수종에 따른 스트로크 하베스터의 벌도⋅조재작업 생산성 및 비용 = Productivity and Cost of Mechanized Felling and Processing Operations Performed with an Excavator-based Stroke Harvester by Tree Species

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Chainsaw use for motor-manual timber harvesting in South Korea is associated with worker safety issues.
However, forestry operations such as timber harvesting have already been mechanized to reduce hazards to workers and increase productivity. This study analyzed the productivities and costs of felling and processing, felling and processing using an excavator-based stroke harvester for Pinus rigida and Quercus mongolica stands. To efficiently operate the stroke harvester, we developed a regression equation to estimate the productivities of felling and processing, felling, and processing operations,and we conducted sensitivity analysis of the operation costs using DBH and machine utilization.
The felling and processing productivity was 6.53 and 4.02 m3/SMH for P. rigida and Q. mongolica, respectively, and the cost was 17,983 and 29,210 won/m3, respectively. The felling productivity for P. rigida and Q. mongolica was 40.9 and 23.0 m3/SMH, respectively, and the cost was 2,667 and 4,743 won/m3, respectively. The processing productivity for P. rigida and Q. mongolica was 8.25 and 7.75 m3/SMH, respectively, and the cost was 15,296 and 16,283 won/m3, respectively. In the developed regression equation, the DBH, traveling distance, and number of cuttings were found to be important factors (p<0.05). Therefore, it is necessary to construct a DB considering the various conditions and species associated with harvester operations, and further research is needed to increase the accuracy of predicting operation productivity and costs.

국문 초록 (Abstract)

체인톱에 의한 인력위주의 임목수확작업은 안전사고 문제에 직면하고 있으나, 기계화작업을 통해 작업자의 위험성을 줄이고 생산성을 높일 수 있다. 본 연구는 국내 수종에 적합한 굴삭기 기반의 스트로크 하베스터을 이용하여 리기다소나무(Pinus rigida)와 신갈나무(Quercus mongolica)를 대상으로 벌도+조재작업, 벌도작업과 조재작업으로 구분하여 생산성과 비용을 분석하였다. 스트로크 하베스터의 효율적인 운영을 위한 작업생산성 예측모델 개발과 직경 및 기계이용률에 따른 작업비용 변화를 분석하였다. 벌도+조재작업에서 리기다소나무와 신갈나무의 생산성은 각각 6.53 m3/SMH와 4.02 m 3/SMH이고, 비용은 각각 17,983 won/m3과 29,210 won/m3으로 나타났다. 벌도작업에서 리기다소나무와 신갈나무의 생산성은 각각 40.9 m3/SMH와 23.0 m3/SMH이고 비용은 각각 2,667 won/m3와 4,743 won/m3으로 나타났다. 조재작업에서 리기다소나무와 신갈나무의 생산성은 각각 8.25 m3/SMH와 7.75 m3/SMH이고, 비용은 각각 15,296 won/m3와16,283 m3/SMH으로 나타났다. 스트로크 하베스터를 이용한 벌도+조재작업, 벌도작업과 조재작업의 생산성에 대한 중요인자는 흉고직경, 이동거리와 절단횟수가 선정되었으며(p<0.05), 이를 이용하여 작업생산성 예측모델을 개발하였다. 따라서 스트로크 하베스터를 이용한 벌도 및 조재작업에서 다양한 조건과 수종을 고려한 DB 구축으로 생산성과 비용 예측의 정확성을 높이기 위한 연구가 필요할 것으로 판단된다.

참고문헌 (Reference)

• 1 한원성 ; 조구현 ; 송태영 ; 김재원 ; 신만용 ; 오재헌, "체인톱을 이용한 잣나무의 벌도작업 공정 분석" 한국산림과학회 98 (98): 451-457, 2009
• 2 신만용 ; 한원성, "지속가능한 산림경영에 적합한 표본조사 방법의 개발" 한국산림과학회 95 (95): 370-377, 2006
• 3 김민규 ; 박상준, "전목 및 단목 집재작업시스템에서 작업시간 및 공정 분석" 한국산림과학회 101 (101): 344-355, 2012
• 4 김민규 ; 박상준, "전목 및 단목 집재작업시스템에서 작업비용 분석" 한국산림과학회 102 (102): 229-238, 2013
• 5 조민재 ; 최윤성 ; 문호성 ; 이충건 ; 이은재 ; 정응진 ; 오재헌 ; 한상균 ; 김대현 ; 차두송, "임목수확방법별 벌도작업 생산성 및 비용 분석" 한국산림과학회 105 (105): 441-448, 2016
• 6 조구현 ; 조민재 ; 한한섭 ; 한상균 ; 차두송, "낙엽송 간벌작업에서 전간수확시스템의 작업비용 분석" 한국산림과학회 104 (104): 221-229, 2015
• 7 Snee, R. D, "Validation of regression model : Methods and example" 19 : 415-428, 1977
• 8 McEwan, A., "The effects of number of stems per stool on cutting productivity in coppiced Eucalyptus plantations" 50 (50): 1448-, 2016
• 9 Spinelli, R., "The effect of mechanization level and harvesting system on the thinning cost of Mediterranean softwood plantations" 48 (48): 1-15, 2014
• 10 이진아, "Swing-yarder를 이용한 전목수확시스템의 생산성 및 비용분석" 강원대학교 대학원 2013
• 11 Korea Forest Service(KFS), "Statistical yearbook of forestry"
• 12 Glade, D, "Single-and double-grip harvesters–productive measurements in final cutting of shelterwood" 10 (10): 63-74, 1999
• 13 Alam, M., "Self-levelling feller-buncher productivity based on Lidar-derived slope" 34 (34): 273-281, 2013
• 14 Gerasimov, Y., "Productivity of single-grip harvesters in clear-cutting operations in the northern European part of Russia" 131 (131): 647-654, 2012
• 15 Spinelli, R, "Productivity norms for harvesters and processors used in Italy" 2011
• 16 Jiroušek, R., "Productivity and costs of the mechanized cut-to-length wood harvesting system in clear-felling operations" 53 (53): 476-482, 2007
• 17 Acosta, F. C., "Productivity and costs of harvester cutting of teak trees for thinning" 28 : 2020
• 18 Vitorelo, B., "Productivity and cost of integrated harvesting for fuel reduction thinning in mixed-conifer forest" 61 (61): 664-674, 2011
• 19 Adebayo, A. B., "Productivity and cost of cut-to-length and whole-tree harvesting in a mixed-conifer stand" 57 (57): 59-69, 2007
• 20 Strandgard, M., "Productivity and cost of whole‑tree harvesting without debarking in a Eucalyptus nitens plantation in Tasmania, Australia" 77 (77): 173-178, 2015
• 21 Dykstra, D. P, "Production rates and costs for cable, balloon, and helicopter yarding systems in old-growth Douglas-fir" Oregon State University 1975
• 22 Brinker, R. W., "Machine rates for selected forest harvesting machines"
• 23 Conway, S, "Logging practices: Principles of timber harvesting systems" Miller Freeman Publications 432-, 1982
• 24 Forbrig, A, "Konzeption und anwendung eines informationssystems über forstmaschinen auf der grundlage von maschinenbuchführung, leistungsnachweisen und technischen daten"
• 25 "Konzeption und anwendung eines informationssystems uber forstmaschinen auf der grundlage von maschinenbuchfuhrung, leistrungsnachweisen und technischen daten" 2000
• 26 Raymond, K, "Innovation to increase profitability of steep terrain harvesting" 57 (57): 19-23, 2012
• 27 Hartsough, B. R., "Harvesting cost model for small trees in natural stands in the interior northwest" 51 (51): 54-56, 2001
• 28 Slappendel, C., "Factors affecting work-related injury among forestry workers : A review" 24 (24): 19-32, 1993
• 29 Slappendel, C., "Factors affecting work-related injury among forestry workers : A review" 24 (24): 19-32, 1993
• 30 Pausch, R., "Ein System-Ansatz zur Untersuchung von Zusammenhängen zwischen Waldstruktur, Arbeitsvolumina und Kosten der technischen und biologischen Produktion in Forstrevieren ost-und nordbayerischer Mittelgebirge" Technische Universität München 2002
• 31 Cho, M. J, "Efficient tree-length harvesting system using tower-yarder and tractor-yarder" Kangwon National University 2015
• 32 Nakagawa, M., "Effect of tree size on time of each work element and processing productivity using an excavator-based single-grip harvester or processor at a landing" 15 (15): 226-233, 2010
• 33 Nakagawa, M., "Effect of tree size on productivity and time required for work elements in selective thinning by a harvester" 18 (18): 24-28, 2007
• 34 Korea National Oil Corporation, "Domestic oil prices"
• 35 Han, W. S, "Development of an estimation model for timber harvesting and transportation costs" Kookmin University 2008
• 36 Miyata, E. S, "Determining fixed and operation costs of logging equipment. U.S" 16-, 1980
• 37 LeDoux, C. B., "Comparison of two cut-to-length harvesting systems operating in eastern hardwoods" 12 (12): 53-60, 2001
• 38 Cho, M. J., "Comparison of productivity and cost between two integrated harvesting systems in South Korea" 10 (10): 763-, 2019
• 39 Zinkevicius, R., "Comparison of harvester and motor-manual logging in intermediate cuttings of deciduous stands" 36 (36): 591-600, 2012
• 40 Bell, J. L, "Changes in logging injury rates associated with use of feller-bunchers in West Virginia" 33 (33): 463-471, 2002
• 41 Bilici, E., "Assessing the effects of site factors on the productivity of a feller buncher : A time and motion analysis" 30 (30): 1471-1478, 2019
• 42 Ministry of Employment and Labor(MOEL), "Analysis of industrial accident status"
• 43 Stampfer, K., "A new approach to derive a productivity model for the harvester Valmet 911 Snake" 254-262, 2001
• 44 Woo, B. M., "A study on economical analysis of yarding operation by cable crane" 79 (79): 413-418, 1990
• 45 최윤성 ; 조민재 ; 문호성 ; 김대현 ; 차두송 ; 한상균 ; 오재헌, "2중 무선 클램프 반송기를 이용한 굴삭기 기반 타워야더의 생산성 및 비용 분석" 한국산림과학회 107 (107): 266-277, 2018