규모의 지리 측면에서 바라본 창조적 계급과 도시창조성 = Reconstruction of the concepts of creative class and urban creativity in the multisclalar approach

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

On the basis of a multiscalar view, this paper examines how the urban creativity can be constituted out of factors operating at various geographical scales. In partic-ular, it aims to introduce the approach of critical realism into the analytic frame of the urban creativity. Up to now, since most of the studies about urban creativity have focused on the urban or neighbourhod scale, some crucial mechanism originat-ing from global, national scale. The creative capacity of one city, however, must be understod as a contingent product of complex interactions among various scales. Although the factors of one scale may have the internal/necessary relation, those from diferent scales have the external/contingent relation. The norms of urban crea-tivity, thus, must be considered as products of contingent relations betwen various geographical scales. In this paper, I conclude that policy makers ned to discern tasks having internal relation with the urban creativity from many contingent foreign experiences.

국문 초록 (Abstract)

본 논문은 최근 도시성장전략 또는 재생전략으로 각광받고 있는 창조성 논의가 지나치게 도시규모에 갇혀 있어 창조성의 실제를 이루는 다양한 측면을 놓치고 있다는 문제의식에서 출발한다. 도시의 창조성이라는 것이 도시에서 드러나는 경향이 큰 건 사실이지만 그 창조성은 도시 외의 다른 규모에서 기인하는 요인도 다양하게 존재한다. 이것이 이른바 다규모적 접근이 필요한 이유다. 외국의 경험들 속에서 드러나는 도시의 창조성은 도시규모에서 드러나는 지표들 외에 국가나 글로벌 규모 또는 근린규모에서의 다양한 요인들이 해당 사회의 도시적 맥락에서 접합한 것이다. 따라서 이를 도시규모에서 드러나는 특징들에 기인하는 것으로 오해해 규범화할 경우 정책적 혼선, 나아가 의도하지 않은 결과들이 일어날 개연성이 높은 것이다. 본 연구에서는 도시 창조성을 다양한 규모에서 경험 연구한 논의들을 종합해 도시 창조성의 실재는 다양한 규모의 내적·외적 관계가 접합됨을 논증하고, 향후 창조적 도시를 향한 정책적 적용에 있어 다른 틀에서 접근할 필요가 있음을 주장한다.

참고문헌 (Reference)

• 1 황은정, "창조산업의 분포특성과 프로젝트 조직의 군집화" 서울대학교 2007
• 2 박배균, "지역정치가 경제활동의 세계화에 미치는 영향에 대한 연구" 25 : 10-45, 2005
• 3 이용숙, "세계화 시대의 지역경제발전: 클러스터론과 세계생산네트워크론의 비교연구" (봄) : 227-254, 2006
• 4 구문모, "서울시 창조산업의 경제적 성과와 집적화에 대한 일고찰" 17 : 223-250, 2005
• 5 김학희, "문화소비공간으로서 삼청동의 부상: 갤러리 호황과 서울시 도심 재활성화 전략에 대한 비판적 성찰" 10 : 144-162, 2007
• 6 Gibson, C., "the ‘Cultural Turn’ in australian Regional Economic Development Discourse: Neoliberalising Creativity?" 43 (43): 93-102, 2005
• 7 Smith, N., "Uneven Development: Nature, Capital and the Production of Space" Blackwell 1994
• 8 Lovering, J., "Theory led by policy: the inadequancies of the ‘New Regionalism’" 23 : 379-395, 1999
• 9 Agnew, J., "The territorial trap: the geographical assumptions of international relations theory" 1 : 53-80, 1994
• 10 Shea, C., "The road to riches?" 29 : 1-3, 2004
• 11 Delaney, "The political construction of scale" 16 (16): 93-97, 1997
• 12 Ottaviano, G., "The economic value of cultural diversity: evidence from US cities" 6 : 9-44, 2006
• 13 Malanga, S., "The curse of the creative class" 14 : 36-45, 2004
• 14 Jonas, A., "The Scale Politics of Spatiality" 12 (12): 257-264, 1994
• 15 Florida, R., "The Rise of the Creative Class in Creative Class 창조적 변화를 주도하는 사람들" 전자신문사 2002
• 16 Leo, P., "The New Singapore: Mediating Culture and Creativity" 18 (18): 205-218, 2004
• 17 Gertler M., "The Invention of Regional culture in Geographies of Economies" Arnold 53-64, 1997
• 18 Wang, J., "The Global Reach of a New Discourse: How far can ‘Creative Industries’ Travel?" 7 (7): 9-19, 2004
• 19 Florida, R., "The Flight of the Creative Class" HarperBusiness 2005
• 20 Coy, P., "The Creative Economy" Businessweek Online 2000
• 21 Landry, C., "The Creative City: A Toolkit for Urban Innovators" Comedia 2000
• 22 Fainstein, S., "The Changing World Economy and Urban Restructuring in Readings in Urban Theory" Blackwell 2002
• 23 Florida, R., "Technology and Tolerance: The Importance of Diversity to High-Technology Growth" 9 : 199-219, 2003
• 24 Peck, J., "Struggling with the Creative Class" 29 : 740-770, 2005
• 25 Evans, G. L., "Strategies for Creative Spaces" Phase Report 2006
• 26 Thomas, J. M., "Social Diversity and Development in the Metropolis" 51 : 153-168, 2006
• 27 Howitt, R., "Scale as relation: musical metaphors of geographical" 30 (30): 49-58, 1998
• 28 G. Robertson, "Remaking scale: competition and cooperation in prenational and postnational Europe in Competitive European Peripheries" Springer 59-74, 1995
• 29 Christopherson S., "Project work in context: regulatory change and the new geography of media" 34 : 2003-2015, 2002
• 30 Massey, D., "Politics and space/time" 196 : 65-84, 1992
• 31 Rantisi, N. M., "Placing the creative economy: scale, politics, and the material" 38 : 1789-1797, 2006
• 32 Lucas, R., "On the Mechanics of Economic Development in Frontiers of research in economic theory: the Nancy L. Schwartz Memorial Lectures, 1983~1997" Cambridge University Press 1986
• 33 Oakley, K., "Not so Cool Britannia" 7 (7): 67-77, 2004
• 34 Sayer, A., "Method in Social Science: A realist approach in 사회과학방법론" 한울 1999
• 35 G. Robertson, "Mapping the Futures. Local Cultures, Global Change" Routledge 97-119,
• 36 Cox, K., "Locality and community in the politicsof local economic development" 78 : 307-325, 1988
• 37 MacKinnon, D., "Learning. Innovation and Regional Development: a Critical Appraisal of Recent Debates" 26 : 293-311, 2002
• 38 Miles, S., "Introduction: the rise and rise of culture-led urban regeneration" 42 : 833-839, 2005
• 39 Webber, M., "International Political Economy in A Companion to Economic Geography" Blackwell 2000
• 40 McCann, "Inequality and Politics in the Creative City-Region: Questions of Livability and State Strategy" 31 : 188-196, 2007
• 41 Izushi, H., "Industry evolution and cross-sectoral skill transfers: a comparative analysis of the video game industry in Japan, the United States, and the United Kingdom" 38 : 1843-1861, 2006
• 42 Smith, N., "Homeless/global: scaling places" 1993
• 43 Solow, R., "Growth theory: an exposition" Oxford University Press 1969
• 44 Markusen, A., "Fuzzy Concepts. Scanty Evidence. Policy Distance: the Case for rigour and Policy Relevance in Critical Regional Studies" 33 : 869-884, 1999
• 45 Inglehart, R., "Culture Shift in Advanced Industrial Society" Princeton University Press 1990
• 46 Saris, J., "Creativity as competitive factor for urban regions in Creativity and the city. How the creative economy is changing the city" NAi Publishers 108-143, 2005
• 47 Caves. R., "Creative Industry: Contacts between Art and Commerce" Harvard University Press 2004
• 48 UK DCMS, "Creative Industries Mapping Document"
• 49 Hartley, J., "Creative Industries" Blackwell 2005
• 50 Scott, A., "Creative Cities: Conceptual Issues and Policy Questions" 28 (28): 1-17, 2006
• 51 Flew, T., "Creative Cities and Creative Clusters" 2005
• 52 Florida, R., "Cities and the Creative Class" Routledge 2005
• 53 Jones, P., "Capitalising culture: Liverpool 2008" 19 : 341-360, 2004
• 54 Dreher, C., "Be Creative, or die" Salon 2002
• 55 Purcell, M., "Against the local trap: scale and the study of environment and development" 5 : 279-297, 2005
• 56 Gibson, C., "Academic publishing as ‘creative’ industry, and recent discourses of ‘creative economies’: some critical reflections" 36 (36): 423-434, 2004
• 57 Taylor, P., "A Materialist Framework for Political Geography" 7 : 15-34, 1982
• 58 Michigan Department of Labor & Economic Growth, "2006 Cool Cities Grants & Planning Program"