로마서에 나오는 바울 복음의 중심을 향하여 = 로마서 1:16-8:39 담화 분석

국문 초록 (Abstract)

본 연구는 로마서 1:16-8:39에 나오는 바울 복음에 대한 언어학적 담화 분석이다. 연구의 주 목적은 다음의 세 가지 질문에 답을 하는 것이다. 로마서 1:16-8:39에서 바울 사상의 중심 부분은 어디인가? 중심부분의 내용은 무엇인가? 그리고 어떻게 중심 부분을 규명할 수 있는가? 바울의 논지를 조사하기 위해서 본 연구는 언어학적 담화 분석을 토대로 다음과 같은 결론을 내린다. 로마서 1:16-8:39에 나오는 바울의 복음은 하나님과 인간 사이의 상호 작용의 틀과 두 영역 틀을 통해서 설명된다. 로마서 1:18-5:11에서 복음을 설명하는 기본적 틀로 등장하는 상호작용의 틀은 자신의 신성을 드러내거나 구원 과정을 시작하는 하나님의 시작과 그에 대한 인간의 거절이나 믿음의 반응이 있고, 그것에 따른 하나님의 진노와 구원이라는 결과로 구성되어 있다. 또한 두 영역의 틀은 죄의 옛 영역과 구원과 은혜의 새 영역의 대조로 구성되어 있으며 로마서 5:12-8:39의 기본 틀로 나온다. 이런 두 설명적 틀 속에 나타나는 바울 논지들의 논리적 관계성 고찰을 통해서 필자는 바울의 복음이 하나님의 구원에 대한 예수의 역할과 그 결과를 논하는 중심부(롬 5장)와 하나님과 성령의 역할을 설명하는 두 개의 보조 중심부(롬 3:21-26과 롬 8장)로 구성되어 있다고 주장한다.

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

This study is a linguistic discourse analysis of Paul’s gospels in Rom 1:16-8:39. The major objective is to answer the following three questions: Where is Paul’s central point(s) or peak(s) in Rom 1:16-8:39? What is the content of the peak point(s)? And how can one identify the central point(s)? In order to investigate Paul’s arguments, this study suggests a discourse analytic methodology. After examining the topical flow and its logical relationship in Rom 1:16-8:39 based on this methodology, this study concludes that Paul’s arguments in Rom 1:16-8:39 are delivered by two descriptive frameworks: (1) interactive framework between God and humans; and (2) two-realm framework. As a dominant framework in Rom 1:16-5:11, the interactive framework shows a process that God begins the interaction by revealing his divine attribute or salvific process, and humans respond to it either by sinful rejection or faith. According to the nature of human response, God also renders either wrath and judgment or salvation to humans. The two-realm framework has a contrast between old sinful realm and new realm of grace and salvation, and it appears as the fundamental framework in Rom 5:12-8:39. According to the logical relationship of Paul’s argument within these frameworks, I insist that his gospel about God’s salvation has one peak point(Romans 5), which shows the central role of Jesus and its result in God’s salvation, and two sub-peaks(Rom 3:21-26 and Romans 8), which elucidate salvation with the stress on the role of God and the Holy Spirit.

목차 (Table of Contents)

• 1. 들어가면서
• 2. 로마서에 나오는 바울 복음의 중심을 향하여
• 3. 나오면서
• 참고문헌
• 초록
• Abstract

참고문헌 (Reference)

• 1 Earnshaw, J. D., "“Reconsidering Paul’s Marriage Analogy in Romans 7:1-4" 40 : 68-88, 1994
• 2 Dunn, J. D. G., "“Once More, PISTIS CRISTOU,”" Scholars Press 4 : 61-81, 1997
• 3 Cranfield, C. E. B., "“On the Pi,stij Cristou/ Question,” On Romans and Other New Testament Essays" T. & T. Clark 81-97, 1998
• 4 Howard, G., "‘On the ‘Faith of Christ’" 60 : 459-465, 1967
• 5 Longenecker, B. W., "pi,stij in Romans 3:25: Neglected Evidence for the ‘Faithfulness of Christ’?" 39 : 478-480, 1993
• 6 Gathercole, S.J., "Where Is Boasting?" Eerdmans 2002
• 7 Howard, G., "The ‘Faith of Christ’" 85 : 212-215, 1973
• 8 Lambrecht, J., "The Wretched “I” and Its Liberation: Paul in Romans 7 and 8" Peters/Grand Rapids: Eerdmans 14 : 1992
• 9 Miller, James C., "The Romans Debate: 1991-2001" 9 : 306-349, 2001
• 10 Ziesler, J. A., "The Role of Tenth Commandment in Romans 7" 33 : 41-56, 1988
• 11 Porter, Stanley E., "The Rhetorical Scribe: Textual Variants in Romans and Their Possible Rhetorical Purpose" Sheffield Academic Press 195 : 403-419, 2002
• 12 Jervis, L. A., "The Purpose of Romans" Sheffield Academic Press 55 : 1991
• 13 Taylor, G. M., "The Function of pi,stij Cristou/ in Galatians" 85 : 58-76, 1966
• 14 Moo, D. J., "The Epistle to the Romans, NICNT" Eerdmans 1996
• 15 Porter, Stanley E., "The Argument of Romans 5: Can a Rhetorical Question Make A Difference?" 110 : 655-677, 1991
• 16 Dunn, J. D. G., "Romans, WBC" Word 1988
• 17 Bruce, F. F., "Romans, TNTC" Eerdmans 1983
• 18 Byrne, B., "Romans, Sacra Pagina" Liturgical Press 1996
• 19 Jewett, R., "Romans, Hermeneia" Fortress 2007
• 20 Schreiner, T. R., "Romans, BECNT" Baker 1998
• 21 Fitzmyer, J. A., "Romans, AB" Doubleday 1993
• 22 Guerra, A.J., "Romans and the Apologetic Tradition" Cambridge University Press 81 : 1995
• 23 Song, Changwon, "Reading Romans as a Diatribe" Peter Lang 59 : 2004
• 24 Johnson, L. T., "Reading Romans" Crossroad 1997
• 25 Theissen, G., "Psychological Aspect of Pauline Theology" Fortress 1987
• 26 Stuhlmacher, P., "Paul’s letter to the Romans" Westminster/John Knox Press 1994
• 27 Tobin, T. H., "Paul’s Rhetoric in Its Contexts" Hendrickson Publishers 2004
• 28 Witherington, Ben., "Paul’s Letter to the Romans" Eerdmans 2004
• 29 Lee, Jae Hyun, "Paul’s Gospel in Romans: A Discourse Analysis of Rom 11:16-8:39" Brill 3 : 2010
• 30 Schreiner, T. R., "Paul: Apostle of God’s Glory in Christ" InterVarsity Press 2001
• 31 Beker, J. C., "Paul, the Apostle" Fortress Press 1980
• 32 Longenecker, R. N., "Paul, Apostle of Liberty" Baker Book House 1964-, 1976
• 33 Räisänen., H., "Paul and the Law" Mohr Siebeck 29 : 1983
• 34 Davies, W. D., "Paul and Rabbinic Judaism" SPCK 1965
• 35 Burnett, Gary W., "Paul & the Salvation of the Individual" Brill 57 : 2001
• 36 Hays, R. B., "PISTIS and Pauline Christology: What Is at Stake?" Scholars Press 4 : 35-60, 1997
• 37 Hooker, M. D., "PISTIS CRISTOU" 35 : 321-342, 1989
• 38 Marshall, I. H., "New Testament Theology" InterVarsity Press 2004
• 39 Snyder, Graydon F., "Major Motifs in the Interpretation of Paul’s Letter to the Romans" Eerdmans 42-63, 2004
• 40 Malherbe, A. J., "ME GENOITO in the Diatribe and Paul" 231-240, 1980
• 41 Seifrid, M. A., "Justification by Faith" Brill 68 : 1992
• 42 Keck, L. E., "Jesus’ in Romans" 108 : 443-460, 1989
• 43 Moo, D. J., "Israel and Paul in Romans 7-1-12" 32 : 122-135, 1986
• 44 Schreiner, T. R., "Interpreting Pauline Epistles" Baker book 1990
• 45 Porter, Stanley E., "Idioms of Greek New Testament, BLG 2" Sheffield Academic Press 1992
• 46 Louw, J. P., "Greek-English Lexicon of the New Testament based on Semantic Domains" United Bible Societies 1988
• 47 Garlington, Don B., "Faith, Obedience and Perseverance" Mohr Siebeck 79 : 1994
• 48 Robinson, D. W., "Faith of Jesus Christ - A New Testament Debate" 29 : 71-81, 1970
• 49 Dodd, C H., "Epistle of Paul to the Romans, MNTC" Hodder & Stoughton 1932
• 50 Hays, R. B., "Echoes of Scripture in the Letters of Paul" Yale University Press 1989
• 51 McDonald, L. M., "Early Christianity and Its Sacred Literature" Hendrickson 2000
• 52 Porter, Stanley E., "Diatribe in : Dictionary of New Testament Background" InterVarsity Press 296-298, 2000
• 53 Matlock, R. B., "Detheologizing the PISTIS CRISTOU Debate: Cautionary Remarks from a Lexical Semantic Perspective" 42 : 1-23, 2000
• 54 Lichtenberger, H., "Das Ich Adams und das Ich der Menschheit" Mohr Siebeck 164 : 2004
• 55 Esler, Philip F., "Conflict and Identity in Romans" Fortress Press 2003
• 56 Käsemann, E., "Commentary on Romans" Eerdmans 1980
• 57 Martin, R. P., "Center of Paul’s Theology" InterVarsity Press 92-95, 1993
• 58 Gorman, Michael J., "Apostle of the crucified L" Eerdmans 2004
• 59 Lee, Jae Hyun, "Against Richard B. Hays’s ‘Faith of Jesus Christ’" 5 : 51-80, 2008
• 60 Williams, S. K., "Again Pistis Christou" 49 : 431-447, 1987
• 61 Porter, Stanley E., "A Newer Perspective on Paul: Romans 1-8 through the Eyes of Literary Analysis" Sheffield Academic Press 200 : 366-392, 1995
• 62 Sanday, W., "A Critical and Exegetical Commentary on the Epistle to the Romans, ICC" T. & T. Clark 1902
• 63 Cranfield, C. E. B., "A Critical and Exegetical Commentary on the Epistle to the Romans, ICC" T&T Clark 1975
• 64 Barrett, C. K., "A Commentary on the Epistle to the Romans" Harper & Row 1957