헌법 관점에서 본 ‘서울대학교 인권헌장(안)’의 문제점 = A Critical Review on the Human Rights Charter of SNU: Constitutional Perspective

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

In 2020, Seoul National University(SNU) sought to enact a human rights charter. At this time, the proposed Human Rights Charter draft can be a SNU version of the Comprehensive Anti-Discrimination Act. As a cmapus norm, the Charter is expected to provide substantive remedies and procedures to ensure its effectiveness. It can be placed in the Charter of Human Rights and can be included in the other existing provisions or new regulations. The SNU Charter affects other universities in Korea. The enactment of the Charter of Human Rights at SNU can be seen as a “planned legislation”. Therefore, it is necessary to clearly understand the dangers hidden in the Charter and take the countermeasures to eliminate them.
The interests of members of SNU, especially undergraduate and graduate students, must be protected. For this reason, it is desirable to supplement and embody the current imperfect provisions. It is necessary to enact the Guidelines for Human Rights of Graduate Students at Seoul National University. However, sexual orientation and gender identity must be excluded as grounds of discrimination. In addition, more rights can be added to the provisions of the current Human Rights Center Regulation which is the school norm of human rights.
If the Human Rights Charter is necessary as a basic minimal human rights standard, the contents must be composed of the things with which members of Seoul National University can sympathize with. Things that are disputable morally such as sexual orientation and gender identity must not be stipulated as discriminatory grounds.

참고문헌 (Reference)

• 1 유기천, "형법학[각론강의 하]" 일조각 1982
• 2 국가인권위원회, "혐오표현 리포트" 2019
• 3 민성길, "탈동성애자의 인권에 대한 국가의 역할”에 대한 토론문" 2015
• 4 이상현, "성적지향을 포함한 차별금지법안에 대한 비판적 접근: 영미법제 연구를 중심으로" 법학연구소 39 : 161-194, 2017
• 5 송지우, "서울대학교 인권규범 제정에 관한 연구"
• 6 음선필, "동성애·동성혼의 헌법적 수용에 대한 비판" 법학연구소 18 (18): 89-119, 2017
• 7 길원평, "동성애 과연 타고 나는 것일까?" 아론누리 2014
• 8 조영길, "국가인권위원회법상 차별금지사유 ‘성적 지향’ 삭제 개정의 정당성" 미래사 2016
• 9 백상현, "가짜 인권, 가짜 혐오, 가짜 소수자" 밝은생각 2017
• 10 "https://www.yna.co.kr/view/AKR20201024055600004"
• 11 "https://www.humanrights.go.kr/site/program/board/basicboard/view?menuid=001003004&pagesize=10& boardtypeid=20&boardid=617177"
• 12 "http://www.snunews.com/news/ articleView.html?idxno=16249"
• 13 "http://www.newsnnet.com/news/articleView.html?idxno=4788"
• 14 L.S. Mayer, "Executive Summary, Sexuality and Gender Finding from the Biological, Psychological, and Social Sciences" 50 : 2016
• 15 M. Foust, "Ex-homosexuals protest APA's position on homosexuality"
• 16 R. L. Spitzer, "Can Some Gay Men and Lesbians Change Their Orientation?" 32 : 2003
• 17 국가인권위원회, "2018 국가인권위원회 통계"
• 18 국가인권위원회, "2017 국가인권위원회 통계"