‘수업을 보는 눈’으로서 교사의 전문적 시각에 대한 기존 연구의 특징과 쟁점 분석 = Analyzing Studies on Teacher Professional Vision: A Literature Review

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

The purpose of this study is to synthesize the theoretical perspectives, research methods, and research results of teachers’ professional vision by reviewing and analyzing previous research papers and to suggest implications for science teacher education and research. Three databases were used to search peer reviewed journal articles published between 1997-2017, which include ‘teachers’ and ‘professional vision’ explicitly in abstracts and empirical studies only. 21 articles in total were analyzed and review results are as follows.
First, researchers regarded professional vision as a new concept of teacher professionalism. Previous research viewed professional vision as integrated structure of teachers’ knowledge or ability activated at specific moment. Second, the analytical framework of professional vision included two aspects; ‘selective attention’ and ‘reasoning’. Several aspects of lessons or the desirable teaching and learning factors are suggested as the subcategories of selective attention. Hierarchical levels or independent reasoning ability factors are suggested as the subcategories of reasoning process. Third, research on teachers’ professional vision focused more on middle school teachers than elementary teachers and on various subject areas. Most studies used video clips and more cases of using videos of non-participants were found. In case of measurement of professional vision, most quantitative scoring methods were whether the responses of experts and teachers on video clips were consistent. Last, most studies examined or assessed teachers’ professional vision. It is reported that in-service teachers’ professional vision was evaluated higher than novice teachers’ and using video clips were effective to examine and improve teachers’ professional vision.

국문 초록 (Abstract)

본 연구의 목적은 교사의 전문적 시각에 대한 기존 연구 분석을 통해 다양한 연구자들의 이론적 관점, 연구 방법, 연구 결과를 비교, 종합하고 이로부터 과학교사의 전문적 시각과 관련된 후속 연구에 대해 시사점을 얻고자 하는 것이다. 1997년부터 2017년에 발표된 논문 중 초록에 ‘professional vision’과 ‘teacher’를 포함한 논문을 ERIC, Educational Source, Web of Science 데이터 베이스를 활용하여 검색 하였다. 최종 분석 대상은 21개 논문이며 연구 결과를 요약하면 다음과 같다. 첫째, 연구자들은 전문적 시각을 교사의 지식과 구분되는 새로운 교사 전문성 구인이라고 보고 있었다. 교사의 전문적 시각을 특정한 순간이나 특정한 상황에서 활성화 되는 지식 또는 능력으로 보고 있으며, 여러 지식이 구조화되고 통합되어 나타나는 것이라고 보고 있다. 둘째, 전문적 시각의 분석틀은 대개 선택적 주목과 추론의두 과정을 포함하고 있었다. 선택적 주목의 경우에는 수업의 여러 측면이나 바람직한 교수 학습 요소들을 하위 범주로 하고 있었으며, 추론의 경우에는 위계가 있는 수준이나 독립적 추론 능력 요소들을 하위 범주로 하는 연구들이 있었다. 셋째, 연구 방법 측면에서는 초등 교사보다는 중등교사를 대상으로 하는 연구가 더 많았고, 수학과 과학을 비롯하여 다양한 교과 영역으로 확장되고 있었다. 대부분의 연구가 수업 비디오를 활용하고 있으며, 연구 참여자의 수업을 활용한 연구보다 연구 비참여자의 수업 비디오를 활용하고 있는 경우가 많았 다. 전문적 시각의 측정 혹은 분석은 전문가와의 응답 일치 여부로 정량적으로 점수화하는 경우와 토론과 면담의 정성적 자료를 활용하여 특징이나 수준을 범주화하는 경우로 대별되었다. 넷째, 연구의 목적과 결과를 살펴본 결과, 대부분은 전문적 시각에 대한 실태조사 연구였으며, 전문적 시각을 조사하는 도구를 개발하거나 전문적 시각 향상 방안을 제안하고 그 효과성을 보는 연구도 있었다. 여러 연구에서 예비 교사 보다는 현직 교사의 전문적 시각이 높다고 보고하고 있으며, 전문적 시각을 증진시키기 위해서는 수업 비디오를 활용한 교사교육 프로그램이 효과적이라고 보고하고 있다.

참고문헌 (Reference)

• 1 방정숙, "수학 교육에서 노티싱(Noticing) 연구의 동향과 과제" 대한수학교육학회 19 (19): 795-817, 2017
• 2 윤혜경, "생산적 반성의 관점에서 분석한 초등 예비교사의 과학 수업 반성의 특징" 한국과학교육학회 32 (32): 703-716, 2012
• 3 조대훈, "사회과 PCK 연구 동향 및 연구 담론 분석" 한국사회과교육학회 47 (47): 115-143, 2015
• 4 윤혜경, "과학 수업 비디오에 기초한 반성 활동을 통한 초등 예비교사의 전문적 시각의 변화" 한국과학교육학회 37 (37): 553-564, 2017
• 5 Stürmer, K., "What is in the eye of preservice teachers while instructing? An eye-tracking study about attention processes in different teaching situations" 20 : 75-92, 2017
• 6 Sherin, M. G., "Video research in the learning sciences" Lawrence Erlbaum 383-395, 2007
• 7 Bernadette Gold, "Using digital video to measure the professional vision of elementary classroom management: Test validation and methodological challenges" Elsevier BV 107 : 13-30, 2017
• 8 Lee, J., "Toward a Holistic View : Analysis of pre-service teachers'professional vision in field experiences and its implications" 18 (18): 4-19, 2016
• 9 McDonald, S. P., "The transparent and the invisible in professional pedagogical vision for science teaching" 116 (116): 95-103, 2016
• 10 Reuker, S., "The knowledge-based reasoning of physical education teachers : A comparison between groups with different expertise" 23 (23): 3-24, 2017
• 11 Meschede, N., "Teachers'professional vision, pedagogical content knowledge and beliefs : On its relation and differences between pre-service and in-service teachers" 66 : 158-170, 2017
• 12 Seidel, T., "Teacher learning from analysis of videotaped classroom situations:Does it make a difference whether teachers observe their own teaching or that of others?" 27 (27): 259-267, 2011
• 13 Park, S., "Revisiting the conceptualisation of pedagogical content knowledge(PCK) : PCK as a conceptual tool to understand teachers as professionals" 38 (38): 261-284, 2008
• 14 Steffensky, M., "Professional vision of classroom management and learning support in science classrooms—Does professional vision differ across general and content-specific classroom interactions?" 13 (13): 351-368, 2015
• 15 Sherin, M. G., "Professional vision in action : An exploratory study" 17 (17): 27-46, 2008
• 16 Charles Goodwin, "Professional Vision" Wiley 96 (96): 606-633, 1994
• 17 Yoon, H. -G., "Pre-service teachers’ views of inquiry teaching and their responses to teacher educators’ feedback on teaching practice" 9 (9): 347-359, 2013
• 18 Levin, D. M., "Novice teachers' attention to student thinking" 60 (60): 142-154, 2009
• 19 Mendez, E. P., "Multiple perspectives on the development of an eighth-grade mathematical discourse community" 108 (108): 41-61, 2007
• 20 Tina Seidel, "Modeling and Measuring the Structure of Professional Vision in Preservice Teachers" American Educational Research Association (AERA) 51 (51): 739-771, 2014
• 21 van Es, E. A., "Mathematics teacher noticing" Routledge 164-181, 2011
• 22 van Es, E., "Learning to notice : Scaffolding new teachers’ interpretations of classroom interactions" 10 (10): 571-596, 2002
• 23 Jeffrey Choppin, "Learned adaptations: Teachers’ understanding and use of curriculum resources" Springer Nature 14 (14): 331-353, 2011
• 24 Shulman, L., "Knowledge and teaching : Foundations of the new reform" 57 (57): 1-23, 1987
• 25 Stürmer, K., "Intra-individual differences in developing professional vision : Preservice teachers’ changes in the course of an innovative teacher education program" 44 (44): 293-309, 2016
• 26 Blomberg, G., "How pre-service teachers observe teaching on video : Effects of viewers' teaching subjects and the subject of the video" 7 (7): 1131-1140, 2011
• 27 Windschitl, M., "Fostering ambitious pedagogy in novice teachers : The new role of tool-supported analyses of student work" 113 (113): 1311-1360, 2011
• 28 Stürmer, K., "Factors within university-based teacher education relating to preservice teachers’professional vision" 8 : 35-54, 2015
• 29 Lee, E., "Experienced secondary science teachers’representation of pedagogical content knowledge" 30 (30): 1343-1363, 2008
• 30 Sherin, M. G., "Effects of video club participation on teachers’ professional vision" 60 (60): 20-37, 2009
• 31 LaBoskey, V. K., "Development of reflective practice : A study of pre service teachers" Teachers College Press 1994
• 32 Michalsky, T., "Developing the SRL-PV assessment scheme : Preservice teachers’ professional vision for teaching self-regulated learning" 43 : 214-229, 2014
• 33 Ho, K. F., "Developing a professional vision of classroom practices of a mathematics teacher : Views from a researcher and a teacher" 24 (24): 415-426, 2013
• 34 Sturmer, K., "Declarative knowledge and professional vision in teacher education : Effect of courses in teaching and learning" 83 (83): 467-483, 2013
• 35 Sturmer, K., "Changes in professional vision in the context of practice" 44 : 339-355, 2013
• 36 Blömeke, S., "Beyond dichotomies. Competence viewed as a continuum" 223 (223): 3-13, 2015
• 37 Sherin, M. G., "Beyond classical pedagogy: Teaching elementary school mathematics" Erlbaum 75-93, 2001
• 38 Stürmer, K., "Assessing professional vision in teacher candidates : Approaches to validating the observer extended research tool" 223 (223): 54-63, 2015