부시(George W. Bush) 행정부의 이란 정책: 외교정책이념과 정부정치의 동학 = The Foreign Policy of the George W. Bush Administration Toward Iran: Dynamics of Foreign Policy Thought and Governmental Politics

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

The purpose of this study is to describe and explain the Bush Administration`s policy toward the Iranian nuclear problem and its change from theoretical perspectives of foreign policy thought and the governmental politics model. As the result of the analysis, first, there were divisions and conflict over the policy about the Iranian nuclear issue between a coalition of hard-liners in the Vice-President`s Office and the Defense Department, on one hand, and one of moderates mainly in the State Department, on the other hand. And their policy positions were largely determined by foreign policy thought shared by policy-makers of each coalition. Whereas a policy of confrontation favored by the hard-liners reflected prescriptions offered by neo-conservatism, a policy of limited engagement preferred by the moderates was guided by realism. Second, the policy of passive confrontation was the political resultant of competition and conflict between the hard-liners and the moderates, and reflected the policy position favored by the former who prevailed over the policy-making process. Third, a change of policy to one of limited engagement during the 2nd Administration, resulted mainly from the factor that initiative and control over the policy-making process were shifted to the hands of the State Department moderates. The changed policy of limited engagement was primarily determined by the realist thought shared among them and a compromise in which to reflect the position of the hard-liners.

참고문헌 (Reference)

• 1 김현, "부시 행정부의 외교정책이념과 대북한 정책" 세종연구소 14 (14): 123-153, 2008
• 2 조성권, "미국-이란 핵 갈등과 미국의 에너지 안보" 세종연구소 14 (14): 155-184, 2008
• 3 프랜시스 후쿠야마, "기로에 선 미국" 랜덤하우스코리아 2006
• 4 Thompson, Mark, "Why the Pentagon Is Happy about the NIE" 2007
• 5 Lobe, Jim, "War, Diplomacy on Parallel Tracks" 2006
• 6 Burns, William, "United States Policy Toward Iran in: Under Secretary for Political Affairs, U.S. Department of State" 2008
• 7 Burns, Nicholas, "United States Policy Toward Iran In: Under Secretary for Political Affairs, U.S. Department of State" 2005
• 8 International Crisis Group, "U.S.-Iranian Engagement: The View from Tehran" 2009
• 9 Rice, Condoleezza, "U.S. Secretary of State in: Press Conference on Iran"
• 10 Maloney, Suzanne, "U.S. Policy Toward Iran: Missed Opportunities and Paths Forward" 32 (32): 25-44, 2008
• 11 Baker, Peter, "U.S. Is Studying Military Strike Options" 2006
• 12 Tisdal, Simon, "Tough Response May Seem Inevitiable But Could Play Into Tehran’s Hands" 2006
• 13 Fayazmanesh, Sasan, "The United States and Iran: Sanctions, Wars and the Policy of Dual Containment" Routledge 2008
• 14 Sick, Gary, "The US Offer to Iran" 3 (3): 2006
• 15 Walt, Stephen, "The Shattered Kristol Ball" 263-33, 2008
• 16 Rosati, Jerel, "The Power of Human Cognition in the Study of World Politics" 2 (2): 45-75, 2001
• 17 Pollack, Kenneth, "The Persian Puzzle: The Conflict Between Iran and America" Random House 2004
• 18 Campbell, Kurt, "The New Tribalism: Cliques and the Making of U.S. Foreign Policy" 30 (30): 193-203, 2006
• 19 U. S. White House, "The National Security Strategy of the United States of America"
• 20 U. S. White House, "The National Security Strategy of the United States of America"
• 21 Gordon, Philip, "The End of the Bush Revolution" 85 (85): 75-86, 2006
• 22 Kessler, Glenn, "The Confidante: Condoleezza Rice and the Creation of the Bush Legacy" St. Martin’s Press 2007
• 23 Skiba, Alexander, "The Bush-Administration’s Iran Policy and Europe: From ‘Regime Change’ to 'Engagement'" VDM Verlag Dr. Muller 2008
• 24 Milani Mohsen M., "Tehran’s Take" 88 : 46-62, 2009
• 25 Kaplan Lawrence, "Teharan Twist: Bush’s new Iran policy" 2005
• 26 Bush, George W., "State of Union Address"
• 27 Risen, James, "Spy Case Renews Debate Over Pro-Israel Lobby’s Ties to Conservatives at Pentagon" 2004
• 28 Porter, Gareth, "Seismic Shift or Non-Decision by Bush on Iran?" 2008
• 29 Hirsh, Michael, "Rumors of War" 28-35, 2007
• 30 Kessler,Glenn, "Rice Fails to Repair Rifts, Officials Say; Cabinet Rivalries Complicated Her Role" 2003
• 31 Haass, Richard, "Restoring the Balance: A Middle East Strategy for the Next President" Brookings Institute Press 2008
• 32 Litwak, Robert, "Regime Change: U.S. Strategy Through the Prism of 9/11" The Johns Hopkins UP 2007
• 33 Haass, Richard, "Regime Change and Its Limits" 84 (84): 66-78, 2005
• 34 Lobe, Jim, "Realist Rack Up Another Win" 2008
• 35 Ellisworth, Robert, "Realism’s Shining Morality" The National Interest 517-10, 2004a
• 36 Preston, Thomas, "Presidential Leadership Style and the Foreign Policy Advisory Process,” in Eugene Wittkopf & James McCormick, The Domestic Sources of American Foreign Policy: Insights and Evidence" Rowman & Littlefield Publishers 363-80, 2004
• 37 Arbatov Alexei, "Praeger Security International" Praeger Security International 63-76, 2008
• 38 Elias, Diana, "Powell: Iran Far From Nuclear Weapon" 2007
• 39 Porter, Gareth, "Pentagon Targeted Iran for Regime Change after 9/11" 2008
• 40 Skidmore, David, "Paradoxes of Power: U. S. Foreign Policy in a Changing World" Paradigm Publishers 2007
• 41 U. S. Department of Defense, "Nuclear Posture Review"
• 42 Arkin, William, "Not Just A Last Resort? A Global Strike Plan, With a Nuclear Option" 2005
• 43 Khong, Yuen Foong, "Neoconservativism and the Domestic Source of American Foreign Policy: the Role of Ideas in Operation and Iraqi Freedom" Oxford UP 251-67, 2008
• 44 Maoz, Zeev, "National Choices and International Choices" Cambridge UP 1990
• 45 Rothkopf, David, "Look Who’s Running the World Now" 2006
• 46 Callahan, Patrick, "Logics of American Foreign Policy: Theories of America's World Role" Pearson/Longman 2004
• 47 Ikenberry, John, "Liberal Realism: The Foundations of a Democratic Foreign Policy" 77 : 38-49, 2004
• 48 Gwertzman, Bernard, "Leverett: Bush Administration ‘Not Serous’ About Dealing With Iran, In: Interview with Flynt Leverett, Council on Foreign Relations"
• 49 Ozcan, Nihat, "Iran’s Nuclear Program and the Future of U.S.-Iranian Relations" 16 (16): 121-133, 2009
• 50 Joseph, Robert, "Iran’s Nuclear Program In:Under Secretary for Arms Control and International Security, U.S. Department of State" 2006
• 51 Katzman, Kenneth, "Iran: U.S. Concerns and Policy Responses" 2009
• 52 Brezezinski, Zbigniew, "Iran: Time for a New Approach, Report of an Independent Task Force by the Council on Foreign Relations"
• 53 International Crisis Group, "Iran: Is There a Way out of the Nuclear Impasse?" 2006
• 54 Wright, Robin, "In the Debate Over Iran, More Calls for a Tougher U.S. Stance" 2007
• 55 Kessler, Glenn, "In 2003, U.S. Spurned Iran’s Offer of Dialogue: Some Officials Lament Lost Opportunity" 2006
• 56 Kessler, Glenn, "Impact From the Shadows: Cheney Wields Power With Few Fingerprints" 2004
• 57 Leverett, Flynt, "Illusion and Reality" 2006
• 58 DeYoung, Karen, "Gates: U.S. Should Engage Iran With Incentives and Pressure" 2008
• 59 Kessler, Glenn, "Foreign Policy: After Iraq, U.S. Debates The Next Steps" 2003
• 60 U. S. Department of State, "Foreign Policy Bulletin" Cambridge UP 2005
• 61 Porter, Gareth, "For Neocons, Iran War Aim is Still Regime Change" 2007
• 62 Allison, Graham, "Essence of Decision: Explaining the Cuban Missile Crisis, 2nd" Longman 1999
• 63 Fitzpatrick Mark, "Double Trouble: Iran and North Korea as Challenges to International Security" Praeger Security International, 23-46, 2008
• 64 Cronin, Patrick M., "Double Trouble: Iran and North Korea as Challenges to International Security" Praeger Security International 2008
• 65 Brezezinski, Zbigniew, "Differntiated Containment: U.S. Policy Toward Iran and Iraq" Council on Foreign Relations Press 1997
• 66 Krauthammer,Charles, "Charles, Democratic Realism: An American Foreign Policy for a Unipolar World" The AEI Press 2004
• 67 Lobe, Jim, "Challenges 2007-2008: Gates Led Realist Resurgence in ’07," 2007
• 68 Porter, Gareth, "Cabal’ Blocked 2003 Nuclear Talks with Iran" 2006
• 69 Porter, Gareth, "Burnt Offering" 2006
• 70 Nuruzzaman, Mohammed, "Beyond the Realist Theories: ‘Neo-Conservative Realism’ and the American Invasion of Iraq" 7 : 239-253, 2006
• 71 Hulsman, John, "Beyond the Neocons: Ethical Realism and America’s Future"
• 72 Solomon, Jay, "As ‘Neocons’ Leave, Bush Foreign Policy Softer Line" 2006
• 73 Mitchell, David, "Anatomy of Failure: Bush’s Decision-Making Process and the Iraq War" 5 : 265-286, 2009
• 74 Ignatius,David, "An F for Bush's Iran Policy" 2008
• 75 Kurlantzick, Josh, "After the Bush Doctrine" 2006
• 76 Cooper, Helene, "A rift emerges over U.S.policy toward Iran" 2007
• 77 Cooper, Helene, "A Talk at Lunch that Shifted the Stance on Iran" 2006
• 78 Hulsman, John, "A Paradigm for the New World Order: A Schools-of-Thought Analysis of American Foreign Policy in the Post-Cold War Era" St. Martin’s Press 1997