다큐멘터리와 극영화의 제작방식 만족도 차이 분석: <탐욕의 제국>과 <또 하나의 약속> 중심으로 = Analysis of Differences in Satisfaction with the Production Methods of Documentaries and Feature Films: Focusing on < Empire of Greed > and < Another Promise >

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Purpose: The films < Empire of Greed > (2013) and < Another Promise > (2013) are films based on the same content in the scenario, one as a documentary and the other as a feature film. This study aims to analyze the difference in satisfaction that the audience receives when the different formats of a documentary and a feature film convey the same event. Methods: The information and narrative structure comparison of the two films, which serve as theoretical backgrounds, were conducted through an analysis of existing prior research, and the satisfaction difference analysis was conducted through a survey of 250 college students living in Seoul who watched < Empire of Greed > and < Another Promise > for a week from November 15 to November 21, 2023. Result: First, in terms of narrative structure, < Empire of Greed > does not have a narration that clearly organizes the events taking place or conveys their essence, making it difficult to grasp the essence of the events. Second, < Another Promise > makes the most of the storytelling of a feature film to clearly convey the message, making the events feel real and giving the audience trust while persuasively criticizing Samsung’s absurdity. Conclusion: First, we found that documentary films and feature films have differences in their expression methods, rather than in the formal differences of their genres. This means that there was no difference in the formal differences between documentary films and feature films, and there was also no significant difference in the emotional satisfaction of the viewers. Second, there was a statistically significant difference in cognitive satisfaction and viewer attitude, which depended on whether the message of the subject was clearly expressed or not. In cognitive satisfaction, the audience of < Empire of Greed > was higher than the audience of < Another Family >, and in viewer attitude, the audience of < Another Family > was higher than the audience of < Empire of Greed >.