러시아의 우크라이나 침략의 본질 - 러시아의 오래된 제국적 기획의 실현 = The truth of Russia’s invasion of Ukraine - The realization of Russia’s old imperial project

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Many experts and intellectuals from around the world and Korea have been conducting formal discussions without any knowledge of Russia’s tenacious and meticulous strategy to make the Ukrainian state itself disappear. What is important is the fact that the essence of war has been concealed in this process.
In addition, China and Russia have been recognized as a socialist counter-system that has long resisted the US-centered world system and the tendency to give positive meaning to Russia as a multipolarization-leading force opposing the Western world division and domination order under US hegemony. Due to the long inertia, the situation continues to fail to grasp the essence of this war. The nature of this war, which Russia is preemptively engaged in despite not receiving serious threats from Ukraine, can be understood only outside the framework of discussions that have been raised so far. All of the claims related to the cause of the war posed by the Western, Ukrainian, and Russian sides, such as the US, which are in sharp opposition, are not without basis, but within the existing frame that may miss the true essence of an illegal war of aggression. It is necessary to refrain from discussion.

국문 초록 (Abstract)

세계와 한국의 많은 전문가들과 지식인들은 우크라이나 국가 자체를 사라지게 하려는 러시아의 집요하고도 치밀한 전략을 전혀 모른 채 형식적인 논의를 이어오고 있다.
중요한 것은 이 과정 속에서 전쟁의 본질이 은폐되어 왔다는 사실이다. 게다가 중국과더불어 러시아에 대해서도 미국의 헤게모니하 서구의 세계분할지배 질서에 반대하는 다극화 주도 세력으로서 긍정적 의미를 부여하는 경향과 미국 중심의 세계체제에 오랫동안 저항해 온 사회주의적 대항체제 세력으로 인식해 온 오랜 관성으로 인해 이 전쟁의본질을 파악하지 못하는 상황이 지속되고 있다. 우크라이나로부터의 심각한 위협을 받지 않았음에도 불구하고 러시아가 선제적으로 벌이고 있는 이 전쟁의 본질은 지금까지제기되어 왔던 논의의 틀을 벗어나야 이해가 가능하다고 할 수 있다. 첨예하게 대립하고있는 미국 등 서구, 우크라이나 측과 러시아 측이 제기하고 있는 전쟁의 원인과 관련된주장들 모두 다 근거가 없는 것은 아니지만 자칫 불법적인 침략 전쟁의 진정한 본질을놓칠 수도 있는 기존의 프레임 내에서의 논의를 지양하는 것이 필요하다.

참고문헌 (Reference)

• 1 Goble, P, "‘Hybrid Truth’ as Putin’s New Reality"
• 2 Sonechnyi udar, "dir. Mikhalkov. N"
• 3 Trotskii, "dir. Kott. A. and Statskii. K."
• 4 News24UA. com, "Yanukovich i Timoshenko: eto ne Lichnosti, a politicheskie mashiny- Aleksandr Prokhanov"
• 5 Glaziev, S, "Who Stands to Win?: Political and Economic Factors in Regional Integration"
• 6 Umland, A., "Vladimir Zhirinovskyy in Russian Politics" Free University of Belarus 1997
• 7 PK, "Vladimir Putin called the annexation of Crimea the most important event of the past year"
• 8 Fond Demokratychni Initsiatyvy im. Il’ka Kucheriva, "Vid Maidanu-taboru-do Maidanu-sichi"
• 9 Russkia Liniia, "V Moskve sostoialas’ tseremonia perezakhroneniia prakha generala A. I. Denikina i filosofa I. A. Ilyina"
• 10 NTV, "V Kieve aktivisty vodili khorovod i protykali puzyr’ evrogomointegratsii"
• 11 Herzenhorn, D. M, "Unrest Deepens in Ukraine as Protests Turn Deadly"
• 12 Johnson’s Russia List, "Ukraine’s Catch 22 Over Its Oligarch Class"
• 13 Motyl, A. J., "Ukraine: The Yanukovych Family Business"
• 14 Snyder, T., "Ukraine: The New Dictatorship"
• 15 Korovin, V, "Ukraina so vremenem vernetsia k Rossii"
• 16 News24UA. com, "Ukraina dolzhna stat’ tsentrom Evrazii: Aleksandr Prokhanov"
• 17 Dugin, A, "Tretsii put’ i trets’ia sila"
• 18 Dugin, A., "Towards Laocracy"
• 19 Kripkov, O., "To Serve God and Russia: Life and Thought of Russian Philosopher Ivan Il’in" University of Kansas 1998
• 20 Trueinform, "The gay maelstrom of Euro-integration"
• 21 Dugin, A., "The War on Russia in its Ideological Dimention"
• 22 Viola, L, "The Ukrainian Gulag" Oxford University Press 2007
• 23 Soldatov, A., "The True Role of the FSB in the Ukrainian Crisis"
• 24 Kellogg, M, "The Russian Roots of Nazism" UK 2005
• 25 Sherr, J, "The Russian Challenge" Chatham House 2015
• 26 Bachman, K., "The Maidan Uprising, Separatism and Foreign Intervention" Peter Lang 2014
• 27 Sattter, D., "The Less You Know, The Better You Sleep" New York 2016
• 28 Arad, Y, "The Holocaust in the Soviet Union" University of Nebraska Press 2009
• 29 Basin, M, "The Gumilev Mystique" Cornell University Press 2016
• 30 Graziozi, A, "The Great Peasant War" Harvard Ukrainian Research Institute 1996
• 31 Plokhy, S, "The Gates of Europe" Basic Books 2015
• 32 Strzelecki, J, "The Eurasian Economic Union: A time of crisis"
• 33 Kudelia, S, "The Donbas Rift" 54 (54): 5-27, 2016
• 34 Riabov, O., "The Decline of Gayropa?"
• 35 Heschel, S, "The Arian Jesus" Princeton 2010
• 36 New York Times, "The Agency"
• 37 Surkov, V, "Suvernitet: Eto politicheskii sinonim konkurentosposobnosti" Evropa 2008
• 38 Gouldner, A, "Stalinism: A Study of Internal Colonialism" (38) : 34-56, 2009
• 39 Surkov, V, "Speech at Center for Party Studies and Personnel Training ant the United Russia Party"
• 40 Memorandum ekpertov Izborskovo Kluba, "Spasti Ukrainu!"
• 41 Zaidman, I, "Russkii filosof Ivan Il’in i ego pokhlonik Vladimir Putin"
• 42 Reuters, "Russia’s Putin signs NGO ‘foreign agents’ law"
• 43 Matthews, O., "Russia’s Greatest Weapons Maybe Its Hackers"
• 44 Grove, T., "Russian ‘smear’ documentary provokes protests"
• 45 Stopfake, "Russian ultra-nationalists come to fight in Ukraine"
• 46 BigMir, "Russian troops in Crimea and traitor admiral"
• 47 DiLeonardo, R., "Russian president signs law re-criminizing libel and slander"
• 48 Shekhovtsov, A., "Russian and Western Far Right" Routledge 2017
• 49 Grier, P. T, "Russian Thought after Communism" M. E. Sharpe 1994
• 50 Human Rights Watch, "Russia: New Treason Law Threatens Rights"
• 51 Putin, V, "Russia: Natsional’nyi vopros"
• 52 Rupert, J., "Russia Allows - or Organizes – Chechen Fighters to Reinforce the Secessionist War in Ukraine"
• 53 Trudoliubov, M., "Rossiskoe obshestvo ne vidit sebia"
• 54 Applebaum. A, "Red Famine: Stalin’s War on Ukraine" Doubleday 2017
• 55 Snyder, T, "Reconstruction of Nations: Poland Ukraine, Lithuania, Belarus, 1569~1999" Yale University Press 2004
• 56 Moscow Times, "Rebel Leader Blames Ukrainian War on Masons"
• 57 Ilyin, I, "Put’ dukhovnogo obnovleniia, in Sobranie sochnenii Vol.1"
• 58 Telgina, N., "Put’ Malofeeva: Ot detskovo pitania k sponsorstvu Donbassa i proshchenym"
• 59 Arkhipov, I., "Putin’s ‘Soros’ Dreams of Empire as Allies Wage Ukraine Revolt"
• 60 Shuster, S., "Putin’s Man in Crimea is Ukraine’s Worst Nightmare"
• 61 Dawisha, K, "Putin’s Kleptocracy" Simon and Schuster 2014
• 62 Dugin, A, "Putin protiv Putina" Yauza-Press 2021
• 63 Kalinnikov, M, "Putin i russkiye filosofy: Kogo tsitiruet President"
• 64 Korovin, V, "Putin i Evraziiskaia Ideologia"
• 65 Clover, C, "Putin and the Monk"
• 66 Zarakhovich, Y., "Putin Pays Homage to Ilyin"
• 67 Gregory, P. R, "Putin Demands Federalization for Ukraine, But Declares it Off-Limits for Siberia"
• 68 Medvedev, D. A, "Puti Rossii" Vagrius 2007
• 69 FT, "Profile of Russian Tycon’s Big New Christian TV Channel"
• 70 Kanygin, P, "Pridnestrovskii general’ Vladimir Antiufeev"
• 71 Kremlin, "Priamaia Liniia s Vladimirom Putinym"
• 72 Glaziev, S, "Predotvratit’ voinu: pobedit’ v voine"
• 73 Umland, A., "Post-Soviet ‘Uncivil Society’ and the Rise of Aleksandr Dugin" University of Cambridge 2007
• 74 Surkov, V., "Pochemu Putin tsitiruet filosofa Il’ina?"
• 75 Ilyin, I, "Pis’ma o fashizme: Lichnost’ Mussolini"
• 76 Ilyin, I, "Pis’ma o fashizme: Biografiia Mussolini"
• 77 Walker, S., "Patriotic group formed to defend Russia against pro-democracy protesters"
• 78 Saenko, T, "Parlamentrii o priniatii v sostav Rossiiskoi Federatsii novykh sub’ektov"
• 79 Sokolov-Mitrich, D., "Ostavit’ Bogu mesto v istorii"
• 80 Ilyin, I, "Osnovy gosudarstvennogo ustroistva" Rarog 1996
• 81 Prokhanov, A., "Odinnadtsatyi stalinskii udar: O Nashem novom Dne Pobedy"
• 82 Ilyin, I, "O soprotivlenii zlu siloiu, in Sobranie sochnenii Vol.5"
• 83 Ilyin, I, "O Russkom fashizme"
• 84 Putin, b, "Novyi integratsionnyi proekt dlia Evrazii: budushchee, kotoroe rozhdaetsia segodnia"
• 85 Pomerantsev, P, "Nothing is True and Everything is Possible" Public Affairs 2014
• 86 Yakunin, V, "Nonyi mirovoi klass’ vyzov dlia chelovechestva"
• 87 Chalupa, I., "Needing Better Control in Ukraine War, Moscow Sends in an Old KGB Hand"
• 88 Lower, W, "Nazi Empire-Building and the Holocaust in Ukraine" University of North Carolina Press 2005
• 89 Ilyin, I, "Nashi Zadachi: Stat’i 1948~1954" Izdanie Russkogo obshevoinskogo soiuza 1956
• 90 Luhn, A., "Moscow Holds First May Day Since Soviet Era"
• 91 Kremlin, "Meeting with young scientists and history teachers"
• 92 Izborsk Club, "Manifest Otsov-Osnovatelei"
• 93 Finberg, L., "Maidan" Svidchenia 2016
• 94 newsru.com, "MSU will digitize archives of Ilyin"
• 95 Kalinovsky, A, "Long Goodbye: The Soviet Withdrawal from Afghanistan" Harvard University Press 2011
• 96 Titov, A. S., "Lev Gumilev, Ethnogenesis and Eurasianism" University College London 2005
• 97 Dugin, A., "Letter to the Amerian People on Ukraine"
• 98 Ilyin, I, "Kakie Zhe vybory nuzhny Rossii" 2 : 1993
• 99 Kofner, I., "Ivan Il’in: Evraziiskii filosof Putina"
• 100 Evlampiev, I. I, "Ivan Aleksandrovich Il’in" Rosspen 2014
• 101 Lavrov, S., "Istoricheskaia perspektiva vneshnei politiki Rossii"
• 102 Prokhanov, A, "Interview for Ekho Moskvy"
• 103 Pomerantsev, P, "Inside Putin’s Information War"
• 104 Mitrokhin, Nikolay, "Inflation, Instruction, Invasion" 8 : 3-16, 2014
• 105 Burlaka, D. K, "I. A. Il’in: pro et contra" Izd-vo Russkogo khristianskogo gumartarnovo In-ta 2004
• 106 Rutenberg, J, "How the Kremlin built one of the powerful information weapons of the 21st century"
• 107 Shekhovtsov, A, "How Aleksandr Dugin’s Neo-Eurasianist Geared up for the Russian-Ukranian War in 2005~2013" Euromaidan Press 2016
• 108 Dugin, A., "Horizons of Our Revolution from Crimea to Lisbon"
• 109 Glaziev, S, "Genocide: Russia and the New World Order" Executive Intelligence Review 1999
• 110 Komsomol’skaia Pravda, "Gei-drovishki v koster Maidana"
• 111 Connelly, J, "From Enemy to Brother" Harvard University Press 2012
• 112 Shevtsova, L, "Forward to the Past in Russia" 26 (26): 22-36, 2015
• 113 Putin, b, "Experts from the transcript of the meeting of the Valdai International Discussion Club"
• 114 Barnachik, Y., "Evrosoiuz: Imperria, kotoraia ne sostoialas"
• 115 Gower, J, "European Union-Russia Relations at the end of the Putin Presidency" 16 (16): 161-167, 2008
• 116 Laruelle, M, "Eurasianism and the European Far Right" Lexinton Books 2015
• 117 Snyder, T., "Diaries and Memoirs of the Maidan"
• 118 Mazower, M, "Dark Continent" Knopf 1999
• 119 Bebler, A, "Crimea and the Russian-UKrainian Conflict" 15 (15): 35-53, 2015
• 120 Clover, C, "Black Wind, White Snow: The Rise of Russia’s New Nationalism" New York 2016
• 121 Snyder, T, "Black Earth: The Holocaust as History and Warning" Tim Duggan Books 2015
• 122 Hale, H. E, "Beyond the Euromaidan" Palo Alto 2016
• 123 Ilyin, I, "Belaia ideia, in Sobranie sochnenii Vol.9-10"
• 124 Miller, James, "An Invasion by Any Other Name: Kremlin’s Dirty War on Ukraine" Institute of Modern Russia 2015
• 125 Weiss, M., "All is not well in Novorossiya"
• 126 Kanygin, P, "Aleksandr Borodai: We are not ready to conclude peace on conditions of capitulation"
• 127 Putin, b, "Address to Federal Assembly"
• 128 Putin, b, "Address to Federal Assembly"
• 129 Putin, V, "Address to Federal Assembly"
• 130 Putin, V, "Address to Federal Assembly"
• 131 Putin, b, "Address at Valdai"
• 132 Bennets, M, "A New Russian Law Targets Evangelicals and other ‘Foreign’ Reigions"