감사시장의 경쟁수준과 재무제표 비교가능성 = Audit Market Competition and Financial Statement Comparability

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

This study investigates whether the audit market competition affects financial statement comparability. The audit market competition is one of the important factors which influence auditors’ behaviors. Prior studies report that the audit market competition, measured by the number of audit firms in the same year and industry, has negative effect on audit quality.
If the level of competition in the audit market is high, the auditor is more likely to acquiesce to the preference of the client firms to secure and maintain the client firms as a client. In this situation, the auditor's bargaining power with the client firms will be weakened, and it leads to the decrease of auditor independence in delivering audit services. Also, according to prior studies, the auditors are able to influence financial statement comparability through the consistent application of the audit procedures. In this perspective, we expect that intensified audit market competition makes it difficult for the auditor to perform rigorous and consistent audits, which result in a decrease of financial statement comparability.
To confirm our prediction, we conduct empirical analyses using 11,759 firm-years observations of Korean listed firms over the period of 2005-2018. We find that financial statement comparability decreases as audit market competition intensifies. It suggests that if competition in the audit market intensifies, the auditors are more likely to comply with the client’s preference related to financial reporting, making it difficult to conduct rigorous and consistent audits. It leads to the decrease of financial statement comparability as well as audit quality.
We also find that the empirical results are not statistically different between the subsample of Big4 and that of non-Big4 auditors, showing that more fierce audit market competition lowers financial statements comparability, regardless of a Big4 audit firm. Furthermore, we document that the negative relationship between the level of audit market competition and the financial statement comparability has been alleviated since the implementation of International Financial Reporting Standards. The main findings of this study are robust even after using alternative measures of financial statements comparability, and considering fixed effect of audit firm and client firm.
In sum, this study shows that audit market competition is one of the important factors determining the financial statement comparability. Also, by revealing the negative effect of audit market competition on financial statement comparability, which is one of the qualitative characteristics of accounting information, these results provide meaningful implications for regulatory agencies paying attention to the level of competition in the audit market.

국문 초록 (Abstract)

본 연구에서는 감사시장의 경쟁수준이 재무제표의 비교가능성에 영향을 미치는 지 살펴보았다. 회계 감사시장의 경쟁수준은 감사인의 행동에 영향을 미치는 중요한 요인 중 하나로, 과거 선행연구는 회계법인의 수로 측정한 감사시장의 경쟁이 심할수록 감사품질이 저해된다는 발견을 보고한 바 있다. 감사시장의 경쟁수준이 높다면 감사인은 피감기업을 고객으로 확보, 유지하기 위해 피감사기업의 요구에 순응할 가능성이 높아지며, 감사인의 피감기업에 대한 협상력이 약해질 것이다. 이는 감사인의 엄격하고 일관된 감사수행을 어렵게 만들어 감사의 결과물인 피감기업 재무제표의 비교가능성이 하락하는 결과를 초래할 수 있다. 본 연구는 이런 예측을 확인하기 위해 2005년부터 2018년까지 상장기업을 대상으로 11,759개의 기업-연도 관측치를 이용하여 실증분석을 수행하였다. 실증분석 결과 감사시장의 경쟁수준이 치열해질수록 재무제표의 비교가능성이 감소하는 것을 발견하였다. 또한 이러한 결과는 Big4와 non-Big4 회계법인 표본 사이에 유의한 차이가 없으며, 감사시장 경쟁수준과 재무제표 비교가능성 사이의 음(-)의 관계는 국제회계기준이 도입된 후 완화된 것으로 나타났다. 본 연구의 발견은 감사시장의 경쟁이 재무제표 비교가능성을 결정하는 중요한 요인 중 하나임을 보여주고 있으며, 감사시장 경쟁수준에 주목하고 있는 규제기관에게 중요한 시사점을 제공한다.

참고문헌 (Reference)

• 1 강민정, "회계정보의 비교가능성이 재무분석가 이익예측 및 회계정보 가치관련성에 미치는 영향에 대한 연구" 한국회계학회 38 (38): 281-320, 2013
• 2 하원석, "회계법인의 수로 측정한 감사시장의 경쟁수준과 감사품질 사이의 관계" 한국회계학회 43 (43): 159-196, 2018
• 3 조미옥, "회계법인의 수로 측정한 감사시장의 경쟁 수준이 감사보수 및 감사시간에 미치는 영향" 한국회계학회 28 (28): 189-222, 2019
• 4 조형진, "회계감사시장의 경쟁수준과 감사품질 및 감사보수 사이의 관계" 한국경영학회 43 (43): 1529-1556, 2014
• 5 양승희, "한국기업의 지배구조는 개선되었는가? : 현금보유수준 및 가치관련성 추세를 중심으로" 한국회계학회 43 (43): 101-159, 2018
• 6 기은선, "재무제표의 비교가능성과 피감기업 감사복잡성 상호작용이 감사노력에 미치는 영향" 한국회계학회 40 (40): 43-81, 2015
• 7 최승욱, "재무제표 비교가능성이 기업의 투자효율성에 미치는 영향" 한국회계학회 25 (25): 209-241, 2016
• 8 박경서, "상품시장에서의 경쟁과 기업지배구조의 상호작용이 투자와 배당에 미치는 영향" 한국재무학회 24 (24): 483-522, 2011
• 9 이명건, "산업 내 경쟁정도와 회계정보의 비교가능성" 한국산업경영학회 30 (30): 125-154, 2015
• 10 최승욱, "동일한 감사인의 고객기업간 재무제표가 서로 유사한가? 감사법인과 감사파트너를 이용한 분석" 한국회계학회 25 (25): 239-273, 2016
• 11 남혜정, "기업의 위치와 재무제표의 비교가능성" 한국공인회계사회 61 (61): 121-151, 2019
• 12 한국회계기준원, "국제회계기준 도입 로드맵"
• 13 안혜진, "경영자의 능력이 재무제표의 비교가능성에 미치는 영향" 한국회계학회 45 (45): 253-290, 2020
• 14 최승욱, "감사시장의 집중도와 감사보수, 감사시간 및 시간당감사보수 사이의 관계: Big N 회계법인을 사용한 분석" 한국공인회계사회 57 (57): 211-246, 2015
• 15 조은혜, "가치평가오류, 내부자거래와 회계정보의 비교가능성" 한국공인회계사회 60 (60): 221-260, 2018
• 16 Francis, J. R., "The role of Big 6 auditors in the credible reporting of accruals" 18 (18): 17-34, 1999
• 17 Dechow, P. M., "The quality of accruals and earnings : the role of accrual estimation errors" 77 (77): 35-59, 2002
• 18 Ghosh, A., "The impact of regulation on auditor fees : Evidence from the Sarbanes-Oxley Act" 28 (28): 171-197, 2009
• 19 Ahn, H., "The effect of audit partner style on financial statement comparability" 28 (28): 44-70, 2021
• 20 Sohn, B, "The effect of accounting comparability on the accrual-based and real earnings management" 35 (35): 513-539, 2016
• 21 De Franco, G., "The benefits of financial statement comparability" 49 (49): 895-931, 2011
• 22 Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB), "Qualitative Characteristics of Accounting Information. Statement of Financial Accounting Concepts No. 2"
• 23 Government Accountability Office (GAO), "Public Accounting Firms: Mandated Study on Consolidation and Competition" 2003
• 24 Government Accountability Office (GAO), "Public Accounting Firms: Continued Concentration in Audit Market for Large Public Companies does not Call for Immediate Action" 2008
• 25 Kothari, S. P., "Performance matched discretionary accrual measures" 39 (39): 163-197, 2005
• 26 Dedman, E., "Perceived competition, profitability and the withholding of information about sales and the cost of sales" 48 (48): 210-230, 2009
• 27 Choi, J. -H., "Measuring audit market competition with the number of auditors : A re-examination of the effect of competition on audit quality" 2019
• 28 최영수, "K - IFRS 의무도입이 동일 산업 내 비교가능성에 미치는 영향–기업지배구조 특성별 차이를 중심으로" 한국회계학회 24 (24): 235-276, 2015
• 29 Fang, X., "Financial statement comparability and loan contracting : Evidence from the syndicated loan market" 30 (30): 277-303, 2016
• 30 Kim, S., "Financial statement comparability and credit risk" 18 (18): 783-823, 2013
• 31 조정은, "Financial Statement Comparability and the Cost of Equity Capital" 한국회계학회 40 (40): 1-38, 2015
• 32 Newton, N. J., "Does a lack of choice lead to lower quality? Evidence from auditor competition and client restatements" 32 (32): 31-67, 2013
• 33 Yip, R. W. Y., "Does Mandatory IFRS Adoption Improve Information Comparability?" 87 (87): 1767-1789, 2012
• 34 Swanquist, Q., "Do clients avoid"contaminated"offices? The economic consequences of low-quality audits" 90 (90): 2537-2570, 2015
• 35 Choi, J. -H., "Did the 1998 merger of Price Waterhouse and Coopers & Lybrand increase audit quality?" 34 (34): 1071-1102, 2017
• 36 Buijink, W., "Competition in auditing: Evidence from entry, exit, and market share mobility in Germany versus the Netherlands" 15 (15): 385-404, 1998
• 37 Imhof M. J., "Comparability and cost of equity capital" 31 (31): 125-138, 2017
• 38 Carson, E., "Changes in audit market competition and the Big N premium" 31 (31): 47-73, 2012
• 39 Khurana, I., "Big four global networks, auditor industry expertise, and properties of analysts’ earnings forecasts" University of Missouri-Columbia and University of North Texas 2011
• 40 U.K. House of Lords, "Auditors: Market Concentration and Their Role. 2nd report of session 2010-2011of Select committee on economic affairs" 2011
• 41 Francis, J. R., "Auditor style and financial statement comparability" 89 (89): 605-633, 2014
• 42 Boone, J. P., "Audit market concentration and auditor tolerance for earnings management" 29 (29): 1171-1203, 2012
• 43 Kallapur, S., "Audit market concentration and audit quality" Indian School of Business 2010
• 44 Endrawes, M., "Audit committee characteristics and financial statement comparability" 60 : 2361-2395, 2020
• 45 Lennox, C., "Accounting misstatements following lawsuits against auditors" 32 : 65-93, 2014
• 46 Zhang, J, "Accounting comparability, audit effort, and audit outcomes" 35 (35): 245-276, 2018