건강권의 법적 토대와 그 실현에 대한 국제인권법적 고찰 = Legal Foundation of Right to Health and Issues for Realizing Right to Health

국문 초록 (Abstract)

이 글은 세계인권선언(UDHR)과 경제‧사회‧문화적 권리에 관한 국제협약(ICESCR)을 중심으로 오늘날 건강권이 어떻게 적용되고 실현되며 이에 대한 국제인권법적‧보건학적인 함의는 무엇인지 논의하였다. UDHR은 건강권의 법적인 토대를 놓았고 이러한 권리의 사회적인 실현을 추동해왔다. 각 국가들이 가진 보건의료자원의 정도에 따라서 개인의 권리 실현 정도에는 차이가 있으나 UDHR과 ICESCR은 국가와 사회 기관이 건강권에 대한 책무성을 가지고 관련 제도를 마련하는데 기여를 하였다. 그리고 더 나아가 건강이라는 본질적 권리가 한 사회 안에서 법적으로 검토되고 평등과 비차별의 원칙 하에서 그 실현 범위가 확대되는데 도움을 주었다. 그러나 인권이 한 국가의 실정법 안에서 뿌리내리는데 국제법의 영향력이 미미했던 것처럼 UDHR과 ICESCR 역시 현실에 존재하는 건강권 침해의 구체적 사안들을 해결하는데 제약이 있었다. 이런 측면에서 건강권을 법률적 권리로 실현하는데 국제기구와 비정부기구들(NPOs)의 역할이 컸다. 특히 전지구적 NPOs는 국제보건의 관점에서 HIV 감염인을 위해 ARV(anti-retrovirus) 치료제에 대한 접근권을 요청하여 각국 정부의 책무성(accountability)을 이끌어냈다. 이들은 정부의 관리적 인권(managerial human rights)의 한계를 지속적으로 확대하고자 노력했으며 재판회부가능성을 높여서 건강권의 법적 실현에 도움을 주었다. 그러므로 오늘날 건강권의 근본적인 실현을 위해서는 UDHR과 ICESCR 등을 통하여 건강권의 법적 토대를 강화하는 것뿐 아니라 국제보건의 관점에서 다양한 NPOs의 역할을 모색하는 것이 요구된다. 아울러 환자의 자율성 문제와 같이 점증하는 보건의료 분야의 윤리적인 사안들을 검토하여 건강권 실현을 위한 절차화를 고민하는 것도 필요하다.

참고문헌 (Reference)

• 1 김주경, "헌법상 건강권의 개념 및 그 내용" 3 (3): 2011
• 2 이주영, "지적재산권협정(TRIPs)과 국제인권법의 관계: 의약품 접근성의 맥락에서" 2013
• 3 김왕배, "인권으로서의 건강권에 대한 탐색과 전망" 한국보건사회학회 (32) : 5-18, 2012
• 4 정민수, "인권과 건강의 상호교차성- 보건의료의 측면에서 본 인간 존엄성과 사회적 존엄성 -" 한국의료법학회 21 (21): 7-28, 2013
• 5 Foucault M, "성의 역사 1: 앎의 의지" 나남 2004
• 6 Faunce T, "Will international human rights subsume medical ethics?" 31 : 173-, 2004
• 7 Callahan D, "Why America accepted Bioethics" 8 : 8-, 1993
• 8 London L, "What is a human rights-based approach to health and Does it matter?" 10 (10): 65-72, 2008
• 9 "Universal Declaration of Human Rights (1948. 12. 10.) UNGA Res 217A (III)"
• 10 Freeman LP, "UN Millennium Project Task Force on Child Health and Maternal Health, Who's Got the Power? Transforming Health Systems for Women and Children" 34-, 2005
• 11 Kennedy I, "Treat Me Right" Oxford University Press 1988
• 12 Chapman AR, "The social determinants of health, health equity, and human rights" 12 (12): 17-, 2010
• 13 Landau D, "The reality of social rights enforcement" 53 (53): 223-224, 2012
• 14 Rothman DJ, "The origins and consequences of patient autonomy: A 25-year retrospective" 9 : 261-, 2001
• 15 Meron T, "The humanization of humaniratian law" 94 : 239-, 2000
• 16 Morsink J, "The Universal Declaration of Human Rights: Origins, Drafting, and Intent" University of Pennsylvania Press 2000
• 17 Alstocn P, "The United Nations and Human Rights: A Critical Appraisal" Oxford University Press 1992
• 18 MacNaughton G, "The State of Economic and Social Human Rights: A Global Overview" Cambridge University Press 2012
• 19 Sunstein CR, "The Second Bill of Rights" Basic Books 2004
• 20 Tobin J, "The Rightto Health in International Law" Oxford University Press 2012
• 21 Sarat A, "The Place of Law" University of Michigan Press 2003
• 22 Annas GJ, "The Nazi Doctors and the Nuremberg Code: Human Rights in Human Experimentation" Oxford University Press 1995
• 23 Moll A, "The Logic of Care: Health and the Problem of Patient Choice" Routledge 2008
• 24 Shubber S, "The International Code of Marketing of Breast-Milk Substitutes" Kluwer 1998
• 25 Hollis A, "The Health Impact Fund: Making New Medicines Available for All"
• 26 Glendon MA, "The Forgotten Crucible: The Latin American Influence on the Universal Human Rights Idea" 16 : 27-, 2003
• 27 Schutter O De, "The European Social Charter: A Social Constitution for Europe" Bruylant 2010
• 28 Greer S, "The European Convention on Human Rights: Achievements, Problems and Prospects" Cambridge University Press 2006
• 29 Rothman DJ, "Stranger at the Beside: A History of How Law and Bioethics Transformed Medical Decision Making" Basic Books 1991
• 30 White LE, "Stones of Hope: How African Activists Reclaim Human Rights to Challenge Global Poverty" Stanford University Press 2011
• 31 Yamin AE, "Shades of dignity: Exploring the Demands of Equality in Applying Human Rights Frameworks to Health" 11 (11): 1-, 2009
• 32 Jacobs BB, "Respect for Human Dignity in Nursing: Philosophical and Practical Perspectives" 32 : 15-33, 2000
• 33 Strathern M, "Reproducing the Future: Essays on Anthropology, Kinship and the New Reproducive Technologies" Manchester University Press 1992
• 34 Montgomery J, "Reflections on the nature of public bioethics" 22 : 9-, 2013
• 35 Clapham A, "Realising the Right to Health" Rüffer & Rub 2009
• 36 Blanchard J, "R-E-S-P-E-C-T: Patient reports of disrespect in the health care setting and its impact on care" 53 : 721-730, 2004
• 37 Bilchitz D, "Poverty and Fundamental Rights: The Justification and Enforcement of Socioeconomic Rights" Oxford University Press 2007
• 38 Landau D, "Political Institutions and Judicial Role in Comparative Constitutional Law" 51 : 319-, 2010
• 39 Ayer AJ, "Philosophical Essays" Macmillan 1954
• 40 Tauber AL, "Patient Autonomy and the Ethics of Responsibility" MIT Press 2005
• 41 Seale A, "Partnership, Sex, and Marginalization" 12 (12): 123-, 2010
• 42 Meeks MD, "On Human Dignity: Political Theology and Ethics" Fortress Press 1984
• 43 Kennedy I, "Medical Law: Text and Materials" Butterworths 1994
• 44 Syrett K, "Law, Legitimacy and the Rationing of Health Care: A Contextual and Comparative Perspective" Cambridge University Press 2007
• 45 Brownsword R, "Law and the Technologies of the Twenty-First Century" Cambridge University Press 2012
• 46 Montgomery J, "Law and the Demoralisation of Medicine" 26 : 185-, 2006
• 47 Daniels N, "Just Health: Meeting Health Needs Fairly" Cambridge University Press 2008
• 48 King J, "Judging Social Rights" Cambridge University Press 2012
• 49 Rajagopal B, "International Law from Below: Development, Social Movements and Third World Resistance" Cambridge University Press 2003
• 50 Davis KE, "Indicators as Interventions: Pitfalls and Prospects in Supporting Development Initiative" Rockfeller Foundation 2011
• 51 Boyle A, "Human rights or environmental rights: A reassessment" 18 : 471-, 2007
• 52 Pullman D, "Human dignity and the ethics and aesthetics of pain and suffering" 23 : 75-94, 2002
• 53 Redfield P, "Human Rights in Crisis" Ashgate Publishing 139-140, 2008
• 54 Koch IE, "Human Rights as Indivisible Rights: The Protection of Socioeconomic Demands under the European Convention on Human Rights" Martinus Nijhoff 2009
• 55 Gostin LO, "Human Rights and Public Health in the AIDS Pandemic" Oxford University Press 1997
• 56 World Health Organization, "Health for All in the Twenty-First Century"
• 57 Oppenheimer GM, "Health and Human Rights: Old Wine in New Bottles?" 30 : 522-, 2002
• 58 Mann JM, "Health and Human Rights: If Not Now, Then When?" 2 (2): 113-, 1997
• 59 Murphy T, "Health and Human Rights" Oxford University Press 2013
• 60 Maunz T, "Grundgesetz Kommentar" Beck 2011
• 61 Hassoun N, "Globalization and Global Justice: Shrinking Distance, Expanding Obligations" Cambridge University Press 2012
• 62 Joint United Nations Programme on HIV/AIDS (UNAIDS), "Global Report: UNAIDS Report on the Global AIDS Epidemic" UNAIDS 2012
• 63 Meier BM, "Global Health and Human Rights: Legal and Philosophical Perspectives" Routledge 2010
• 64 Forman L, "Global AIDS Funding and the Re-emergence of AIDS “Exceptionalism" 45 : 45-, 2011
• 65 Dworkin R, "Free Will and Responsibility. Justice for Hedgehogs" Belknap Harvard 2011
• 66 Jacob MA, "Form-Made Persons: Consent Forms as Consent’s Blind Spot" 249 : 260-, 2007
• 67 Ashcroft RA, "Fair process and the redundancy of bioethics: A polemic" 3 : 7-, 2008
• 68 Brems E, "Exploring Social Rights: Between Theory and Practice" Hart Publishing 2007
• 69 Rabinow P, "Essays on the Anthropology of Reason" Princeton University Press 1996
• 70 Gargarella R, "Editors, Courts and Social Transformation in New Democracies: An Institutional Voice for the Poor?" Ashgate Publishing 2006
• 71 Ssenyonjo M, "Economic, Social and Cultural Rights in International Law" Hart Publishing 2009
• 72 Pannuti F, "Dying with Dignity: Illusion, Hope or Human Right?" 14 : 172-173, 1993
• 73 Libet B, "Do we have free will?" 6 (6): 45-, 1999
• 74 Koch IE, "Dichotomies, trichotomies or waves of duties?" 5 : 81-, 2005
• 75 World Medical Association, "Declaration of Helsinki"
• 76 Gauri V, "Courting Social Justice: Judicial Enforcement of Social and Economic Rights in the Developing World" Cambridge University Press 2008
• 77 Libet B, "Conscious vs Neural Time" 352 (352): 27-28, 1991
• 78 Commission on Social Determinants of Health, "Closing the Gap in a Generation: Health Equity through Action on the Social Determinants of Health"
• 79 Lenoir N, "Biotechnology, Bioethics and Law: Europe's 21st Century Challenge" 69 : 1-, 2006
• 80 Yamin AE, "Beyond compassion: The central role of accountability in applying a human rights framework to health" 10 (10): 1-, 2008
• 81 Walker N, "Beyond Boundary Disputes and Basic Grids: Mapping the Global Disorder of Normative Orders" 6 : 373-396, 2008
• 82 O’Neal O, "Autonomy and Trust in Bioethics" Cambridge University Press 2001
• 83 Annas GJ, "American Bioethics: Crossing Human Rights and Health Law Boundaries" Oxford University Press 2005
• 84 Scott C, "Adjudicating constitutional priorities in a transnational context: A comment on Soobramoney's Legacy and Grootboom's Promise" 16 : 206-, 2000
• 85 Glendon MA, "A World Made New: Eleanor Roosevelt and the Universal Declaration of Human Rights" Random House 2002