인격권 관점에서 본 퍼블리시티권 = A Study on the right of publicity from the perspective of personality rights

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Personality rights pursue free development of personality based on the value of human dignity. The commercial interests of a person's identity is directly associated with the development of personality and it can raise problems in regard to human dignity. Therefore, the commercial interests of a person's identity should be protected under personality rights.
Otherwise, the right of publicity becomes a separate and independent property right, which is not only unnecessary but also undesirable in legal composition.
Transferring the right of publicity to protect the person who commercially uses another's identity is an excessive legal method considering its purpose. This can bring about undue result that a person loses the right over the commercial use of his or her own identity. Also,the part of personality rights which protects the commercial interests of a person's identity cannot be transferred as a whole. However, a person can permit the commercial use of his or her own identity and a licensee is entitled to damages when his or her exclusive right is intentionally infringed upon by others and also able to claim the injunction.
Furthermore, it is possible to grant a license like a real right as a partial transfer of personality rights and there should be relevant legislation established to regulate the license.
The personality rights of decedents should be recognized in terms of protecting human dignity. Personality rights of decedents no longer have aspect of free development of personality, so that it is considered more like property right and effective defense is necessary against appropriation of the decedent's identity. Therefore, the part of personality rights which protects commercial interests of a person's identity can be inherited. The part of personality rights protecting the commercial interests of a person's identity should be recognized during the subject's life and for additional 70years posthumously on the analogy of regulations of copyright law.
Commercial interests of a person's identity in Korea should be protected under the personality rights. The right of publicity should be understood within the concept of the personality rights and relevant regulations should be enacted in civil law.

참고문헌 (Reference)

• 1 金泳勳, "하급심 판결례의 퍼블리시티권(Right of Publiciy) 인정에 대한 비판적고찰" 44 : 2007
• 2 남형두, "퍼블리시티권의 철학적 기반 (上)" 한국법학원 (97) : 135-166, 2007
• 3 최형구, "퍼블리시티권의 양도성에 대한 재검토" 한국산업재산권법학회 (31) : 267-301, 2010
• 4 이재경, "퍼블리시티권의 법제화 가능성" 숭실대학교 법학연구소 15 : 2006
• 5 구재군, "퍼블리시티권에 관한 연구 - 국회에서의 입법논의와 관련하여 -" 법학연구소 (30) : 209-234, 2008
• 6 李相珵, "퍼블리시티권에 관한 소고" (4) : 2001
• 7 李漢周, "퍼블리시티권에 관하여" 39 : 2004
• 8 서태환, "퍼블리시티권(Right of Publicity)의 意義와 그 讓渡性 및 相續性" 1 : 1999
• 9 이호선, "퍼블리시티권 (신원 공표권)의 성격에 관한 연구 －지적재산권적 관점, 과연 타당한가?－" 법학연구원 19 (19): 27-63, 2009
• 10 韓渭洙, "퍼블리시티權의 侵害와 民事責任(下)" (243) : 1996
• 11 韓渭洙, "퍼블리시티權의 侵害와 民事責任(上)" (242) : 1996
• 12 엄동섭, "퍼블리시티(Publicity)權" 서강대학교 법학연구소 6 : 2004
• 13 金載亨, "제3자에 의한 債權侵害" 박영사 3 : 2007
• 14 오승종, "저작권법" 博英社 2007
• 15 남형두, "재산분할청구권의 대상으로서 지적재산권 ― 퍼블리시티권을 중심으로" 한국가족법학회 22 (22): 337-372, 2008
• 16 안병하, "인격권의 재산권적 성격 － 퍼블리시티권 비판 서론 －" 한국민사법학회 45 (45): 71-122, 2009
• 17 박영규, "인격권, 퍼블리시티권 그리고 지적재산권" 한국법학원 112 : 265-293, 2009
• 18 박성호, "유명인의 목소리에 대한 퍼블리시티권의 보호" (18) : 2007
• 19 장재옥, "연예인의 성명․초상의 경제적 가치 보호와 손해배상법의 역할" 중앙대학교 법학연구소 27 (27): 2003
• 20 남형두, "세계시장 관점에서 본 퍼블리시티권 - 한류의 재산권보장으로서의 퍼블리시티권 -" 한국법학원 (86) : 101-121, 2005
• 21 김상중, "불법행위의 사전적 구제수단으로서 금지청구권의 소고 - 대법원 2010.8.25.자 2008마1541 결정에 관한 평석 -" 한국비교사법학회 17 (17): 141-172, 2010
• 22 김상용, "민법총칙" 화산미디어 2009
• 23 안병하, "무형의 인격표지의 상업적 이용에 내재된 위험성" 법학연구원 19 (19): 247-281, 2009
• 24 박용상, "명예훼손법" 현암사 2008
• 25 李 漢 周, "경주마(競走馬)의 퍼블리시티권" 한국법학원 (85) : 156-188, 2005
• 26 許營, "韓國憲法論" 博英社 2010
• 27 金載亨, "言論의 事實報道로 인한 人格權 侵害" 39 (39): 1998
• 28 정경석, "肖像權의 침해요건과 구제방법" 한국법학원 (98) : 122-146, 2007
• 29 丁相朝, "知的財産權法" 弘文社 2004
• 30 金曾漢, "民法總則" 博英社 2006
• 31 郭潤直, "民法總則" 博英社 2009
• 32 李英俊, "民法總則" 博英社 2007
• 33 郭潤直, "民法注解(ⅩⅧ), (ⅩⅨ)" 博英社 2005
• 34 尹眞秀, "損害賠償의 方法으로서의 原狀回復 ― 民法改正案을 계기로 하여 ―" 한국비교사법학회 10 (10): 77-119, 2003
• 35 梁建, "憲法講義" 法文社 2011
• 36 金哲洙, "憲法學新論" 博英社 2010
• 37 權寧星, "憲法學原論" 法文社 2011
• 38 郭潤直, "債權總論" 博英社 2009
• 39 박성호, "人格權의 變容 - 퍼블리시티권에 관한 논의를 중심으로-" 법학연구소 23 (23): 385-406, 2006
• 40 金載亨, "人格權 一般" 박영사 21 : 1999
• 41 Beuthien, Volker, "Was ist Vermögenswert, die Persönlichkeit oder ihr Image?" NJW 1220-, 2003
• 42 Schack, Haimo, "Urheber- und Urhebervertragrecht, 5. Aufl." Mohr Siebeck 2010
• 43 McCarthy, J. Thomas, "The Rights of Publicity and Privacy, 2d ed." Thomson Reuters 2009
• 44 Nimmer, Melville B., "The Right of Publicity" 19 : 203-, 1954
• 45 Beuthien, Volker, "Schützt das allgemeine Persönlichkeitsrecht auch kommerzielle Interessen der Person?, In Persönlichkeitsgüterschutz vor und nach dem Tode" Nomos 75-, 2002
• 46 Sims, Andrew B., "Right of Publicity: Survivability Reconsidered" 49 : 453-, 1981
• 47 Gordon, Harold R., "Right of Property in Name, Likeness, Personality and History" 55 : 553-, 1960
• 48 The American Law Institute, "Restatement of the Law, Unfair Competition, 3d ed." American Law Institute Publishers 1995
• 49 Terrell, Timothy P., "Publicity, Liberty, and Intellectual Property: A Conceptual and Economic Analysis of the Inheritability Issue" 34 : 1-, 1985
• 50 Madow, Michael, "Private Ownership of Public Image: Popular Culture and Publicity Rights" 81 : 125-, 1993
• 51 Felcher, Peter L., "Privacy, Publicity, and the Portrayal of Real People by the Media" 88 : 1577-, 1979
• 52 Ullmann, Eike, "Persönlichkeitsrechte in Lizenz?" AfP 209-, 1999
• 53 Götting, Horst-Peter, "Persönlichkeitsrechte als Vermögensrechte" J. C. B. Mohr 1995
• 54 Magold, Hans Arno, "Personenmerchandising" 1994
• 55 Forkel, Hans, "Lizenzen an Persönlichkeitsrechten durch gebundene Rechtsübertragung" GRUR 491-, 1988
• 56 Hoffman, Steven J., "Limitations on the Right of Publicity" 28 : 111-, 1980
• 57 Kwall, Roberta Rosenthal, "Is Independence Day Dawning for the Right of Publicity?" 17 : 191-, 1983
• 58 Peifer, Karl-Nikolaus, "Indiviualität im Zivilrecht" Mohr Siebeck 2000
• 59 Peifer, Karl-Nikolaus, "Eigenheit oder Eigentum - Was schützt das Persönlichkeitsrecht?" GRUR 495-, 2002
• 60 Götting, Horst-Peter, "Die Vererblichkeit der vermögenswerten Bestandteile des Persönlichkeits rechts - ein Meilenstein in der Rechtsprechung des BGH" NJW 585-, 2001
• 61 Heldrich, von Andreas, "Die Persönlichkeitsschutz Verstorbener, in: Festschrift für Heinrich Lange zum 70" C.H.Beck 1970
• 62 Fischer, Annette, "Die Entwicklung des Postmortalen Persönlichkeitsschutzes" Peter Lang GmbH 2004
• 63 Hubmann, Heinrich, "Das Persönlichkeitsrecht, 2. Aufl." Böhlau Verlag 1967
• 64 Schack, Haimo, "Anmerkung zu BGH, Urteil vom 1. Dezember 1999 - “Marlene Dietrich"" 1060-, 2000
• 65 Wagner, Gerhard, "Anmerkung zu BGH, Urteil vom 1. Dezember 1999 - “Der Blaue Engel"" 717-, 2000