 14 Kwon, Y., "Science Education -From thinking to learning-" Bookshill 2013
• 15 Shin, Y., "Research on the development of the 2022revised science curriculum plan" KOFAC 2022
• 16 Park, K., "Prospects and tasks of international comparative study on mathematics achievement : Outcomes and tasks of international comparative study of student achievement" KICE 2015
• 17 조헌국 ; 노현아 ; 최재혁, "Network Analysis of Achievement Standards Relevant to the Concept of Energy Presented in the 2022Revised National Curriculum of Science" 13 (13): 125-136, 2023
• 18 Sang, K., "International comparative study on changes in math and science achievement trends : Analysis of TIMSS 2019 results" KICE 2020
• 19 김지영 ; 김수진 ; 동효관, "International Comparison of Cognitive Attributes using Analysis on Science Results at TIMSS 2011 Based on the Cognitive Diagnostic Theory" 35 (35): 267-275, 2015
• 20 Seo, M., "In-depth analysis of TIMSS 2019 results and change trends" KICE 2021
• 21 유은정 ; 박재용 ; 이현동, "Improving the 2022 Revised Science Curriculum : Elementary School ‘Earth and Universe’ Units" 41 (41): 173-185, 2022
• 22 Lee, J., "Exploring the support system for curriculum implementation in the 2022 Revised National Curriculum" KICE 2022
• 23 곽영순 ; 신영준, "Exploring Ways to Improve Integrated Science and Science Laboratory Experiments in Preparation for the 2022Revised Curriculum" 45 (45): 143-155, 2021
• 24 신영준, "Contents Analysis of the 2022 Revised Curriculum related to the Climate Change Education" 13 (13): 23-34, 2023
• 25 정용욱 ; 윤혜경, "Consideration on the Contents of the Electromagnetism Domain in the 2022 Revised Elementary School Science Curriculum" 41 (41): 186-198, 2022
• 26 강경희, "Comparison of Achievement Standards in the Life Science of 2015 and 2022 Revised Curriculum Based on Bloom’s Revised Taxonomy" 26 (26): 103-119, 2023
• 27 김현경 ; 임희준, "Comparison between TIMSS 2019 science framework and Korea elementary school science curriculum" 19 (19): 497-516, 2019
• 28 이소영 ; 노석구, "Comparison and Analysis of the 2009 Elementary Science Curriculum of South Korea and the Elementary Science Curriculum of Finland" 33 (33): 491-509, 2014
• 29 조헌국, "Comparing the 2015 with the 2022 Revised Primary Science Curriculum Based on Network Analysis" 42 (42): 178-193, 2023
• 30 이지은, "Characteristics of the 2015 and 2022 Revised National Curriculum and Future Tasks Through International Comparative Study" 14 (14): 35-61, 2023
• 31 한제준 ; 권유지 ; 오현석, "Analyzing the adequacy of the Contents of the 2022 Revised Science Curriculum-Elementary School ‘Earth and Universe’ Units-" 17 (17): 120-137, 2023
• 32 송은정 ; 제민경 ; 차경미 ; 유준희, "Analysis of the Verbs in the 2009 Revised National Science Curriculum-from the Viewpoint of Cognitive Domain of TIMSS Assessment Framework" 36 (36): 607-616, 2016
• 33 Kim, W., "Analysis of achievement standards for 3rd and 4th grade elementary school students in the 2022 revised science curriculum based on Bloom’s new classification of educational goals" 85 : 67-, 2024
• 34 홍미영 ; 정은영 ; 이미경 ; 곽영순, "Analysis of Korean Middle School Student Science Achievement at International Benchmarks in TIMSS 2003" 26 (26): 246-257, 2006
• 35 곽영순, "Analysis of Features of Korean Fourth Grade Students`TIMSS Science Achievement in Content Domains with Curriculum Change" 37 (37): 599-609, 2017
• 36 곽영순, "Analysis of Features of Korean Eighth Grades’ TIMSS 2015 Achievement in Chemistry" 38 (38): 625-633, 2018
• 37 곽영순 ; 신영준, "Analysis of Features of Korean Eighth Grade Students’ TIMSS 2015 Achievement in Life Science" 45 (45): 350-363, 2017
• 38 김희경 ; 이봉우, "Analysis of Climate Change–Related Content in the New Jersey Student Learning Standard and the 2022 Revised Science National Curriculum" 13 (13): 163-172, 2023
• 39 임유나, "A critical review of the ‘key ideas’ in the 2022 revised national curriculum" 23 (23): 747-768, 2023
• 40 김미영 ; 김경희, "A Content Analysis of Biology Domain of Korean and Singaporean Textbooks Based on the TIMSS Framework" 39 (39): 217-234, 2011
• 41 윤지영 ; 온정덕, "A Conceptual Analysis of Reflection in Learning and Its Application in the Curriculum Design" 40 (40): 1-27, 2022
• 42 김윤경 ; 김종영 ; 신명경, "A Comparative Study of Elementary Science Curriculum between Korea and USA-Focusing on Earth and Space Domain of Third and Fourth Grades-" 35 (35): 362-376, 2016
• 43 MOE(Ministry of Education), "2025 Revised Science Education Curriculum"
• 44 Shin, Y., "2022 revised science curriculum draft (final draft)development policy research final report" KOFAC 2022
• 45 MOE(Ministry of Education), "2022 Revised Science Education Curriculum"