인권과 건강의 상호교차성- 보건의료의 측면에서 본 인간 존엄성과 사회적 존엄성 - = The Intersectionality of Human Rights and Health: Dignity as Seen from the Perspective of Health Care

국문 초록 (Abstract)

이 글은 보건의료의 측면에서, 인권과 존엄이 갖는 의미와 권리로서의 건강과의 상호교차성을 분석하고, 이들의 해석과 적용을 통해 건강권의 법적 지평을 넓히고자 하는 시도를 담고 있다. 특히, 사회적 관계로서의 존엄성 개념에 주목하였다. 인간 존엄성이 자율적인 인간으로서 자신이 직접 부여하는 스스로에 대한 존엄인 반면, 사회적 존엄성은 이러한 인간 존엄성이 특정한 사회적 상호작용에서 어떻게 실현되는지에 대한 관계에서의 존엄이다. 사회적 존엄성 개념을 통하여 인간다운 삶과 웰빙의 조건으로서 건강과 인권은 세 가지 상호교차성을 가진다. 첫째, 건강 문제를 다룬 인권 정책, 프로그램, 실천과의 연관성이다. 이들은 공중보건의 목표와 인권 규범 간의 최적 균형을 맞추기 위해 상호작용한다. 둘째, 권리의 침해로 야기되는 건강 효과이다. 인권 침해는 개인의 건강 보장과 연관하여 위해를 가져올 수 있다. 셋째, 인구집단의 건강 증진과 보호는 인권의 증진 및 보호와 불가분하게 연관된다. 따라서 건강과 인권의 상호의존성은 본질적, 개념적, 실천적으로 사회적 존엄성이라는 하나의 프레임 안에 있다. 지역사회에서 인권 프레임에 입각한 건강 증진의 실천은 이러한 존엄성에 대한 이해를 풍부하게 하면서 건강 증진 활동을 활성화 하는데 도움을 준다. 그리고 현대 사회에서 건강권의 보장 영역을 확대하는데 새로운 기회를 제공한다.

참고문헌 (Reference)

• 1 최민영, "존엄사와 생명처분권, 법현상에 대한 조응과 평가" 47 : 54-, 2010
• 2 김왕배, "인권으로서의 건강권에 대한 탐색과 전망" 한국보건사회학회 (32) : 5-18, 2012
• 3 이석배, "의료영역에서 인간의 존엄, 생명, 생명권의 관계" 한국의료법학회 20 (20): 247-265, 2012
• 4 맹광호, "공중보건 활동에서의 '사전 동의' 문제 -유네스코<생명윤리 및 인권에 관한 선언>을 중심으로-" 대한예방의학회 41 (41): 339-344, 2008
• 5 The International Bank for Reconstruction and Development, "World development report 1993: Investing in Health" Oxford University Press 1993
• 6 Moody HR, "Why Dignity in Old Age Matters" 29 : 13-38, 1998
• 7 Pullman D, "Universalism, Particularism and the Ethics of Dignity" 7 : 333-358, 2001
• 8 United Nations, "Universal Declaration of Human Rights. adopted and proclaimed by UN General Assembly Resolution 217A(III)"
• 9 Miller AB, "Understanding Dignity in the Lives of Homeless Persons" 29 : 331-354, 2001
• 10 Global AIDS Policy Coalition, "Towards a New Health Strategy for AIDS: A report of the global AIDS policy coalition" Global AIDS Policy Coalition 1993
• 11 World Health Organization, "The World Health Report 2000" World Health Organization 2000
• 12 Nordenfelt L, "The Varieties of Dignity" 12 : 69-81, 2004
• 13 Liebenberg S, "The Value of Human Dignity in Interpreting Socio-economic Rights" 1 (1): 1-31, 2005
• 14 Morsink J, "The Universal Declaration of Human Rights: Origins, drafting, and intent" University of Pennsylvania Press 1999
• 15 Geiger HJ, "The Role of Physicians in Conflicts and Humanitarian Crises: Case studies from the field missions of Physicians for Human Rights, 1988-1993" 270 : 616-620, 1993
• 16 Gurnham D, "The Mysteries of Human Dignity and the Brave New World of Human Cloning" 14 : 197-214, 2005
• 17 Gostin L, "The Interconnected Epidemics of Drug Dependency and AIDS" 26 : 113-184, 1991
• 18 Hailer M, "The General Notion of Human Dignity and the Specific Arguments in Medical Ethics, In Sanctity of Life and Human Dignity" Kluwer Academic Publishers 91-106, 1996
• 19 Pullman D, "The Ethics of Autonomy and Dignity in Longterm Care" 18 : 26-49, 1999
• 20 Jacelon CS, "The Dignity of Elders in an Acute Care Hospital" 13 : 543-556, 2003
• 21 Guerra MD, "The Affirmation of Genuine Human Dignity" 4 : 295-301, 2001
• 22 Dworkin R, "Taking Rights Seriously" Harvard University Press 1978
• 23 Schauer F, "Speaking of Dignity, In The Constitution of Rights: Human dignity and American values" Cornell University Press 1992
• 24 Gortmaker SL, "Social and Economic Consequences of Overweight in Adolescence and Young Adulthood" 329 : 1008-1012, 1993
• 25 Kapiga SH, "Risk Factors for HIV Infection among Women in Dar-es-Salaam, Tanzania" 7 : 301-309, 1994
• 26 Jacobs BB, "Respect for Human Dignity in Nursing: Philosophical and Practical Perspectives" 32 : 15-33, 2000
• 27 Horton R, "Rediscovering Human Dignity" 364 : 1081-1085, 2004
• 28 Blanchard J, "R-E-S-P-E-C-T: Patient reports of disrespect in the health care setting and its impact on care" 53 : 721-730, 2004
• 29 Harding T, "Prevention of Torture and Inhuman or Degrading Treatment: Medical implications of a new European Convention" 8648 : 1191-1194, 1989
• 30 Shotton L, "Practical Dignity in Caring" 5 (5): 246-255, 1998
• 31 Dutton DB, "Overview, Methodological Critique, and Reformulation, In Pathways to Health: The role of social factors" Henry J. Kaiser Family Foundation 1989
• 32 Schoendorf KC, "Mortality among Infants of Black as Compared with White College-Educated Parents" 326 : 1522-1526, 1992
• 33 Friedman E, "Money isn't Everything" 271 : 1535-1538, 1994
• 34 Mollica RF, "Measuring Torture and Torture-related Syndromes" 3 : 1-7, 1991
• 35 Lothian K, "Maintaining the Dignity and Autonomy of Older People in the Healthcare Setting" 322 : 668-670, 2001
• 36 Meyer MJ, "Kantian Dignity and Modern Political Thought" 8 : 319-332, 1987
• 37 Shell SM, "Kant on Human Dignity, In Defense of Human Dignity: Essays for our times" University of Notre Dame Press 53-80, 2003
• 38 Kristeller PO, "Introduction, In The Renaissance Philosophy of Man" University of Chicago Press 215-222, 1948
• 39 Meeks MD, "Introduction, In On Human Dignity: Political Theology and Ethics" Fortress Press 1984
• 40 United Nations, "International Guidelines on HIV/AIDS and Human Rights: 2006 Consolidated Version. United Nations"
• 41 du Guerny J, "Inter-Relationship between Gender Relations and the HIV/AIDS Epidemic: Some considerations for policies and programmes" 7 : 1027-1034, 1993
• 42 Beauchamps DE, "Injury, Community and the Republic" 17 : 42-49, 1989
• 43 Kawachi I, "Income Inequality and Life Expectancy: Theory, research and policy" The Health Institute, New England Medical Center and Harvard School of Public Health 1994
• 44 Pullman D, "Human dignity and the ethics and aesthetics of pain and suffering" 23 : 75-94, 2002
• 45 McDougal MS, "Human Rights and the World Public Order: The basic policies of an international law of human dignity" Yale University Press 1980
• 46 Cooley CH, "Human Nature and the Social Order" Transaction Books 1983
• 47 Bayertz K, "Human Dignity: Philosophical origin and scientific erosion of an idea, In Sanctity of Life and Human Dignity" Kluwer Academic Publishers
• 48 Spiegelberg H, "Human Dignity: A challenge to contemporary philosophy, In Human Dignity: This century and the next" Gordon & Breach 39-64, 1970
• 49 Beyleveld D, "Human Dignity in Bioethics and Biolaw" Oxford University Press 2001
• 50 Gewirth A, "Human Dignity as the Basis of Rights, In The Constitution of Rights: Human dignity and American values" Cornell University Press 1992
• 51 Schachter O, "Human Dignity as a Normative Concept" 77 (77): 848-854, 1983
• 52 Feldman D, "Human Dignity as a Legal Value—Part II" (Spring) : 61-76, 2000
• 53 Feldman D, "Human Dignity as a Legal Value–Part I" (Winter) : 682-702, 1999
• 54 Paust JJ, "Human Dignity as a Constitutional Right: A jurisprudentially based inquiry into criteria and content" 27 : 146-225, 1984
• 55 Andorno R, "Human Dignity and the UNESCO Declaration on the Human Genome" 2003
• 56 Johnson JP, "Human Dignity and The Nature of Society" 10 : 213-231, 1971
• 57 Pritchard MS, "Human Dignity and Justice" 82 : 299-313, 1972
• 58 Petermann T, "Human Dignity and Genetic Tests, In Sanctity of Life and Human Dignity" Kluwer Academic Publishers 123-138, 1996
• 59 Oyaya CO, "Health, Poverty, and Dignified Living" 44 : 51-57, 2001
• 60 Institute of Medicine, "Future of Public Health" National Academy Press 1988
• 61 Ottawa-Charter for Health Promotion, "First International Conference on Health Promotion" World Health Organization 1986
• 62 Physicians for Human Rights, "Final Report of UN Commission of Experts" UN 1994
• 63 Pannuti F, "Dying with Dignity: Illusion, Hope or Human Right?" 14 : 172-173, 1993
• 64 Pullman D, "Dying with Dignity and the Death of Dignity" 4 : 197-219, 1996
• 65 Abiven M, "Dying with Dignity" 12 : 375-381, 1991
• 66 Meyer MJ, "Dignity, Rights, and Self-Control" 99 : 520-534, 1989
• 67 Macklin R, "Dignity is a Useless Concept" 327 : 1419-1420, 2003
• 68 Chochinov HM, "Dignity in the Terminally Ill: A developing empirical model" 54 : 433-443, 2002
• 69 Chochinov HM, "Dignity in the Terminally Ill: A cross-sectional, cohort study" 360 : 2026-2030, 2002
• 70 Soderberg A, "Dignity in Situations of Ethical Difficulty in Intensive Care" 13 : 135-144, 1997
• 71 Chochinov HM, "Dignity and the Eye of the Beholder" 22 : 1336-2030, 2004
• 72 Nordenfelt L, "Dignity and the Care of the Elderly" 6 : 103-110, 2003
• 73 Mann J, "Dignity and Health: The UDHR’s revolutionary first article" 3 (3): 30-38, 2004
• 74 Kade WJ, "Death with Dignity: A case study" 132 : 504-506, 2000
• 75 American Public Health Association, "Control of Communicable Disease in Man" American Public Health Association 1990
• 76 Parent WA, "Constitutional Values and Human Dignity, In The Constitution of Rights: Human dignity and American values" Cornell University Press 1992
• 77 World Health Organization, "Constitution, in Basic Documents"
• 78 Mairis ED, "Concept Clarification in Professional Practice–Dignity" 19 : 947-953, 1994
• 79 Witte J, "Between sanctity and depravity: Human dignity in Protestant perspective, In Defense of Human Dignity: Essays for our times" University of Notre Dame Press 2003
• 80 Hayry M, "Another Look at Dignity" 13 : 7-14, 2004
• 81 Epp J, "Achieving Health for All: A framework for health promotion" Health and Welfare Canada 1986
• 82 Dales RC, "A Medieval View of Human Dignity" 38 : 557-572, 1977