열반의 바다에 들어가기: 󰡔람림첸모󰡕에서 쫑카빠의 하샹 비판 = Entering the Ocean of Nirvāṇa: Tsong kha pa’s Criticism of the Chinese Monk Hwa shang in the Lam Rim Chen Mo

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

This article analyzes Tsong kha pa’s criticism of a Chan master, called “the Chinese mkhan po Hwa shang” (rGya nag gi mkhan po Hwa shang, fl. second half of the 8th c.), which was described in the Lam Rim Chen Mo (hereafter LRChM) written at Rwa sgreng in 1402. Herein, I point out that the meaning of mu stegs pa in the LRChM is not merely ‘non-Buddhist adherents.’ Rather, it describes ‘a person who has no right view of selflessness.’ The word ‘someone’ in the third Bhāvanākrama by Kamalaśīla (ca. 740-795) corresponds to “Hwa shang, the one who erroneously conceptualizes” (phyin ci log tu rtog pa) in the LRChM. Drawing upon the LRChM’s presentation of the issue, this present study synthesizes Tsong kha pa’s three principal critiques of Hwa shang as mu stegs pa: his rejection of (1) virtuous conduct; (2) attention (yid la byed pa, manaskāra); and (3) the meditation of analytical investigation (so sor rtog pa, pratyavekṣaṇa). As a counterargument against Hwa shang and other figures who articulated opposing viewpoints, Tsong kha pa defines the concepts of emptiness, conceptuality, virtuous conduct, and discriminating insight (so sor rtog pa'i shes rab, pratisamkhyāprajñā) cited from (1) the early Yogācāra literature; (2) the Ratnagotravibhāga, the treatises on the Tathāgatagarbha theory; and (3) the Bhāvanākrama, the literature that presents the stages of meditation and various Mahāyāna sūtras. Therefore, this article contributes to an in-depth understanding of the practice system of LRChM, which involves progressive training according to an individual’s abilities. In addition, this study suggests that the claims symbolized by “the tradition of Hwa shang” (hwa shang gi lugs) played an essential role as a tool to correct wrong views as a ‘platform for entering the ocean of nirvāṇa’ at that time.

국문 초록 (Abstract)

티벳의 8세기 후반 쌈얘 논쟁(bSam yas rtsod pa) 이후 겔룩(dGe lugs)의 개조인 쫑카빠 롭상닥빠(Tsong kha pa Blo bzang grags pa, 1357-1419)는 1402년 라뎅(Rwa sgreng)에서 저술한 󰡔람림첸모󰡕(Lam rim chen mo, 󰡔보리도차제광론󰡕(菩提道次第廣論))에서 하샹(Hwa shang, 和尙 摩訶衍, 8세기 후반 활동)을 “phyin ci log tu rtog pa”(전도되게 분별하는 자)로서 지목하며 강력히 비판한다.
쫑카빠는 하샹을 비롯한 외도(mu stegs pa)의 견해에 대응해 공성, 분별, 지혜와 방편 개념을 󰡔십지경󰡕(十地經, Daśabhūmikasūtra, Sa bcu pa'i mdo), 󰡔해심밀경󰡕(解深密經, Saṃdhinirmocanasūtra, mDo sde dgongs 'grel), 󰡔보살지󰡕(菩薩地, Bodhisattvabhūmi, Byang chub sems dpa'i sa)등 인도 유식학파의 초기 문헌과 󰡔수습차제󰡕(修習次第, Bhāvanākrama, sGom pa'i rim pa)와 같은 수행 지침서, 󰡔보성론󰡕(寶性論, Ratnagotravibhāga, dKon mchog gi rigs rnam par dbye ba)등 여래장 계열의 논서와 대승 경전의 핵심 관련 구절에 따라 정의한다.
이 논문은 하샹의 교설로 상징된 당시 외도의 주장을 분석해 󰡔람림첸모󰡕의 근기에 따른 단계별 수습체계를 보다 면밀하게 이해하고, 하샹 전통으로 상징되는 주장이 잘못된 견해를 바로잡기 위한 도구로써 활용된다는 관점을 논증한다.

참고문헌 (Reference)

• 1 AHN, Sungdoo (안성두), "｢삼예사의 논쟁: 돈점론의 티베트 불교적 전개｣ [*“The Debate of bSam yas: Development of the Sudden-Gradual Theory in Tibetan Buddhism”]" 14 : 399-417, 2003
• 2 차상엽, "펠리오 티벳어 사본 116번의 사본학적 특징과 중국 선사상" 한국불교연구원 (55) : 35-62, 2021
• 3 TENZIN, Namkha, "티벳어 한글 표기안 [Korean Orthography of Tibetan]" 티벳장경연구소 (The Research Center for Tibetan Buddhist Canon) 2010
• 4 CHA, Sangyeob (차상엽), "쫑카빠(Tsong kha pa)의 삼매에 대한 소고 [A Study on the Concept of Meditative Concentration in Tsong Kha Pa: Focused on the Lam rim chen mo]" 3 : 211-232, 2011
• 5 차상엽, "싸꺄빤디따(Sa skya paṇḍita)의 마하무드라(Mahāmudrā) 비판 -『붓다의 의도를 명료하게 밝힘(Thub pa'i dgongs pa rab tu gsal ba)』 「반야바라밀」장을 중심으로-" 보조사상연구원 (37) : 395-429, 2012
• 6 DEMIÉVILLE, Paul (폴 드미에빌), "세기 말 티벳불교의 돈점논쟁" 씨아이알(CIR) 1952-, 2017
• 7 CHA, Sangyeob (차상엽), "돈황 출토 티벳어 사본에 나타난 마하연의 선사상 재조명 [Revisiting the Chan Thought of Moheyan(摩訶衍) as Represented in the Tibetan Manuscripts Unearthed from Dunhuang]" 7 : 357-393, 2021
• 8 CHA, Sangyeob (차상엽), "돈황 사본과 불교학 [Dunhuang Manuscripts and Buddhist Studies]" 여래 (Yoerai) 2019
• 9 조석효, "공성과 아이온의 시간: 티벳 불교 수행 해석의 한 가능성" 불교학연구회 69 : 81-111, 2021
• 10 "頓悟大乘政理決 B0195"
• 11 ZONGFENG (宗峰), "菩提道次第廣論四家合注 [The Annotations of Lam rim chen mo by Four Prominent Scholars], 2 vols" 中国社会科学出版社 (Zhōngguó Shèhuì Kēxué Chūbǎnshè) 2014
• 12 "菩提道次第廣論 B0067"
• 13 MATSUMOTO, Shirō(松本史朗), "禪思想の批判的硏究 [Studies in the Critique of Chan Thought]" 大蔵出版 (Daizō Shuppan) 1994
• 14 SATORU, Harada(原田覺), "敦煌蔵文資料に於ける宗義系の論書 (1)[The Philosophy of Mahayana Buddhism Based on the Tibetan Manuscripts from Tun-Huang]" 26 (26): 463-467, 1977
• 15 TAKAKUSU, "大正新脩大藏經 [Revised Buddhist Canon compiled during the Taishō reign period]" 大正一切経刊行会 (Taishō Issaikyō Kankō kai) 1935
• 16 우제선, "修習과 證知 - 까말라쉴라의 觀點" 보조사상연구원 (20) : 89-107, 2003
• 17 "sic erat scriptum"
• 18 "reigned"
• 19 Tsultrim Kelsang Khangkar, "rJe tsong kha pa'i lam rim chen mo'i lung khungs gsal byed nyi ma: 尊者ツォンカパの 『菩提道次第大論』" 西藏佛敎文化協會 (Tibetan Buddhist Culture Association) 2004
• 20 "mNyam med tsong kha pa chen pos byang chub lam rim che ba. sKu 'bum xylograph, 19 vols., vol. 13, ca. 21th"
• 21 "mNyam med tsong kha pa chen pos byang chub lam rim che ba. bKra shis lhun poxylograph, 27 vols" Ngawang Gelek Demo 19-20, 1975
• 22 lHasa Zhol xylograph, "mNyam med tsong kha pa chen pos byang chub lam rim che ba. Collected Works" Library of Tibetan Works and Archives 33-1077, 1981
• 23 "mNyam med tsong kha pa chen pos byang chub lam rim che ba. Bla brang bkra shis 'khyilxylograph, 18 vols., vol. 13, ca. 20th"
• 24 "mNyam mad [read: med] tsong kha pa chen pos byang chub lam rim che ba. sDe dge xylograph, 19 vols., vol. 13, ca. 19-20th"
• 25 "honorific"
• 26 "floruit"
• 27 WANGDU, P., "dBa' bzhed: The Royal Narrative concerning the bringing of the Buddha’s Doctrine to Tibet" Verlag der Österreichischen Akademie der Wissenschaften 2000
• 28 PELLIOT, Paul, "collection, Chinese Fragments in Bibliothèque nationale de France"
• 29 "circa"
• 30 "brDa bkrol nyer mkho bsdus pa"
• 31 "brDa bkrol"
• 32 SUZUKI, Daisetsu Teitarō, "Tsong kha pa Blo bzang grags pa, sKyes bu gsum gyis nyams su blang ba'i rim pa thams cad tshang bar ston pa'i byang chub lam gyi rim pa" Tibetan Tripitaka Research Institute 1961
• 33 JONES, C. V, "Translating Buddhism: Historical and Contextual Perspectives" SUNY Press 195-227, 2021
• 34 BIALEK, Joanna, "Towards a standardisation of Tibetan transliteration for textual studies" (56) : 70-88, 2020
• 35 VAN SCHAIK, Sam, "Tibetan Zen: Discovering a Lost Tradition" Snow Lion 2015
• 36 BRETFELD, Sven, "The ‘Great Debate’ of bSam yas: Construction and Deconstruction of a Tibetan Buddhist Myth" LVIII (LVIII): 15-56, 2004
• 37 ZHANG, Linghui, "The Wholesome Streams (dGe ba'i chu rgyun): Tshe dbang nor bu’s Treatment of the Chinese Monk’s Simultaneist Approach to Awakening" (37) : 592-610, 2016
• 38 BARBER, Anthony W, "The Tibetan Tripitaka, Taipei Edition (= sDe dge)" SMC Publishing Inc 1991
• 39 VAN SCHAIK, Sam, "The Tibetan Chan Manuscripts: A Complete Descriptive Catalogue of Tibetan Chan Texts in the Dunhuang Manuscript Collections" Sinor Research Institute for Inner Asian Studies Indiana University 2014
• 40 大藏經補, "The Supplement to the Buddhist canon" 華宇出版社 (Huayu Chubanshe) 1985
• 41 MONLAM, Losang, "The Lam-rim Monastery: A Vision for IMI and FPMT" Mandala Magazine 2009
• 42 VAN DER KUIJP, "The Illuminating Mirror: Tibetan Studies in Honour of Per K. Sørensen on the Occasion of his 65th Birthday" Dr. Ludwig Reichert Verlag 253-268, 2015
• 43 OBERMILLER, E., "The History of Buddhism in India and Tibet" Harrassowitz 1931
• 44 VAN SCHAIK, Sam, "The Great Perfection and the Chinese Monk: rNying-ma-pa defences of Hwa-shang Mahāyāna in the Eighteenth Century" 20 (20): 189-204, 2003
• 45 FABER, Flemming, "The Council of Tibet according to the sBa bzhed" XLVII : 33-61, 1986
• 46 HABATA, Hiromi(幅田裕美), "The City of Nirvāṇa: Conceptions of Nirvāṇa with Special Reference to the Central Asian Tradition" 46 (46): 61-83, 2015
• 47 "ThGS [sDe dge] Sa skya paṇḍita Kun dga' rgyal mtshan, Thub pa'i dgongs pa rab tu gsal ba. Sa skya pa'i bka' 'bum, sDe dge xylograph, 15 vols., vol. 5"
• 48 KIM, Sung Chul(김성철), "Systematic Buddhology와 『보리도차제론』[Systematic Buddhology and Lam rim]" 3 : 155-179, 2001
• 49 STEIN, R. A, "Sudden and Gradual: Approaches to Enlightenment in Chinese Thought" University of Hawaii Press 41-65, 1987
• 50 DEMIÉVILLE, Paul, "Sudden and Gradual: Approaches to Enlightenment in Chinese Thought" University of Hawaii Press 13-40, 1987
• 51 GÓMEZ, Luis O, "Studies in Ch’an and Hua-yen" 67-167, 1983
• 52 SHEN, Weirong, "Sino-Tibetan Buddhism across the Ages" Brill 21-66, 2021
• 53 JACKSON, Roger, "Sa skya paṇḍita’s Account of the bSam yas Debate: History as Polemic" 5 (5): 89-99, 1982
• 54 DARIBAZARON, Darima E, "Ploughing Ashes vs. Ploughing a Field”: Studies of Lamrim Texts at Buddhist Monasteries" 9 (9): 146-153, 2016
• 55 "Pelliot tibétain"
• 56 "Pelliot chinois"
• 57 VAN SCHAIK, Sam, "One-Volume Libraries: Composite and Multiple-Text Manuscripts" De Gruyter 287-304, 2016
• 58 RUEGG, David Seyfort, "On the Tibetan Historiography and Doxography of the ‘Great Debate of bSam yas’" Naritasan Shinshoji 237-244, 1989
• 59 VAN DER KUIJP, "On the Fifteenth Century Lho rong chos 'byung by Rta tshag Tshe dbang rgyal and its Importance for Tibetan Political and Religious History" 14 : 57-76, 2001
• 60 VAN DER KUIJP, "Miscellanea to a Recent Contribution on/to the Bsam-Yas Debate" XI (XI): 149-184, 1984
• 61 TUCCI, Giuseppe, "Minor Buddhist Texts, Part II: First Bhāvanākrama of Kamalaśīla, Sanskrit and Tibetan Texts with Introduction and English Summary" Istituto Italiano per il Medio ed Estremo Oriente 1958
• 62 BRAARVIG, Jens, "Manuscripts in the Schøyen Collection: Buddhist Manuscripts, vol. III" Hermes Publishing 2006
• 63 "Lam rim mchan bzhi"
• 64 "LRChM"
• 65 "Kyt"
• 66 LALOU, Marcelle, "Inventaire Des Manuscrits tibétains de Touen-houang conservés à la Bibliothèque Nationale (Fonds Pelliot tibétain, nos. 1-849, Vol. I)" Adrien-Maisonneuve 1939
• 67 YOKOYAMA, Koitsu(横山 紘一), "Index to the Yogācārabhūmi (Chinese-Sanskrit-Tibetan)" Sankibo Busshorin Publishing 1996
• 68 RICHARDSON, Hugh E, "High Peaks, Pure Earth: Collected Writings on Tibetan History and Culture" Serindia Publications 203-206, 1998
• 69 VAN DER KUIJP, "Edition, éditions: l’écrit au Tibet, évolution et devenir" Indus 441-463, 2010
• 70 SUZUKI, "Daisetsu Teitarō, 168 vols" Tibetan Tripitaka Research Institute 1961
• 71 Shar gdong Blo bzang bshad grubrgya mtsho, "Byang chub lam rim che ba. Bya khyung xylograph" mTsho sngon mi rigs dpe skrun khang 1985
• 72 A kyA Yongs 'dzin blo bzang don grub, "Byang chub lam gyi rim pa chen po las byung ba'i brda bkrol nyer mkho bsdus pa. Collected Works, sKu 'bum xylograph, 2 vols., vol. 1"
• 73 RUEGG, David Seyfort, "Buddha-nature, Mind and the Problem of Gradualism in a Comparative Perspective: On the Transmission and Reception of Buddhism in India and Tibet" School of Oriental and African Studies 1989
• 74 "Bla brang bkra shis 'khyil xylograph, 2 vols. (Nga, Ca)" Bla brang bkra shis 'khyil par khang 1807
• 75 "Bhāvanākrama [Q: Peking/Beijing; D: sDe dge]"
• 76 ARY, Elijah S., "Authorized Lives: Biography and the Early Formation of Geluk Identity" Wisdom Publications 2015
• 77 OBERMILLER, E, "A Sanskrit Ms. from Tibet—Kamalaśīla’s Bhāvanā-krama" II : 1-11, 1935
• 78 ISHIKAWA, Mie(石川美惠), "A Critical Edition of the sGra sbyor bam po gnyis pa: An Old and Basic Commentary on the Mahāvyutpatti 二巻本訳語釈 vol. 2" 東洋文庫 1990
• 79 차상엽, "8세기 말 인도 불교도와 禪師 마하연의 논쟁과 관련한 쟁점 사항 - 돈황 출토 한문 사본 『돈오대승정리결』과 티벳어 사본 PT21을 중심으로 -" 대한철학회 163 : 227-250, 2022
• 80 조석효, "14세기 티벳불교의 논쟁적 이슈들: 냐온 뀐가뻴(Nya dbon Kun dga' dpal) (1285~1379)의 비판적 논의를 중심으로" 불교학연구회 66 : 267-294, 2021